|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
my rating |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1250179459
| 9781250179456
| 1250179459
| 4.03
| 2,885
| Oct 03, 2017
| Oct 03, 2017
|
it was amazing
|
If you are troubled by the phenomena that is Donald Trump...YOU MUST READ THIS BOOK. In a nut shell, Bandy Lee has put together a compilation of pieces If you are troubled by the phenomena that is Donald Trump...YOU MUST READ THIS BOOK. In a nut shell, Bandy Lee has put together a compilation of pieces written, for the most part, by her colleagues, namely experts in psychiatric medicine, who offer their professional opinions about a man that has turned American politics into a bad reality TV show. A major theme explored throughout the book is whether Trump is crazy like a fox or just plain crazy like a crazy. The book also explores the impotence that many psychiatrists/mental health professional are feeling with respect to the Trump Effect (yes this is a real thing) because of a gag order imposed by the APA which prevents psychiatrists from diagnosing a public figure whom they have not personally treated. While this policy is understandable and important for obvious reasons, they point out that they also have a duty and obligation to protect the public at large from someone whom they believe dangerous. The book also tries to answer how and why a man like Donald Trump, whom they say displays decades of behavior consistent with a malignant narcissist (not just a narcissist but one that is a sociopath), paranoia, and ADHD, got elected to such a high office in the first place. (note: Time and time again they admit that without evaluating Trump they can't offer a diagnosis. However, they argue, and I think strongly so, that can still provide an informed opinion about what appears to be concerning behavior.) Finally, the book lays out an argument for the mandatory and regular mental health testing of both the President and Vice President given the amount of power and responsibility they have on many fronts. In the end, I think a major goal of the book is to stress the importance of mental health as it applies to our leaders, especially those whose reckless or deranged behavior would potentially affect us all. Mental health has made leaps and bounds in the past few decades in terms of diagnosing, understanding, and treating mental disorders. Is it really so crazy to want to ensure that our leaders are as mentally sound, or at the very least have some method for trying to assess mental stability. Crazy like a fox or simply crazy like a crazy? For many Americans, even some of Trump's greatest critics, the consensus--or at least the hope--is that the answer to that question is the former. After all, like him or not, the man is president of the United States. He was elected, even if he didn't win the majority vote, receiving close to half the votes casts. Let that sink in for a moment. Roughly 1 out of 2 Americans got up, drove to the polls, and willingly voted for Donald Trump. The erratic behavior. The rhetoric. The angry Donald Trump persona. It's all an act. A ploy. A strategy. A conscious effort to undermine his opponents and his critics while shoring up his base. Not to mention, he's a millionaire...a billionaire, married to a beautiful wife half his age. Crazy/Mentally deranged people don't become successful businessmen, and they certainly don't become world leaders, or do they? Was Hitler mentally ill or just pure evil? Both? And does it matter what you call it, if he's dangerous? Many of the authors who contributed to this book believe that Donald Trump suffers from several mental health disorders to include malignant narcissism, paranoia, and ADHD. They admit that while they can not diagnose a mental disorder because none of them have ever personally evaluated him, they feel that as trained mental health professionals, they can offer an informed opinion based on three decades of recorded behavior. In their opinion, whether or not Donald Trump is crazy like a fox, his behavior now and over the decades is consistent with someone who is just plain crazy. And he's not alone. According to the authors, more than 50% of past US presidents demonstrated behavior consistent with a mental health disease, from Abraham Lincoln, who suffered from depression, to Reagan, who was eventually diagnosed with dementia. They go out of their way to point out that suffering from a mental health disorder/illness does not necessarily disqualify someone from being an elected public official, nor should it, though in the case of the man with the codes to our nuclear arsenal, it should probably be a concern. Many of the psychiatrists not only fear Trump suffers from mental health issues, but that his actions suggest that he is also dangerous. So how does a man like Donald Trump get elected anyway? This is perhaps the first time that I've seen any worthwhile analysis into why people supported the Donald. To simply label Trump supporters as "Deplorables" the way Hillary Clinton did simply doesn't cut it. Several essays offered explanations that made sense. For decades, there has been a neoliberal movement that has gained momentum and created real social change for minorities of all flavors. A movement that seemed to culminate in the election