CHAPTER TITLE Bartlett Design Research Folios
Penelope Haralambidou City of Ladies
A
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
B
BARTLETT DESIGN RESEARCH FOLIOS
Penelope Haralambidou City of Ladies
CONTENTS
1 (previous) Elevation. 2 City of Ladies installation view at Domobaal, London.
5
Project Details
6
Statement about the Research Content and Process
8
Introduction
10
Aims and Objectives
18
Questions
22
Context
24
Methodology
32
Dissemination
68
Project Highlights
68
Bibliography
74
Related Publications
75
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
Project Details Author
Penelope Haralambidou
Title
City of Ladies
Output Type
Solo exhibition
Venue and Dates
Domobaal, London (30 January to 8 February 2020)
Curators
Penelope Haralambidou with John Cruwys and Domo Baal
Project Dates
2018 to 2020
Research Assistant
John Cruwys
Manufacture The pieces were developed in collaboration with B-Made at The Bartlett School of Architecture, UCL Glassblower
Graham Reed, Jaytec Glass
Digital Film
Penelope Haralambidou (concept, original design and direction); John Cruwys (digital animation and design); Kevin Pollard (sound design)
Funding £8,915.64 The Bartlett Architecture Research Fund (ARF); £1,500 Domobaal
6
PROJECT DETAILS
3
3 Detail from the gilding process.
7
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
Statement about the Research Content and Process Description
Methodology
In The Book of the City of Ladies (1405), the medieval author Christine de Pizan describes the construction of an imaginary city, a utopia built and inhabited by women. Her work can be seen as a proto-feminist manifesto, conflating the act of building with stories of notable female figures from fiction and history, and erecting a thesis against misogyny. This cross-disciplinary project, taking the form of a solo exhibition and a refereed paper, aims to introduce Christine’s work to an architectural audience for the first time. It builds upon existing scholarship on the relationship between image and text in her work and proposes an innovative, design-led remodelling of her architectural and urban allegory, which displays the city in three stages of completion.
The primary methodology is cross- and trans-disciplinary and is design-led. It focuses on a close study of the original illuminated manuscript, Harley 4431, which was potentially written in Christine’s hand. It brings together medieval drawing with cutting-edge digital manufacturing and imaging- and time-based techniques. The research is supported by an extensive review of existing literature in Christine de Pizan studies and discussions at the biannual international conference at Université Sorbonne Nouvelle in Paris.
Dissemination
One solo exhibition, City of Ladies, at Domobaal, London; one conference paper presented at AHRA Dundee 2019; one refereed paper in the journal Architecture and Culture; one invited seminar at the Architectural Association, London; one invited keynote lecture at the Postgraduate Symposium on Research By Design: Re-appropriation and Representation at Edinburgh School of Architecture and Landscape Architecture; and one invited lecture and exhibition at the experimental drawing festival Cartographies of the Imagination, London.
Questions
1. What is the architectural significance of Christine’s thinking and iconography? 2. How can a design-led methodology reveal the underlying architectural themes in Christine’s text and analyse the architectural motifs in her illuminations? 3. Can a remodelling of Christine’s book/city provide an impetus for a contemporary feminist re-evaluation of the future of the city?
8
STATEMENT ABOUT THE RESEARCH CONTENT AND PROCESS
Project Highlights
The research is significant as it is the first study linking Christine de Pizan’s work with architecture. Christine’s proposal for the construction of an allegorical city to protect women from misogyny, and its iconographic representation in three stages of construction, suggests her to be an early female/feminist speculative architect; yet, her work remains almost entirely unknown in the field of architecture. Beyond architecture, the research is also significant in the field of French and medieval studies, as it provides a novel lens through which the iconographic programme of Christine’s book can be evaluated. Finally, the design-led analytical and creative investigation, which marries medieval drawing techniques with digital modelling and film, constitutes a methodological innovation in both disciplines.
9
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
Introduction
I am interested in the under-researched architectural and urban allegory depicted in the text and the accompanying illuminations (4–5) – a manuscript’s miniature illustration made using silver, gold and bright mineral colours, the name of which derives from the Latin illuminare (to light up) – that imagine a utopia constructed and inhabited solely by women.
