Talk:Raiden Shogun/GA1
GA Review
GA toolbox |
---|
Reviewing |
Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Reviewer: Bluecrystal004 (talk · contribs) 01:32, 23 December 2023 (UTC)
I can take a look at this one during the holidays! Ping me here or on Discord after 7 days if I haven't posted a review. ~Bluecrystal004 (talk · contribs) 01:32, 23 December 2023 (UTC)
Stability -
- Reviewed this version
Copyright/images -
- Earwig
- The infobox image rationale still talks about the game's cover art, instead of the character art
- Raiden Shogun Cooking Meme.png
- Non-replaceable: the rationale doesn't actually justify why this isn't replaceable with an image of the same encyclopedic value
- Minimal use: makes mention of MiHoYo, but not the copyright holder listed in the rationale template, which is Kitchen Nightmares
Infobox -
Lead -
- ...of the game's Inazuma setting. - maybe "region" is a clearer word
- ...they originally act as... -> ...she originally acts as... because she's the subject of this sentence (She consists of...)
- She has also been discussed in regards to some of the better and worst aspects of the game's story - I don't actually know at all what this is intended to mean
- ...though with some criticisms of its own... - at least remove "of its own" which doesn't make sense, possibly something like ...but there has been criticism aimed at...
Conception and creation -
- ...both were built around the game's "Electro" element... - what is "both"?
- ...bluish purple hair that forms a long hair down her back... - should be rephrased from "forms a long hair"
- ...she portrayed the "Shogun" aspect "cold and unemotional, but not emotionless" and "not a robot". - add "as" between "aspect" and the quotes
Appearances -
- The actual "Baal" is revealed to be Raiden Shogun... - not the actual Baal, but the fake Baal
- ...after attempting to chooses to adopt... - grammatical error, probably removing "to chooses" is best
- ...decides to repeal her policies, adoption a more forward-thinking governance... - adoption -> adopting
- ...obtained by inviting to a card duel... - inviting her
- "make her sound like a Queen from nowhere in particular." - prefer paraphrasing this quote
Promotion and reception -
- ...a polearm called "Engulfing Lightning," to acquire. - the "to acquire" is ungrammatical, I assume it means players could explore her story and get her weapon; maybe along with allowing players to obtain...
- Might be good to mention when she was released as a playable character
- ...comments followed regarding her animations, in particular her sword draw animation where the blade is manifested from her exposed cleavage, with mixed reactions. - I would suggest moving the "with mixed reactions" up to replace the start, something like After her reveal trailer, mixed reactions followed regarding her animations, ...
- ...her inability to cook, resulting resulted in... - rm doubled word
- "one of the most realistic portrayals of grief that I have seen in years." - prefer paraphrasing of this quote
- The paper Preliminary study into the Genshin impact's aesthetics... - paper title should be in quotes not italics
- ...suggested that large breasts "sensual figure" were designed to play a large part of her appeal... - kind of doesn't make sense, maybe removing either "large breasts" or "sensual figure" will make more sense?
- ...within that country... - redundant, remove
- In September 2021, a week after Raiden Shogun was released, - was it in the whole month, or a week after her release?
- ...far exceeding the monthly revenue in August. - the game's total monthly revenue?
- In March, 2022, the Shogun's banner saw a rerun... - does "the Shogun" refer to Raiden Shogun? It seems an unusual phrasing but not wrong I guess
References -
- Keep in mind I'm using machine translations for some of the sources in Chinese which might complicate things
Spotcheck part 1, this version of the article
- 1a -
Go with something secondary (not an interview) to establish who the VA is, I found this source
Done
- 4a -
- 2c -
the source isn't English so quoting the word "nostalgic" isn't appropriate, I think
Done
- 6b -
do you have a scan of this issue (looks like it originally was on zhwiki)? There's a lot of info sourced to it
- 10 -
it mentions that she has this Chakra Desiderata but seems like synthesis/OR to say that this reflects design elements from the god Raijin
Done
- 3b -
move this up to ...Park Ji-yoon in Korean. which is the only relevant fact it mentions
Done
Spotcheck, part 2 this version of the article
- 14a -
- 18 -
I'm not seeing any of the previous section supported by this article. I suppose citing the game itself is fine
- 19 -
- 25 -
also doesn't seem to support the sentence at all, but the other source does
- 29 -
fine at its core but I think "took particular delight in" and "significant" are sort of laying it on thick
- 5c -
the quote should be "absolute leader", not "absolute ruler"
- 39b -
@Kung Fu Man: My initial thoughts are here; I'll do a source spotcheck within the next couple days. ~Bluecrystal004 (talk · contribs) 20:32, 29 December 2023 (UTC)
- @Bluecrystal004: Addressed what I could. I'm hoping the image rationale is satisfactory now to boot.--Kung Fu Man (talk) 21:30, 29 December 2023 (UTC)
- @Kung Fu Man: Sorry for the wait, wow! Spotcheck parts 1 and 2 are posted, still let me know about that pash article otherwise I guess I can just assume good faith on the zhwiki editor who cited it. Everything else from the review was addressed, I think. ~Bluecrystal004 (talk · contribs) 02:00, 5 January 2024 (UTC)
- @Bluecrystal004: I should have everything fixed. The Pash article I don't have, but there's a translation of it here in this reddit thread, pages 6 and 7. Lemme know how everything looks!--Kung Fu Man (talk) 07:17, 5 January 2024 (UTC)
- @Kung Fu Man I made some fixes and I removed a line which I couldn't find reference to in the Pash source, feel free to modify if I got anything wrong. Should be fine to pass this now, thanks for your work on this article! ~Bluecrystal004 (talk · contribs) 08:08, 6 January 2024 (UTC)
- @Bluecrystal004: I should have everything fixed. The Pash article I don't have, but there's a translation of it here in this reddit thread, pages 6 and 7. Lemme know how everything looks!--Kung Fu Man (talk) 07:17, 5 January 2024 (UTC)
- @Kung Fu Man: Sorry for the wait, wow! Spotcheck parts 1 and 2 are posted, still let me know about that pash article otherwise I guess I can just assume good faith on the zhwiki editor who cited it. Everything else from the review was addressed, I think. ~Bluecrystal004 (talk · contribs) 02:00, 5 January 2024 (UTC)
Chinese Sources Check
If you have any need, I can help check the Chinese (and perhaps some Japanese) language sources. MilkyDefer 05:47, 31 December 2023 (UTC)