of our first African American president. What a glorious and proud moment for many of us. The deep wounds inflicted by our country's civil war are numerous and deep, and the road to true equality after slavery was officially abolished has been long and hard. So when a smart, articulate black man named Barrack Obama won the presidency, many of us believed, maybe wrongly so, that our journey was almost over. The rise of Trump is proof that you can change the law and you can even change a culture a lot easier than you can change a mind or a heart. For many, the neoliberal agenda has fostered resentment. Not only is it illegal to discriminate against "insert vulnerable group here," you can't even speak your mind for fear of being shut down. Any slight against someone who happens to be from a vulnerable group is all too quickly interpreted as a slight against the vulnerable group. Hell, you can't even hold a rally on a college campus these days. So while the Black Lives Matters movement (extreme voices aside) seems to encompass the neoliberal agenda, it alienates another segment of America which now feels as if they are the minority who are being discriminated against. I can't tell you how many times people (average everyday people) say what about White Lives? Don't they matter, too? Of course, they do. But that's not the point, at least for some. So whether the crimes are real or imagined, they feel real to those who feel left behind, forced to accept laws and new cultural norms that don't jive with their personal values. The failure to kneel during the National Anthem. The desecration or removal of national monuments. Happy Holidays vs. Merry X-mas. These are experienced as major snubs by a number of people who feel they are being punished for being white. Then along comes Trump. He says freely and without apology what they've been saying, thinking, or feeling in the privacy of their homes for too long. And he promises to Make America Great Again...what ever that means, and it means a lot to someone who feels disenfranchised or victimized. It is no accident that hate crimes are up in America, and it is no accident that the Trump Effect is so profound that it is being blamed for a rise in anxiety among minority/immigrant groups across America. Add the power of social media, with its massive reach and perpetuation of alternative facts, to the underlying tension and resentment, and you have the inevitability of someone like Trump. One psychiatrist/author described it as group narcissism. Trump validates the group's superiority, their worthiness, while in turn reinforcing their blame of the "other," and they in turn offer him the adulation he craves. The Trump Effect Do you find yourself constantly checking social media, checking the news sites impulsively, and generally feeling anxious since Nov. 8, 2016? If so, you too may be suffering from the Trump Effect. According to the authors, while Trump inspires great loyalty from his supporters, he inspires great antipathy and revulsion in his adversaries. Personally, I have never felt such contempt for another human being, and apparently I am not alone. At least one psychiatrist describes it as being in a relationship with a malignant narcissist, a relationship that you can not walk away from. It's terrifying. But is he really dangerous or am I (and others) just being liberal snowflakes? Well, I honestly don't believe I'm a liberal snowflake. While I detest Trump, I wasn't a Hillary supporter. And while I generally support socially liberal values, I have many conservative views. But I am also an avid reader with a special interest in abnormal psychology and the biological basis for belief and behavior. If you peruse my bookshelves you will see that I like to read about people who do really bad things and try to understand why. And from day one, I have had the feeling that Trump is a sociopath, a narcissist, and a very dangerous man. I do not believe he is crazy like a fox. I believe he is crazy like a crazy. I believe this because if you look at his history, his actions. If you take what he has said in the past (his own words) at face value, there is no other conclusion. The author of "The Art of Deal" also contributed to this book. He spent a year with Trump. He's the one who actually wrote the book. And he seems to agree that whatever your worst impression of Trump is, it's not even close. I, however, am not a trained psychiatrist. The authors of this book were. And they seem to agree that, crazy or not, Trump's pattern of behavior suggests he is dangerous. So what is a concerned citizen to do? This is a question I ponder daily. I love to read. I love to learn. I love to engage others, particularly those who don't share my views. After all, that's how we broaden our perspective and grow intellectually and emotionally. But politics is not something you can discuss. Politics has become even more taboo and more personalized than religion. There is no healthy debate. No exchange of ideas. No reaching across the aisle. And thanks to the internet which has effectively created ideological bubbles, you don't even ever have to hear an opinion that doesn't echo your own. And on the rare occasion you interact through social media, the conversation, depersonalized, has a high chance or deteriorating