THEATER REVIEW: "Frost / Nixon" ★★★½ Through Oct. 10 at TimeLine Theatre, 615 W. Wellington Ave.; Running Time: 1 hour, 40 minutes; Tickets: $28-$38 at 773-281-8463 and www.timelinetheatre.com
Few would call Rod R. Blagojevich wholly Nixonian. In fact, the former Illinois governor probably has more in common with the legendary British interviewer David Frost, a man with a famously full head of hair, a relentlessly sunny disposition, a gregarious temperament and the honor of being one of the very first media celebrities to become famous mostly for being hungry for fame.
But in the excellent Chicago premiere of Peter Morgan’s savvy play, “Frost/Nixon,” at the TimeLine Theatre, there is a gripping scene, one among many gripping scenes in Louis Contey’s compellingly intimate production, when Terry Hamilton’s remarkably adroit version of Nixon tries to justify his actions during Watergate.
Since Morgan’s play, a Broadway hit that became a Hollywood movie, was dealing with the real Frost interviews, which took place in 1977, you may well be familiar with Nixon’s arguments.
One doubts that Blagojevich would have said “when the governor does it, that means it is not illegal” on the stand, had he chosen to testify. But it’s a pretty fair bet that he would have waxed lyrical on such themes as the necessity of the governor getting frank and confidential advise, how effective politics requires dealmaking and quid pro quos, the unreliability of tapes taken out of context. As a visit to “Frost/Nixon” reveals, Nixon mostly got there first.
Such are the pleasures of political theater just slightly removed. You go to a play about Frost and Nixon and you end up musing all night on the Blago phenomenon.
That’s because Morgan (“The Queen”) is really writing about the corruption of power and the rise of hubris. And, yet more interesting for that Blago connection, he also writes about how personal insecurities and peccadilloes don’t suddenly vanish if we achieve power (just think about your boss).
In one of the best scenes in the play, Morgan imagines Nixon making a late-night, drink-fueled call to his interlocutor, painting a man for whom no achievement was enough to vanquish his own inferiorities as a sweaty man who had to shave several times a day, hated crowded parties and was forever battling the snobbish elites.
I wish there were more juicy plays like “Frost/Nixon,” combining elements of Greek tragedy, politics and tabloid journalism. But I think TimeLine will have a big and deserved success with this production. It’s much less flashy, certainly, than the Broadway version, which has its price. But with the help of the brilliant videographer Mike Tutaj, Contey still makes the point that Frost triumphed because he understood TV, and that politics and showbiz were, to Nixon’s chagrin, becoming one and the same.
Better yet, Contey and his cast make that point right in your face. Contey’s fine work here reminds me of his glory days at the old Shattered Globe Theatre on Halsted Street.
I’ve seen both Frank Langella and Stacy Keach do Nixon in this play, and Hamilton, who is surely doing the best work of his career, stands honorably in that distinguished company. And you get to see him in a tighter close-up. Aside from a few moments when his high tenor pops out in a non-Nixonian way, Hamilton is disciplined, complex, rich and entirely credible. It’s one of the best performances of the year in Chicago.
Young Andrew Carter certainly nails the physicality and the celebrity essence of Frost. The only thing missing in his performance (and it’s significant) is his killer instinct. You don’t ever fully believe that his Frost, once he engages, can take down his man. He hangs back a tad too much.
But that fixable issue hardly spoils a show that’s uncommonly well cast, with the superb Matthew Brumlow’s Jim Reston, the conscience and the narrator of the piece, anchoring the drama. David Parkes, who plays the Nixon aid Jack Brennan, reveals the moral force of loyalty. And the focused Beth Lacke, who play’s Frost’s girlfriend Caroline, takes this role deeper than others I’ve seen.
Contey and his designer, Keith Pitts, get rid of the clutter and instead focus everything on two men in two chairs, sparring, concealing, revealing.
Chicago-style.