The female sex has been left for a long time now, like an orchard without a wall, and bereft of a champion to take up arms in order to protect it. … For this reason, we three ladies whom you see before you have been moved by pity to tell you that you are to construct a building in the shape of a walled city, sturdy and impregnable. … You alone of all women have been granted the honour of building the City of Ladies. In order to lay the foundations, you shall draw fresh water from us three as from a clear spring. We will bring you building materials which will be stronger and more durable, than solid, uncemented marble. Your city will be unparalleled in splendor and will last for all eternity. (Christine de Pizan 1404) With these words, the Italian/French medieval author Christine de Pizan is commissioned to construct a walled city in order to protect the female sex from misogyny. The three ‘ladies’ who commission her are the allegorical female figures Reason, Rectitude and Justice. Christine describes their visitation, and fictional architectural commission, in her celebrated text The Book of the City of Ladies (1404). Each virtue takes a turn in one of three chapters to educate Christine about the achievements of great women throughout history – queens, artists, scholars, warriors, saints – while directing and assisting her in the gradual allegorical construction of a city. The Book of the City of Ladies is seen as a proto-feminist manifesto, correlating the act of writing a book that defends women with the construction of an imaginary defensive city. Although widely studied in terms of its literary significance,
10
INTRODUCTION
4
4 Harley 4431, The Book of the City of Ladies, chapter two illumination. 5 Harley 4431, The Book of the City of Ladies, chapter three illumination.
11
5
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
Alongside historical research, this speculative project explores Christine’s allegorical spatial scheme through a unique design-led methodology, an embodied act of drawing that combines medieval drawing techniques on vellum with digital craft and film. The research culminated in an exhibition featuring an installation and a digital film, which spatially and materially reconstructed Christine’s book and reframed her message in an architectural context while also projecting her allegorical city of ladies into the future. Born in Venice in 1364, Christine moved to Paris as a young child when her father joined the court of King Charles V as a royal consultant. She was married at 14 and had three children. Christine decided to take up writing professionally at the age of 25 in order to support her family after the sudden death of both her father and husband. Between 1401 and 1404 she instigated the Quarrel of the ‘Romance of the Rose’, where she protested against the misogyny of the popular French poem, insisting that it was slanderous to women. Her resulting notoriety led to commissioned work and was the trigger for her decision to embark on an authored text, The Book of the City of Ladies, with the main purpose to portray women more positively. The specific version of the text that this project examines is part of Harley 4431, a compilation that Christine assembled for Queen Isabeau of Bavaria between 1410 and 1414 (7). It is one of the most important manuscripts held at the British Library since its foundation as part of the British Museum in 1753.
This research develops the theme of architectural representation in medieval manuscripts explored in two earlier projects by the author: With-drawing Room on Vellum (2016) and Between the Retina and the Dome (2018) (8–9). Both of these projects/drawings link history with design research to consider the impact of digital technology on architectural representation. They combine medieval drawing materials and illumination techniques with digital film and projection.
6 Digital models of the illuminations at the beginning of the three chapters.
12
INTRODUCTION
6
13
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
14
INTRODUCTION
7 Harley 4431, frontispiece showing Christine offering the book to Queen Isabeau of Bavaria. 8 (overleaf) With-drawing Room on Vellum, 2016. 7
9 (overleaf) Between the Retina and the Dome, 2018.
15
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
8
16
INTRODUCTION
9
17
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
Aims and Objectives
It does so by employing an innovative methodology, which develops existing research on the relationship between text and image in Christine’s work but from an architectural design perspective.
The main objective of the research is to establish the literary and iconographic significance of Christine de Pizan’s The Book of the City of Ladies for the history, practice and education of architecture. The research positions Christine’s imaginative speculative design within architectural history for the first time, presenting her work as an early example of female spatial imagination and perhaps the earliest visual representation of a feminist utopia. Widely celebrated as the first French female professional author, this research also aims to establish Christine as an early female/feminist speculative architect, and one of the first proto-feminist thinkers, through a close study of the design of the architectural illustrations adorning her text. The project aims to use Christine’s work to underpin an appraisal of the importance of female authorship in shaping the image of the city. Although written and illustrated more than 600 years ago, Christine’s message continues to be topical and prescient. Positioned in parallel to the real constructed city, her allegory can shine new light onto female values, measures, modes of design, structures of power and urban life, which can influence policy. Inspired by and in support of initiatives and events that attempt to remember and define the female contribution to the built environment, The Book of the City of Ladies can begin to inform architectural pedagogy and motivate urban futures from a female perspective by claiming Christine’s work for architecture. The project aims to establish a pioneering area of scholarship that brings together medieval studies with architecture and medieval architectural history with design.