quickly into insults and name calling. I do try to engage people. As a therapist I interact with a lot of people. But it's really hard. Political opinions seem rooted in emotion and influenced more our identities than by facts and figures. I have to wonder what the role of technology has already and will continue to play in politics moving forward. While it has the potential to break down walls, it also has the potential to build echo chambers. Anyway, I would highly recommend this book. And not just to my American friends as I think the Trump Effect is not simply an American problem. Crazy like a fox or crazy like a crazy, if this loon (my characterization) starts a nuclear war, which is a major concern expressed and validated throughout the entire book, it will have repercussions around the world. Many people say that while Trump is bad, he's no Hitler. No, he's not. But what if he's worse? ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 04, 2018
|
Feb 04, 2018
|
Feb 04, 2018
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
0062694855
| 9780062694850
| unknown
| 3.96
| 17,321
| Sep 12, 2017
| Sep 12, 2017
|
really liked it
| Well, I’ve learned that Trump insists that he has “the world’s greatest memory,” but his vision of the future go him this far. I’ve learned that Tr Well, I’ve learned that Trump insists that he has “the world’s greatest memory,” but his vision of the future go him this far. I’ve learned that Trump has his own version of reality, which is a polite way of saying he can’t always be trusted. He also brings his own sense of political decorum. I’ve heard him insult a war hero, brag about grabbing women by the pussy, denigrate the judicial system, demonize immigrants, fight with the pope, doubt the democratic process, advocate torture and war crimes, tout the size of his junk in a presidential debate, trash the media, and indirectly endanger my life. I think that this is a major miscalculation on the part of the Democrats. They assumed that Trump voters would care about Pussygate. That they valued political correctness or cultural sensitivity.. In essence, they somehow believed that Republicans shared their values and/or would be outraged by things that outraged them. A man in the crowd yell out that Trump should buy NBC. In all the things I’ve read about Trump, I think this sums up his true strength. For all his faults, he does indeed knows what sells. Make America Great Again is such an ingenious slogan. It says and means nothing, yet can and does mean something to everyone. Every great add campaign understands that you don’t sell products by offering spreadsheets and facts. You sell your product by using emotion. You sell a feeling, an idea, a vision. Yet the left is constantly scratching their head when their fact checks or moral outrage don’t register with the loyal Trump supporter. In fact, it seems that of those people who supported Trump but who are not happy with his performance, most are not concerned about his false claims or inconsistent behaviors. Most people just don’t like his Twitter habit and his negative, punch-em in the face style. No one she (Ali Vitali) spoke to is disturbed by the Muslim ban. There is a lot here. Immigration is a complicated issue. The immigration of Muslims, or potentially hostile parties, is a whole other story. I’m liberal or at least liberal leaning, but the idea that because this country was built on immigrants that we should welcome anyone who wants to come is naïve. Unfortunately, immigration has been politicized and turned into a polarizing hot-button topic to sway voters. His supporters tell us they like this (referring to Muslim ban). They believe it is a wise decision. And they believe Donald Trump is going to keep them safe. Why in our latest MSNBC poll, we found that 60 percent of Republican voters say that one of their biggest concerns is being the victim of a terror attack. One of Trump’s worst traits is his divisive rhetoric. He uses it as a distraction, but also as a means to strengthen the commitment of his base. It resonates with our tribal roots and tendencies. “He uses the reporters to recreate razzle dazzle: there are five stories in the morning papers leading into 11 minutes of television at night,” Breslin wrote. I remember reading that once upon a time Trump would call magazines and plant stories about himself. The old no publicity is bad publicity. But it’s not clear what he’s talking about when he says, ‘Everybody goes against us—down the tubes.” I have a patient whose daughter attended a Trump rally with a friend. She said it was terrifying. The crowds, encouraged by Trump, feel emboldened. We all know what people, even good people, are capable of when they get caught up in a group dynamic. Trump is a charismatic leader who says that we need to come together in one breath and then uses charged and divisive language in the next. All the time feigning innocence. People seem drawn to Trump’s rallies in the same way that they are drawn to a professional wrestling match and as with a professional wrestling match, they seem divided between people who believe all they see and hear, and those who know it’s partially a performance. The scariest thing about being a Trump rally is that you don’t know who believes it and who doesn’t. The people in