www.fgks.org   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

What's keeping you with m43 instead of Sony FE? Your answers.

Started 2 days ago | Polls thread
Shop cameras & lenses ▾
ForumParentFirstPreviousNext
Flat view
HA0T0
New MemberPosts: 23
Like?
What's keeping you with m43 instead of Sony FE? Your answers.
2 days ago

Hi! I asked a question about why you may be choosing to stay with m43 instead of going Sony FE. Link here: http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/57521153

It's reached the 150-post limit per thread (Is it still 1997?) but I guess it's only responsible for me to make a response. And thanks for all the honest answers. I was pleasantly surprised by this forum that only a few people called my out on my apparent trolling. I commend you for that!

But seriously, this struggle is real for me. I should have stated my need first but wanted to see how you use your m43 cameras.

I'm a pretty casual shooter myself, and am not heavily invested in m43. I have a GM1, 20/1.7, 14/2.5 and the Samyang 7.5/3.5. I'm satisfied with the GM1 in every way. And I do like the tiny size. I don't care about telephoto; we have a travelzoom compact covering those rare 300mm creepshots. And I could maybe lose the 14/2.5 too since it doesn't do much more than what my phone does.

But quite often, I do want more DoF control for half/full-body portraits. The PaniLeicas (15, 25, 42.5) are two stops slower than entry-level FF lenses so are non-starters for my needs. This is where m43's lens selection falls apart for me. Yes, I could improve my composition. But I don't live in Paris all year and there are things in the background I don't want to stick out in my everyday snapshots but can't avoid.

Why considering the Sony A7+50/1.8? Because:

1) Price. I'd get a RX1R and call it a day, if money is no object.

2) Weight. They weight just ~650g combined. The GM1+Voigt 25/0.95 actually weight about the same. Add a hypothetical FE 35/2 and a Voigt 17.5/0.95, and my m43 system would actually end up heavier!

3) Autofocus. I can use MF adapters/lenses for less used focal ranges. But for daily snapshots I don't want to shoot MF.

4) Panasonic will probably never make a 17/0.7 (or 25/0.6 and 45/0.7 for that matter, but these are not important to me.)

I considered myself a pretty average amateur shooter. But now that your answers are in, I'm not even sure I'm a typical m43 user anymore. So why not do a poll. Sampling bias and whatnot 

Many of your answers are good and valid. Some of which I too consider are the strong points of the m43 system. I'll try to summarize them here and in the poll:

1) Telephoto, where DoF control is never a problem. And FF systems will probably never make the small portable f/11 zooms m43 has. Or UWA, where DoF control doesn't exist anyway.

2) Video, where MF lenses are used anyway.

3) Tempted to switch, but just too invested in m43. Now I wonder how many of you are there. This is difficult to poll but still  It's a very valid reason. I'm still phasing out my Pentax gear after switching for ~4 years for example.

4) Carry multiple systems at the same time. Now this is IMO too much of a compromise. But for tele/UWA shooters I can understand.

5) Zoom users who want a light system. But I wonder does m43 justify itself compared to, say, the LX100 or RX100? If I didn't care about DoF control, I'd think they are really good and even lighter.

6) m43 just happens to be the cheapest system around. I guess few would openly admit this as their main reason for staying with m43, and again, sampling bias, but I feel this is a valid reason for many too. But it worries me that if this is the main reason for people coming to m43, we will never get a reasonably fast AF glass from Panasonic.

7) Ignorance of optics and camera equivalence. Who would admit that 

Please cast your vote. Comments and derision welcomed as usual.

POLL
I shoot a lot of telephoto or UWA.
12.3% 13  votes
I mainly shoot video.
0.9% 1  vote
I'm tempted to switch, but I'm too invested (monetarily and emotionally) in m43 right now. I'll thus tell you Sony simply sucks.
8.5% 9  votes
I have and actually carry multiple systems out.
28.3% 30  votes
I mainly use zooms. And I find compacts not good enough. And FF zooms are too heavy.
26.4% 28  votes
I like to switch lenses, not necessarily for IQ reasons, and m43 is cheap enough for me to do that.
8.5% 9  votes
Equivalence isn't real. 25/1.4 has the same light gathering capability (whatever that is) as a 50/1.4!
15.1% 16  votes
  Show results
Panasonic Lumix DMC-GM1 Panasonic Lumix DMC-LX100 Panasonic Lumix G 42.5mm F1.7 Sony RX100 Sony RX1R
If you believe there are incorrect tags, please send us this post using our feedback form.
ForumParentFirstPreviousNext
Flat view
Post (hide subjects)Posted by
ForumParentFirstPreviousNext
Keyboard shortcuts:
FForum PPrevious NNext WNext unread UUpvote SSubscribe RReply QQuote BBookmark post MMy threads
Color scheme? Blue / Yellow