18
AIMS AND OBJECTIVES
10
10 Gallery installation, close view of Justice.
19
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
20
AIMS AND OBJECTIVES
11
11 Domobaal installation view.
21
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
Questions
equitable, dignified and visionary urban futures that cater for the needs and desires of both genders? What is the role and value of the female spatial imagination and female architectural drawing practices in the production and perception of architectural and urban design? Christine’s desire for women to shape the image of the allegorical city 600 years ago remains largely unfulfilled. What will our cities look like in the next 600 years and how much will women be involved in shaping them?
1. What is the architectural significance of Christine’s thinking and iconography?
What is the historical significance of architectural motifs in medieval illumination? How do they operate as framing devices for narrative structures and for organising different parts of the text on the page? What is their historical value in depicting everyday scenes and construction techniques?
2. How can a design-led methodology reveal the underlying architectural themes in Christine’s text and analyse the architectural motifs in her illuminations?
Can a hybrid drawing technique discover underlying hidden meaning in her use of imagery by bringing together vellum – recalling the forgotten, visceral past – and digital projection – expressing the uncertain evanescent future of architectural representation? How can an embodied act of drawing perform as practice-led historical research? Can contemporary digital drawing and immersive environmental technologies empower a female vision of the city of the future?
3. Can a remodelling of Christine’s book/city provide an impetus for a contemporary feminist re-evaluation of the future of the city?
What is the significance of the allegory of the city as a metaphor for writing and the construction of a thesis against misogyny? Can a revisiting of the visual metaphors in Christine’s text help trigger women’s desire to draw the city and propose more sustainable,
22
QUESTIONS
12
12 Early sketch arrangement of exhibition.
23
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
Context Design-led research in architecture
This research project fits within the context of my previous practice-led, cross- and transdisciplinary work, which incorporates architectural design with history and theory. Directly employing the tools of the architect – drawing, model making and digital film – I have analysed ideas and work, not only in architecture but also in visual representation, the history of architectural drawing, the politics of vision, fine art and cinema. This methodology is exemplified in my monograph Marcel Duchamp and the Architecture of Desire (Haralambidou 2013), a design-led investigation of French artist Marcel Duchamp’s work, which adds to but also challenges other art historical analyses. Two recent research drawings relating to this project, Between the Retina and the Dome (9) and With-drawing Room on Vellum (8), were presented at Works + Words 2019, 2nd Biennale for Artistic Research in Architecture, at the Royal Danish Academy (17). These were subsequently published in The Artful Plan: Architectural Drawing Reconfigured (2020). Using creative design that employs drawing and model making to perform a feminist re-reading of architectural history resonates with the work of Slovenian artist Jasmina Cibic, who works in film, sculpture, performance and installation to explore ‘soft power’: how political rhetoric is deployed through art and architecture (13). It also resonates with Emma Cheatle, who in her book Part-Architecture: The Maison de Verre, Duchamp, Domesticity and Desire in 1930s Paris (2016) combines theory, creative writing and drawing to trace the history of the spaces and sexuality of Marcel Duchamp’s The Large Glass (1923) and Pierre Chareau’s Maison de Verre (1932) (14–5).
24
CONTEXT
13
14
13 Jasmina Cibic, Nada: Act I, 2016. 14-5 Emma Cheatle, Part-Architecture, 2016.
25
15
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
16
16 Penelope Haralambidou, The Blossoming of Perspective, Domobaal, 2007.
26
CONTEXT
17
17 Works + Words 2019, 2nd Biennale for Artistic Research in Architecture, Royal Danish Academy.
27
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
Medieval studies
By focusing on the iconography of architectural representation of the city in the illuminations, the project builds upon existing research in medieval studies on the relationship between text and image in Christine’s work. Among the most important: Charlotte Cooper, ‘A re-assessment of textimage relationships in Christine de Pizan’s didactic works’ (unpublished PhD thesis); Sandra L. Hindman, Christine de Pizan’s ‘Epistre Othea’: Painting and Politics at the Court of Charles VI (1986); Marilynn Desmond and Pamela Sheingorn, Myth, Montage, and Visuality in Late Medieval Manuscript Culture (2003); and Millard Meiss, French Painting in the Time of Jean De Berry: The Limbourgs and Their Contemporaries (1974).
18
Fine art
Although focusing on the architectural allegory, the work – an installation and a film presented in a gallery – can also be positioned in a fine art context, especially in relation to feminist artworks inspired by the work of Christine de Pizan. For instance, Judy Chicago’s The Dinner Party (1974–9) is an important icon of feminist art, comprised of a triangular table with 39 place settings, each commemorating an important woman from history (19). One of the place settings is for Christine and references her ‘collecting’ of renowned women’s stories (18). Similar to Chicago’s work, this research uses a table in a triadic formation, albeit much smaller in scale and analytical rather than representational.