this ballroom are not the subject of Trump’s speeches, either. Their industries aren’t dead. Their jobs didn’t disappear overseas. More likely, these are the people shipping the jobs overseas. These are the people slashing budgets and enhancing their own bottom line while the bottom falls out of everyone else’s lives. Many people have suggested that part of Trump’s problem is that he is a wanna-be. More than anything he respects wealth and prestige, but despite his claims (often exaggerated) of wealth, over the years he has been snubbed by the elite. In their circle, he's a joke...or at least he was. Now, that story is probably apocryphal. But it shows the kind of love that’s out there for some politicians, and Trump is, for a good portion of America, a politician who inspires that kind of love. “Nothing short of Rump shooting my daughter in the street and my grandchildren” can dissuade me form voting for Trump, a woman told Ashley Parker of the New York Times. Jones’ followers loved him, too. Hitler didn’t perpetuate the Holocaust without the support of many. People who inspire this kind of devotion should scare us all. As I run through a mental list of questions for Trump, one comes to mind for rank-a-file Republicans. Why drop Trump now? Why is this (pussygate) the line for Republican Why not calling Mexicans rapists? Or fighting with the pope? Or racism toward a federal judge? Or the fraud lawsuits? Or the name-calling? Or the fearmongering? Or the xenophobia? Or the countless other degrading statements he’s, made about women, including his own wife? For god’s sake, why not the half decade of birtherism? One thing I’ve learned from my own observations as well as things that I’ve read is that people are capable of performing some pretty impressive mental gymnastics. Every day on the campaign trail Trump’s actions test the definition of normal. He calls for jailing his opponent. He openly admonishes sitting general. He singles out minority groups for blanket condemnation. He goes after the spouses of his rivals. He questions the integrity of the election itself. He is endlessly hostile toward the media. All of this Trump does so often that it’s a struggle to remember what’s old news, by the standard of his behavior, and that is big news, by the standard of history. The book I’m reading now further explores Trumps mental health. Will have more to thoughts on this later. I am desperate to talk about his voters. I want to do a piece explaining that they don’t care about the headlines. Either they aren’t paying attention to them or they are discounting whatever they hear. The Access Hollywood tape, the women accusing Trump of sexual assault, the dark premonitions and lingering grudges—out her, in Trump’s American, none of it is as big a deal as it is in New York or Washington. A book I read recently called Denying to the Grave addresses the problem we face when trying to change people’s minds using facts. Part of the problem is that we make arguments that appeal to us. But that’s the problem. You’re not trying to convince someone who thinks like you. You’re trying to appeal to somebody who has come to a different conclusion. We often think the problem is that these people just don’t understand the facts, but the reality is that often times they’ve simply come to a different conclusion based on their values and biases. Then he (Trump) admitted something usually left unsaid, something expressing in wrinkles, dark circles, and gray spots. “This is more work than in my previous life,” Trump said. Yes, it’s hard being president. People aren’t usually surprised by that fact. Trump was. “I thought it would be easier,” he said. Well, I think this last quote says it all. I honestly don’t think Trump has a clue. I think he is a con man who doesn’t even try to hide that he’s a con man. He doesn’t lie. He speaks his mind. He isn’t sexist or racist, he simply has the courage to say things that we’ve all said when we thought no one was listening. Overall, Tur’s book does a decent job of offering insights garnered from close to two years of covering his campaign, though I could have done without some of the personal accounting. I also feel at times she hit us with the obvious, “Can you believe he just said that.” Interestingly, like Michael Wolff and others, she is capitalizing on the media buzz around Trump. Whatever her motives, her book is giving Donald the media attention he so desperately craves, for better or for worse, but also the kind of media attention that paved his way to the White House, whether we want to admit it or not. And hey…I bought the book. I bought several books. But just imagine…what would happen if suddenly the media just stopped reporting on Trump and all his craziness? With the cameras turned off, would he stop performing and would he slip into celebrity oblivion. If all Trump really has going for him is his celebrity, isn’t the media the one feeding the monster? Trump is not Hitler in that he lacks any real philosophical conviction. He’s a media whore. A narcissist and a bully. His sole driving force is a desire to be loved and admired. He is easily swayed and manipulated and is a reality TV star who doesn’t seem to grasp the import of his position. He’s a joke, and somehow America’s immediate future is his punchline. Politics aside, he has degraded and disgraced the highest office in this nation and has set a new tone that equates crassness with honesty and patriotism with nativism. This past year for many has felt like living in a cheesy reality TV show. I don’t care how good the stock market is doing. I think Trump has taken us to a very dark place, and I look forward to the day when his show finally gets canceled. ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Jan 30, 2018
