*puts on tinfoil hat*
Clearly, the dotty letters were written by a particularly sneaky misogynist-for-jesus. You see, by making himself look like someone who would be seen as an idiot, and making himself be seen as a girl, he knew he could get the clever self-respecting cynical feminists atheists in the group to leave due to all the obnoxious gender-hate. Then the boy atheists will be left only with dumb self-loathing anti-feminist girl atheists to attempt to reproduce with, leading to misplaced organs, frustration, and eventually giving up in defeat to fornicate with the squid.
This will produce a master squid race, but they will not have thumbs and will only rule the sea and not the land.
Cthulu ♥s me!