18-9 Judy Chicago, The Dinner Party, 1974–9.
28
CONTEXT
19
29
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
A more recent example of an artwork inspired by Christine is Tai Shani’s DC: Semiramis (2019), which explores mythical and real women in an expanded performative adaptation of The Book of the City of Ladies (20). Shani uses ‘the structure of an allegorical city of women to explore “feminine” subjectivity and experience, through a gothic/sciencefiction lens’ (Tate 2019). Shani’s work involves the creation of sets and performances based on the narrated stories of women in Christine’s text. Although this research project includes an element of playful performance, the focus is on the design of the architectural motifs and themes in Christine’s text and not on the storytelling.
and Parlour, and through numerous publications, events and exhibitions. The study of Christine enriches these efforts to trace a distinct lineage for the female architectural imagination by providing an early example of a desire to construct the city.
History of female architectural design
Although extensively examined in French and medieval studies, Christine’s work remains overlooked, if not completely unknown, in architectural history and design. Her primary aim when writing The Book of the City of Ladies was to commemorate, celebrate and preserve details of exceptional women’s lives, talents and endeavours, while also putting across a wish for the creation of a city that reflects female values. It is, therefore, astonishing that even today, more than 600 years later, her message is still topical. Her wish for an all-female city is still unfulfilled. The main objective of this research is to remember and establish Christine as an early female/feminist speculative architect. The project and its dissemination belong to a context of similar initiatives that work to bring hitherto forgotten female thinkers, designers and architects to the foreground. This work began in the 1970s and continues today, through collectives such as Women in Architecture, Part W, Voices of Experience
30
CONTEXT
20
20 Tai Shani, DC: Semiramis, 2018.
31
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
Methodology
The research employs an embodied act of drawing and making of a series of artefacts, which combine medieval illumination drawing techniques with digital craft and film to directly respond to the iconographic content of Christine’s work.
The primary methodology is design-led research that culminated in an exhibition, City of Ladies at Domobaal in London. The exhibition featured an installation and a digital film that spatially and materially reconstruct the three illuminations and imagine the pictorial city blossoming from two dimensions into three. The work claims Christine’s message for architecture and is in search of a way to project it into the future. Although it culminates in a composition of finished pieces, the artefacts should not be seen as complete outputs but as design experiments that attempt to interpret Christine’s ideas and iconographic arrangement. The analysis was based on a close study of the recently digitised manuscript at the British Library and two versions of the English translation of the text. The research builds upon Album Christine de Pizan (2012) by Gilbert Ouy, Christine McArdle Reno and Inès VillelaPetit, which studies the composition of the manuscripts and offers significant new information on the illuminators collaborating with Christine. My research has led to a more detailed analysis of the overall architectural composition and decorative motifs in the manuscript, specifically the city-building illuminations.
1. Gilding on vellum
Manuscripts were handwritten and illuminated on sheets of vellum, an extremely durable writing and drawing surface made out of animal skin, which was also used for architectural drawing at the time. Each chapter frontispiece is produced on a whole skin of vellum, obtained from the last remaining manufacturer in the UK, William Cowley Parchment Makers. The vellum skins become drawing surfaces that carry important diagrams relating to selected themes in the book and markings for the positioning of other elements. Their pure white surface is decorated in a painstaking process of gilding, following medieval techniques using silver, gold and white gold leaf (22).
21 Sketchbook 02, gilding pattern development.
32
METHODOLOGY
21
33
METHODOLOGY
2. Design and construction of tables
Resembling tablecloths or place mats, the vellum skins lie on three specially designed tables supported by slender wooden legs. The table-top design was developed in direct reference to the shape of the three skins, so that they can be arranged radially forming a larger composite raised surface (24–5). Each table is named after one of the three virtues, and their surface is covered in different colours of furniture linoleum: Reason (4185 powder), Rectitude (4183 pistachio) and Justice (4177 vapour).
23
22 Gallery installation detail, gilding. 23 Sketchbook 02, development of the table arrangement.
35
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
24
24 Table design iterations.
36
METHODOLOGY
25
25 Testing the arrangement of the tables.
37
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
3. Crystal-glass half domes
A group of six crystal domes in three different diameters operate as paper weights to keep each vellum skin in place on the table (26–7). As a living material, vellum has a tendency to expand, contract and curl depending on environmental temperature and humidity levels. The positions of the crystal domes are decided after observing the natural movements of the material to form an overall composition, dictated by the gilding, but they can also be re-arranged at will. The domes work like magnifying lenses highlighting the drawings on the vellum.