|
Jan 30, 2018
|
Jan 30, 2018
|
Audiobook
| |||||||||||||||
1250158060
| 9781250158062
| 1250158060
| 3.44
| 75,859
| Jan 05, 2018
| Jan 05, 2018
|
it was amazing
|
The most shocking aspect of this book is that it's not really that shocking, mainly because there's nothing new. Everything. It's all been previously
The most shocking aspect of this book is that it's not really that shocking, mainly because there's nothing new. Everything. It's all been previously reported by the media. And yet still Donald Trump is our president. Still 35% of Americans support him. Still congress refuses to call him out. I think the value of Wolff's book lies in the fact that it offers a cohesive narrative in a one-stop-shop fashion to the reality TV drama that has become American leadership. I also think Wolff, who's been accused of being loose with the truth, loose or not, offers some additional insight into the various voices that are influencing the current president. So, yeah. I despise Trump. Despised him long before he decided to run for office, and despise him more now that he is our sitting president. It's probably why I couldn't wait to read Wolff's book. After all, who doesn't seek out confirmation for their biases...right? And there is no doubt about it. In my mind Trump has, does, and always will exemplify everything that I personally find wrong with America. The man is a megalomaniac at best and a sociopath at worst. Forget that he knows little to nothing about foreign or domestic policy. He is infantile. Immature. Self-centered. Lacking in intellectual curiosity and empathy. Detached. Entitled. Rude. An ignoramus who revels in his ignorance. And worst of all, the man hates to read. Seriously. Imagine that. A world leader who doesn't read. I remember coming across an interview in which the commentator was speculating that Trump was actually unable to read. I watched another interview in which Trump was asked for details about his favorite biography. His reply..."I've never read a biography." But for all his failings, there is one thing Trump excels at. He is a successful entertainer. The robust sales of Fire and Fury, whose film rights have already been purchased, is a tribute to Trump's ability to entertain the masses. We the people do love our reality TV dramas. After Trump was elected, I soothed myself with the possibility that maybe he wouldn't be as bad as I (and so any others) imagined...blowhard or not, in his quest to stroke his ego, his self-interests might somehow align with American interests, but I just don't see it. He's not bad. He's worse. Trump and his administration aren't simply shady characters, they are shady caricatures. The truth is you can't make the likes of Jarvanka, Bannon, Trump Jr, and Stephen Miller up. In the end, I'm pretty sure Trump isn't the cure for what ails America. But I'm also not sure he's the disease. More like a nasty symptom of an uninformed, or rather misinformed, easily distracted, increasingly disenchanted American electorate. I live in Trump country. Many of my neighbors not only voted for him, but did so proudly. I had one patient and Trump supporter who told me that not only did she cast her first ever presidential vote for Trump, but she went to the inauguration. As always, I purchased a few additional books to offer perspective, Unbelievable by Katy Tur and The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump by Bandy Lee. Yeah. I know. I should probably try harder to find at least one Pro-Trump narrative, so leave a suggestion if you have one. Some passages that I highlighted: This was the peculiar and haunting consensus—not that Trump was guilty of all that he was accused of, but that he was guilty of so much else. It was all too possible that the hardly plausible would lead to the totally credible. Here was a key Trump White House rationale: expertise, that liberal virtue, was overrated. What’s more, the success of the speech confirmed the Jared and Ivanka strategy: look for common ground. It also confirmed Ivanka’s understanding of her father: he just wanted to be loved. And, likewise, it confirmed Bannon’s worst fear: Trump, in his true heart, was a marshmallow. “Repeal and replace” was a useful slogan, too, in that it came to have meaning without having any actual or specific meaning. Some seducers are preternaturally sensitive to the signals of those they try to seduce; others indiscriminately attempt to seduce, and, by the law of averages, often succeed (this latter group of men might now be regarded as harassers). That was Trump’s approach to women—pleased when he scored, unconcerned when he didn’t (and, often, despite the evidence, believing that he had). And so it was with Director Comey. It’s worse than you can imagine. An idiot surrounded by clowns. Trump won’t read anything—not one-page memos, not