26 Gilding marks organising the positioning of the crystal domes on the vellum. 27 Gallery installation view (detail).
38
METHODOLOGY
26
27
39
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
4. Translation of the illuminations into three miniature 3D-printed models
The illuminations showing the city under construction use a distorted projection system that does not obey linear perspective – a technique that would later be invented in Renaissance Italy. To enter the figurative space of the city, the illusory depth depicted in the illuminations was decoded and fleshed out into three dimensions, following a design process in reverse. The pre-linear perspective was translated into digital models as accurately as possible. These were then 3D printed at the same scale. The miniature models, supported by rough blocks of wood representing the columns of text that the illuminations crown, become nuclei of a city not yet built (28).
28
28 Models are supported by wooden towers/bases. 29 Rearranging the crystal domes.
40
METHODOLOGY
29
41
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
30 Development of the digital models. Handdrawn marks on printed digital drawings.
42
METHODOLOGY
30
43
METHODOLOGY
32
31 The printed models are placed on 1:1-scale printouts of the manuscript pages. 32 Different views of the three models.
45
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
5. Significance and construction of the three artefacts
Self-knowledge and recognition of the value of the female point of view literally and metaphorically become the basis of the conception of a new female city. Relating it to body parts, the mirror is equivalent to the face or the head. Reason’s table thus becomes a ‘dressing table’.
A key part of the research involved the interpretation of three symbolic objects, which the virtues offer to Christine as measuring and material standards guiding the metaphorical construction of the female city. This resulted in the design and construction of three artefacts: a mirror, ruler and a measuring vessel (33). The development of the design of these artefacts occurred in conjunction with the research for my AHRA 2019 conference paper ‘The Female Body Politic: Re-modelling The Book of the City of Ladies’, which explores the city as a body.
The Mirror of Reason Reason brings a mirror as a device for measuring self-knowledge and -worth, which she suggests Christine will need to plan the city. The translation of this metaphorical artefact is a table-top mirror (38). It portrays binocular vision as an alternative visual matrix embedded in the body, a female vision against the male sharpness of linear perspective and an instrument to help plan the form of the city. The surface of the proposed mirror is made out of polished metal, as most were in medieval times. The geometry of the surface references the horopter – a geometrical surface describing the binocular picture plane – and is held in place by two large ball bearings referencing the eyeballs, which carry slender steel wires representing the visual rays. It is held by a wooden base made out of machined walnut that also references the visual perceptual system; more specifically, the optical chiasma (37). 33
46
METHODOLOGY
34
33 Digital models of the Mirror of Reason, Ruler of Rectitude and Vessel of Justice.
34 Sketchbook 02, development of the table arrangement.
47
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
35
35 Sketchbook 02, development of the base of the mirror.
48
METHODOLOGY
36
38
37
36 Digital model of the base of the mirror. 37 Machining the base of the mirror in walnut.
38 Final mirror with polished metal surface.
49
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
The Ruler of Rectitude Rectitude holds a ruler, a yardstick of truth that separates right from wrong, which she insists Christine should use to design the interior of the city and its high temples, palaces, houses, roads, squares and marketplaces. In the history of measurement, many distance units are based on human body parts such as the cubit, the fathom and the foot, with variations in length by era and location. One aspect, however, has been constant: they always refer to the male body, as does the name of the measuring instrument, e.g. ‘ruler’ (king). The interpretation of the ruler here is a direct imprint of female hands, specifically the hands of the author. The ruler was derived from a complex process of physically casting hands in ink-tinted plaster (39–40). The casts were then used to create a digital model through photogrammetry, and alternating units of fingers were then arranged to the length of a French ell (aune) used to measure cloth. The resulting model of concave imprints was machined into a piece of pear wood (41). The ruler points to a city that is made for female bodies and their needs. Obviously relating to hands, Rectitude’s table thus becomes a ‘drawing table’.
39
40
50
METHODOLOGY
41
39 Alginate mould. 40 Tinted plaster casts of hands. 41 ‘The ruler fits like a glove’.
51
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
42
42 Linear arrangement options.
52
METHODOLOGY
43
43 Machining path.
53
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
The Vessel of Justice Justice offers Christine a vessel of gold, a container measuring weight or volume that is able to calculate and distribute fortune for each individual. She suggests that Christine will use it to embellish the high turrets and roofs of the completed buildings, and will adorn the city with gold. I see the vessel as a gauge of female values. My interpretation is a complex glass-blown form comprised of two interlocking chambers resembling splitting cells (44–6). A hybrid between an hourglass and a double pitcher, the vessel is able to measure time through mass, promoting long-term thinking that is often absent in design. Sitting on a base machined in lime wood, the vessel decants its timekeeping white-marble sand on designated areas of the vellum. It is an ingesting and gestating abdomen, and its presence on Justice’s table makes this a ‘dining table’.
44
44 Final glass-blown vessel. 45 Sketchbook 01, design of vessel. 46 Early 3D model of the vessel.
54
METHODOLOGY
45
46
55
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
56
METHODOLOGY
48
47 Gallery installation view, the Vessel of Justice.
47
48 Machining the limewood base for the vessel..
57
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
6. Digital film
In direct dialogue with the installation, which performs a historical reading of the medieval artefact of the book, the film attempts to project Christine’s ideas into the far future (50). Developed in collaboration with John Cruwys and Kevin Pollard, the film catches a glimpse of the allegorical genesis of the three artefacts, the mirror, ruler and vessel, which leads to the conception and gestation of the City of Ladies. Using visual and sonic tropes from science fiction films, it creates an ambiguous spatial voyage moving from the interior of the body to outer space and back to the present moment in the gallery.
49 Sketchbook 01, planning the film scenes.
58
METHODOLOGY
49
59
METHODOLOGY
7. Performance
The artefacts and glass half domes, and their positions on the vellum, have been designed so that they can be moved into different locations and configurations like pawns on a game board. A performance around the installation involves the setting of the tables and the ceremonial repositioning of the artefacts (52–3).
51
50 Digital film stills. 51 Gallery installation view with film. 52-3 (overview) Film stills from the performance, rearranging the artefacts.
61
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
8. Literature review
An expansive literature review of historical and theoretical research relating to Christine, primarily The Book of the City of Ladies and the relationship between writing and image in her work (54). This research also looked at a second book, Christine’s The Book of the Body Politic (1407), where she attempts to describe the underlying structure of medieval collective life.
54 Harley 4431, The Book of the City of Ladies, chapter one illumination.
66
METHODOLOGY
54
67
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
Dissemination
Project Highlights
·
This research project is significant because it introduces for the very first time the literary and iconographic importance of Christine de Pizan’s The Book of the City of Ladies to the history, practice and education of architecture. To date, it is the only study of the architectural implications of Christine’s allegory and iconographic construction, presenting her work as one of the earliest examples of female spatial imagination and visual representation of a feminist utopia. Although recognised in Medieval and French studies as the first female professional author, and one of the earliest proto-feminist thinkers, this novel analysis of her oeuvre aims to also establish Christine as an early, if not the first, female/feminist speculative architect. Although written and illustrated more than 600 years ago, The Book of the City of Ladies continues to be topical and prescient. By exposing Christine’s work to an architectural audience, it underpins the importance of female authorship in shaping the image of the city and also the persistent lack of it throughout history. By claiming Christine’s work for architecture, the project aims to inform architectural pedagogy, impact ‘the desire for the city’ and ‘the formation of the urban imagination’ of young female architects, and motivate urban futures from a female perspective. Finally, the project is also significant for medieval and French studies. It contributes a pioneering design-led methodology that develops existing research on the relationship between text and image in Christine’s work from an entirely new architectural design perspective.
·
·
·
·
· · ·
·
·
·
·
One solo exhibition, City of Ladies, at Domobaal, London (2020); One group exhibition, Works + Words 2019, 2nd Biennale for Artistic Research in Architecture, Royal Danish Academy, which included an accompanying leaflet; One conference paper, ‘The Female Body Politic: Re-modelling The Book of the City of Ladies’, presented at AHRA Dundee 2019: Architecture & Collective Life; One refereed paper (approx. 6,000 words), ‘The Female Body Politic: Enacting the Architecture of The Book of the City of Ladies’, published in the journal Architecture & Culture (2020); One book chapter in Drawing Futures: Speculations for Contemporary Art and Architecture; Review of the exhibition published by The Conversation; A short paper for Architectural Research Quarterly; Invited seminar at the Architectural Association in London to present ‘The Female Body Politic: Re-modelling The Book of the City of Ladies’; Invited lecture and exhibition at the experimental drawing festival, Cartographies of the Imagination (postponed due to Covid-19); Keynote lecture at Postgraduate Symposium on Research by Design: Re-appropriation and Representation, Edinburgh School of Architecture and Landscape Architecture, University of Edinburgh (2020); Forthcoming review in The Journal of Architecture by Teresa Stoppani, Doreen Bernath and George Themistokleous (2021); Forthcoming interview with Nicholas James for CV/Visual Arts Research.