the brief policy papers; nothing. He gets up halfway through meetings with world leaders because he is bored. And his staff is no better. Kushner is an entitled baby who knows nothing. Bannon is an arrogant prick who thinks he’s smarter than he is. Trump is less a person than a collection of terrible traits. No one will survive the first year but his family. I hate the work, but feel I need to stay because I’m the only person there with a clue what he’s doing. This was why he had so naturally cottoned to the “fake news” label. “I’ve made stuff up forever, and they always print it,” he bragged. The left-right junkies might pretend otherwise, but the great middle doesn’t put political concerns at the top of their minds. That was the radical and transformational nature of the Trump presidency: it held everybody’s attention. If every new event canceled out every other event, like some wacky news-cycle pyramid scheme, then you always survived another day. Everyone, in his or her own way, struggled to express the baldly obvious fact that the president did not know enough, did not know what he didn’t know, did not particularly care, and, to boot, was confident if not serene in his unquestioned certitudes. ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Jan 22, 2018
|
Jan 22, 2018
|
Jan 22, 2018
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
0446578541
| 9780446578547
| 0446578541
| 3.64
| 516
| Oct 01, 2005
| Oct 26, 2005
|
it was amazing
|
I thought this was a very honest portrayal of Donald Trump, a man whose real talent is not his building expertise or his business acumen but instead h
I thought this was a very honest portrayal of Donald Trump, a man whose real talent is not his building expertise or his business acumen but instead his ability to sell to himself. Like Trump or hate him, it is impossible to deny his celebrity status. And it is this celebrity status that has ensured he remain a household name for decades. After reading this book, I do feel as if I have a greater appreciation for Trump's appeal to so many Americans. 1. Those around him report he is an extremely positive person, claiming that even when he was worth less than nothing (-900 million according to some), he had this uncanny ability to stay positive. 2. He not only does what he wants, he's unapologetic about it...and if you don't like it you can go "f" yourself. 3. He represents not only having money and excess but also in reveling in it. 4. He is extremely loyal to those who support him and extremely viscous to those who don't. 5. He is a marketing genius who understands that perception is everything, but even more importantly perception can be manipulated (too easily, sometimes). 6. He says what he thinks even if he doesn't always mean what he says. 7. He's charismatic and a great entertainer. 8. He is the master of spin, inflating his successes and minimizing his failures. 9. He dares to be politically incorrect (and unapologetically so). 10. He's not a politician or part of the establishment. Personally, I don't begrudge Trump his success or wealth. I don't care how many women he's slept with. I also don't care how inflated his self-worth is...(he has consistently claimed to be worth billions when most estimate his true worth is closer to millions). Because honestly, I don't think being rich or popular qualifies you to be the leader of the free world. My concerns with Trump are many and were also highlighted in the narrative. 1. His sense of entitlement. This idea that he not only gets a free pass because of his wealth, but that he actually deserves it. 2. He is extremely vindictive in an almost childish way. 3. He has the attention span of a toddler. Something his critics claim has contributed to many of his business failures. 4. His absolute failures in business far outnumber his successes. 5. He believes his own bullshit. It's one thing to try and put spin on something, it's another to actually start to believe your own tall tales. 6. He really knows very little about the issues facing America, just like he knew very little about running a casino, or an airline, or a football team etc, etc, etc. But that didn't stop him. 7. Much of his "success" is the result of smoke and mirrors. While this makes for good entertainment, I'm not sure you can fake your way through running a country...and if you can...God help us. 8. He lacks real convictions. He's more interested in wealth and power than in principles. 9. He doesn't feel as if he should answer to anyone...certainly not the American people. 10. Despite what some believe, Trump has a long history of political ambitions and aspirations. This is just the first time that he's been taken seriously. 11. Money isn't everything, not on a basic individual level or a more global level. Integrity, ethics, an appreciation for the human experience, health, happiness, the ability to live our lives as we see fit. Sure money is a necessity, but it's not the end. I could go on, but that's not the point of this review. I once read that a little bit of narcissism is not only essential for success, but probably healthy. I agree. But Trump seems to have more than a little bit of narcissism. In fact, he possess an extraordinary amount of narcissism that prevents him from being reflective, a trait that any true great leader needs. Bottom line: This was a fair book. Well researched and well sourced. O'Brien showed the many sides of Trump...not all of them necessarily bad. This was the fourth of six books I committed to read prior to the election and the only 5 star so far, partly because I felt it was the most objective and well-rounded. ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