68
DISSEMINATION / PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS
55
56
55-7 (overleaf) Domobaal opening.
69
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
57
58 Gallery installation view, close-up of model.
70
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
59
59–60 Gallery installation view.
72
DISSEMINATION / PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS
60
73
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
Bibliography
Hindman, S. L. (1986). Christine de Pizan’s Epistre Othéa: Painting and Politics at the Court of Charles VI. Toronto: Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies. Langdon Forhan, K. (2002). The Political Theory of Christine de Pizan. Aldershot: Ashgate. Lovett, P. (2015). Illumination, Gold and Colour. London: L. Cornelissen & Son. Margolis, N. (2012). An Introduction to Christine de Pizan. Gainesville: University Press of Florida. Meiss, M. (1974). French Painting in the Time of Jean De Berry: The Limbourgs and Their Contemporaries. New York: George Braziller Inc. Ouy, G. (2012). Album Christine de Pizan. Turnhout: Brepols Publishers. Quilligan, M. (1992). The Allegory of Female Authority: Christine de Pizan’s “Cité Des Dames”. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. Tate (2019). ‘Turner Prize 2019: Tai Shani’. Tate. [Viewed 14 October 2020]. www.tate.org.uk/whats-on/turnercontemporary/exhibition/turnerprize-2019/tai-shani
Altmann, B. K. and McGrady, D. L. (2003). Christine de Pizan: A Casebook. London: Routledge. Cheatle, E. (2017). Part-Architecture: The Maison de Verre, Duchamp, Domesticity and Desire in 1930s Paris. London: Routledge. Cibic, J. (2018). ‘Everything that You Desire and Nothing that You Fear’. Jasmina Cibic. [Viewed 14 October 2020]. https://jasminacibic.org/projects/ everything-that-you-desire-and-nothingthat-you-fear/ Cooper, C. (2017). A Re-Assessment of Text-Image Relationships in Christine de Pizan’s Didactic Works. PhD thesis. University of Oxford. de Pizan, C. (1998). The Book of the City of Ladies. Richards, E. J. trans. New York: Persea. de Pizan, C. (1999). The Book of the City of Ladies. Brown-Grant, R. trans. London: Penguin. de Pizan, C. (2007). The Book of the Body Politic. Langdon Forhan, K. trans. and ed. Cambridge University Press. Desmond, M. and Sheingorn, P. (2003). Myth, Montage, and Visuality in Late Medieval Manuscript Culture: Christine de Pizan’s Epistre Othea. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. Enders, J. (1994). ‘The Feminist Mnemonics of Christine de Pizan’. Modern Language Quarterly. 55 (3). pp. 231–49. Haralambidou, P. (2013). Marcel Duchamp and the Architecture of Desire. London: Routledge. Haralambidou, P. (2020). ‘Unveiling the Matrix of Architectural Drawing’. Hougaard, A., Muller, A. and Soberg, M. eds. The Artful Plan: Architectural Drawing Reconfigured. Basel: Birkhauser.
74
BIBLIOGRAPHY / RELATED PUBLICATIONS
Related Publications by the Researchers Haralambidou, P. (2020). ‘The Female Body Politic: Enacting the Architecture of The Book of the City of Ladies’. Architecture and Culture. pp. 1–22. Haralambidou, P. (2016). ‘With-drawing Room on Vellum: The Persistent Vanishing of the Architectural Drawing Surface’. Allen, L. and Pearson, L. eds. Drawing Futures: Speculations for Contemporary Art and Architecture. London: UCL Press. pp. 82–9. Haralambidou, P. (2019). ‘Between the Retina and the Dome’. Bertram, P., Capetillo, C., Anders, A. and Pind, A. eds. Works + Words 2019: 2nd Biennale for Artistic Research in Architecture. The Royal Danish Academy of Fine Arts. Haralambidou, P. (2020). ‘The Female Body Politic: Re-modelling The Book of the City of Ladies’. The PhD Research Programme at the Architectural Association.
Related Writings by Others Cooper-Davis, C. (2020). ‘City of Ladies: Modern Artists are Redefining a 15th-Century Call to Arms by An Early French Feminist’. The Conversation. 8 July. Domobaal (2020). ‘Penelope Haralambidou: City of Ladies’. Domobaal.
Printed article
Online article (clickable link)
75
PENELOPE HARALAMBIDOU
CITY OF LADIES
Image Credits
Bartlett Design Research Folios
All images © Penelope Haralambidou, unless otherwise stated.