Oct 27, 2016
|
Oct 27, 2016
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1612196322
| 9781612196329
| 1612196322
| 3.91
| 3,252
| Aug 02, 2016
| Aug 02, 2016
|
really liked it
|
The third in a series of six books I've committed to read before the election, The Making of Donald Trump was written by David Cay Johnston, past winn
The third in a series of six books I've committed to read before the election, The Making of Donald Trump was written by David Cay Johnston, past winner of the Pulitzer. A look into the myth behind the man, Johnston's portrayal of Trump raises serious questions about the Republican presidential candidate. A real-estate mogul turned reality TV star, Trump has polarized this year's Presidential election like no other. To some he represents the anti-politician, the anti-establishment, the anti-PC sentiment that is valued especially among those voters who fear that their "white working class America" is in jeopardy. One has to wonder exactly what "Make America Great Again" means to his base. America has a long history of suspicion and distrust when it comes to our government. Politics has always been messy, and that is the beauty of democracy. Donald Trump, however, is something completely different, and I'm convinced it's that "different-ness" that has made his candidacy a frightening reality. He is applauded for speaking his mind, no matter that what he says is often poppycock. He is praised for his business acumen, despite many failed businesses and at least four bankruptcies in which he has profited from his failures while those around him has suffered. He accuses his critics of dishonesty, even as fact check after fact check demonstrates that he lies or mostly lies 70-80 percent of the time. He claims conspiracies all the while he is creating and/or perpetuating his own. He questions the Clinton Foundation, while his own foundation has been cited for shady behavior. He screams that the media is out to get him, even though if not but for the media and its excessive coverage of his three-ring-circus he would not be the Republican candidate. He criticizes his opponent's supposed mistreatment of her husband's mistresses and affairs even as he publicly denigrates women reducing them to their bra size, suggesting his own accusers must be lying because they are simply too ugly to be assaulted. He claims his opponent is running a smear campaign and refuses to talk issues, yet given a chance to talk issues he resorts to calling her a "nasty woman," "crooked Hillary," and "liar." It's all so bizarre. We are all sitting here watching him say and do these things, yet after the fact he simply denies that's he's done/said them. And he's so adamant, you almost begin to question yourself. Well according Johnston, this is nothing new. When caught and confronted, Trump has a history of going on the offensive. He also describes Trump as vindictive, petty, and full of himself. Yet his criticism of Trump goes beyond these character flaws. If you believe the case made in Johnston's book, Trump is also a criminal with a long history of ties to organized crime and a blatant disregard for the law. I think what I found most disconcerting is that Trump's characterization of Hillary as crooked is ironically a self-portrait of himself. Interestingly, if you pay attention, whenever the media asks Trump or one of his representatives a question, rather than answer the question they somehow use it as an opportunity to attack Hillary, often in areas that have absolutely nothing to do with the original topic. From talking to Trump supporters, I think they think he is a self-made man, a simple man who relates to the average American, a non-politician who can create jobs and cut through the bureaucracy of government. Unfortunately, Trump is not self-made, he is not simple, he can not relate to the average American, and his success as a businessman has less to do with his ability to create and run companies and more to do with his ability to create and sell himself...The Donald. And he's a bully and a spoiled brat. Definitely a narcissist and possibly even a sociopath. I'm not really sure what kind of President he would make. I want to believe it would be a horrible one. After all, life is not a reality TV show. And if Trump runs America the same way he ran his casinos, we'll end up in bankruptcy. And perhaps what is most upsetting to people like me is that a solid chunk of the American electorate actually thinks Trump not only can win...but should. Even if he is worth billions, which is debatable, how does that qualify him to lead America? The book provides many detailed sources. I would enjoy reading the rebuttal to Johnston's claims as there is obviously some bias here. Sadly, I doubt the people who would benefit the most from reading this book will. ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
Oct 20, 2016
|
Oct 20, 2016
|
Hardcover
|
5 of 5 loaded