ISSN 2753-9822
1, 6, 24, 30, 33, 36, 40, 42–3, 45, 50, 56–7
drawing, modelling and animation: John Cruwys 2, 10–1, 16, 22, 27, 47, 51, 59–60 Photo: Andy Keate 4–5, 7, 54 British Library 13 © Jasmina Cibic 2016; Photo: Richard-Max Tremblay 14–5 © Emma Cheatle 17 Photo: Søren Svendsen 18–9 Elizabeth A. Sackler Center for Feminist Art, Collection of the Brooklyn Museum; © Judy Chicago 20 © Tai Shani 55 Photo: Jan Kattein
© 2022 The Bartlett School of Architecture. All rights reserved.
Digital
Text © the authors Founder of the series and lead editor: Yeoryia Manolopoulou Edited by Yeoryia Manolopoulou, Barbara Penner, Phoebe Adler Picture researcher: Sarah Bell Additional project management: Srijana Gurung Graphic design: Objectif Layout and typesetting: Siâron Hughes Every effort has been made to trace the copyright holders of the material reproduced in this publication. If there have been any omissions, we will be pleased to make appropriate acknowledgement in revised editions.
BARTLETT DESIGN RESEARCH FOLIOS
2022 SERIES
Design for Learning AY Architects
Poikilokydric Living Marcos Cruz
Life of Clay Guan Lee
Audialsense Paul Bavister
Warsaw Karowa Bridge DKFS Architects
Flood House Matthew Butcher
Photosynthetic Architecture ecoLogicStudio
Digital Manual Guan Lee, Daniel Widrig
Instruments Nine and Ten Nat Chard Coworking Spaces Izaskun Chinchilla Architects Organic Growth Pavilion Izaskun Chinchilla Architects TransDisciplinary PostDigital FrAgility Marjan Colletti + REX|LAB
Discrete Timber Architecture Gilles Retsin LA Futures Smout Allen
Kew House Tim Lucas
Infractus Smout Allen
Losing Myself Yeoryia Manolopoulou, Níall McLaughlin
A Register of User Adaptations Storp Weber Architects
Oxford Projects Níall McLaughlin Architects
Uncovering Casa Sperimentale Storp Weber Architects
High Street Regeneration Jan Kattein Architects
Funicular del Tibidabo Miàs Architects
Oxford North Jonathan Kendall
The Cloud Miàs Architects
Cork Construction Oliver Wilton, Matthew Barnett Howland
Hakka Cultural Park Christine Hawley, Abigail Ashton, Andrew Porter, Moyang Yang
Alga(e)zebo mam
55/02 sixteen*(makers)
Chong Qing Nan Lu Towers mam
Envirographic and Techno Natures Smout Allen
City of Ladies Penelope Haralambidou Discrete Methods for Spatial Robotic Extrusion Manuel Jiménez García, Gilles Retsin
Playing the Picturesque You + Pea
2015 SERIES
Bloom Alisa Andrasek, José Sanchez House of Flags AY Architects Montpelier Community Nursery AY Architects Design for London Peter Bishop 2EmmaToc / Writtle Calling Matthew Butcher, Melissa Appleton River Douglas Bridge DKFS Architects Open Cinema Colin Fournier, Marysia Lewandowska The ActiveHouse Stephen Gage Déjà vu Penelope Haralambidou Urban Collage Christine Hawley
House Refurbishment in Carmena Izaskun Chinchilla Architects Refurbishment of Garcimuñoz Castle Izaskun Chinchilla Architects Gorchakov’s Wish Kreider + O’Leary Video Shakkei Kreider + O’Leary Megaframe Dirk Krolikowski (Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners) Seasons Through the Looking Glass CJ Lim Agropolis mam
ProtoRobotic FOAMing mam, Grymsdyke Farm, REX|LAB Banyoles Old Town Refurbishment Miàs Architects Torre Baró Apartment Building Miàs Architects Alzheimer’s Respite Centre Níall McLaughlin Architects Bishop Edward King Chapel Níall McLaughlin Architects Block N15 Façade, Olympic Village Níall McLaughlin Architects
Hydrological Infrastructures Smout Allen Lunar Wood Smout Allen Universal Tea Machine Smout Allen British Exploratory Land Archive Smout Allen, Geoff Manaugh 101 Spinning Wardrobe Storp Weber Architects Blind Spot House Storp Weber Architects
Regeneration of Birzeit Historic Centre Palestine Regeneration Team
Green Belt Movement Teaching and Learning Pavilion Patrick Weber
PerFORM Protoarchitecture Lab
Modulating Light and Views Patrick Weber