Abstract
Housing policy in New Zealand has traditionally been characterised by significant market intervention in support of home ownership and a residual state housing rental sector. Within the context of dramatic social welfare reforms in the 1990s, a set of radical housing reforms was introduced that profoundly transformed the role of the state in the housing system. Key elements of the reforms included the creation of a profit-oriented company to manage state rentals, a move to market rents in the state sector and the introduction of an accommodation supplement. This paper examines the underlying rationale and impacts of the reforms focusing on issues of privatisation, tenant turnover, affordability and tenant protest. Having examined the ongoing problems engendered by these reforms the paper reviews more recent political and legislative reforms that were sought to reassert the state's traditional position within the New Zealand housing market.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Boston J., and Dalziel P. (eds), 1992: The Decent Society. Oxford University Press, Auckland.
Boston J., Dalziel P. and St John S. (eds), 1999: Redesigning the Welfare State in New Zealand: Problems, Policies and Prospects. Oxford University Press, Auckland.
Britton S. Le Heron R. and Pawson E., 1992: Changing places in New Zealand: A Geography of Restructuring, New Zealand Geographical Society, Christchurch.
Davidson A., 1999: Alternative Models of Social Housing: Tenure patterns and cost-renting in New Zealand and Sweden. Housing Studies 14(4): 453-472.
Department of Social Welfare, 1999: Social Environment Scan. Social Policy Agency, DSW, Wellington.
Ferguson G., 1994: Building the New Zealand Dream. Dunmore Press Ltd., Palmerston North, New Zealand.
Forrest R. and Murie A., 1991: Selling the Welfare State: the privatisation of public housing. Routledge, Andover, Hants.
Friendship House, 1997: The Impact of the Accommodation Supplement on South Auckland Housing markets 1993-1997. Friendship House, PO Box 76-140, Manukau City, Auckland.
Gosche M., 2000a: Housing News: Issue 1- September 2000, http://www.executive.govt.nz/minister/gosche/housing_news/0900.htm#2, 14 September.
Gosche M., 2000b: Income-related rents restored, http://www.executive.govt.nz/speech.cmf?speechralph=31118&SR=0
Gosche M., 2000c: A single Housing Solution-Housing New Zealand Corporation, New Zealand Government Executive Press Release, 25 September, http://www.executive.govt.nz/speech.cfm?speechralph=32474&SR=0
Gunby J., 1996: Housing the Hungry: The Third Report, New Zealand Council of Christian Social Services and the Salvation Army, Wellington.
Harloe H., 1995: The People's Home? Blackwell, Oxford.
House of Representatives 1997: Parliamentary Debates, Questions for written answers, Lodged 21 April to 23 May, Hansard Supplement 7.
Housing Corporation Amendment Act, 2001: Government Print, Wellington. Housing New Zealand, 1999: Post Election Briefing Paper prepared for the Incoming Government, Housing New Zealand, Wellington.
Housing New Zealand Corporation, 2001: Statement of Intent 2001/02-2003/4, Housing New Zealand Corporation, Wellington.
Housing Restructuring (Income-Related Rents) Amendment Act 2000, Government Print, Wellington.
Housing Restructuring Act 1992, Government Print, Wellington.
Kelsey J., 1995: The New Zealand Experiment: A World Model for Structural Adjustment?, Auckland University Press and Bridget Williams Books, Auckland.
Kemp P., 1990: Shifting the balance between state and market: the reprivatisation of rental housing provision in Britain. Environment and Planning A 22, 793-810.
Kemp P., 1994: Housing allowances and the fiscal crisis of the welfare state. Housing Studies 9, 531-542.
Labour Party, 2000: Trust in Government and strong social services, New Zealand Labour Party, http://www.labour.org.nz/budget/stmts/sho4.html September 13.
Lawson v Housing New Zealand 1997: 2NZLR 474.
Le Heron R. and Pawson E. (eds), 1996: Changing Places: New Zealand in the Nineties. Longman Paul, Auckland.
Luxton J., 1991: Housing and Accommodation: Accommodation Assistance, Government Printers, Wellington.
McLeay E., 1992: Housing Policy. In: Boston J. and Dalziel P. (eds), The Decent Society? Essays in Response to National's Economic and Social Policies. Oxford University Press, Auckland.
Ministry of Housing, 1996: Post-election Briefing to the Minister of Housing. Ministry of Housing, Wellington.
Ministry of Social Policy, 1999: Post-Election briefing papers. Ministry of Social Policy, Wellington.
Morgan-Thomas E., 1997: Is This the End of Public Housing In: Coles R. (ed.), The End of Public Housing? Urban Research Program, Research School of Social Sciences, Australian National University, Canberra.
Morrison P.S., 1995: The Geography of Rental Housing and the Restructuring of Housing Assistance in New Zealand. Housing Studies 10(1): 39-56.
Morrison P.S. and Murphy L., 1996: The Geography of the Housing Reforms. In: Le Heron R.B. and Pawson E. (eds), Changing Places: New Zealand in the Nineties. Longman Paul, Auckland.
Murie A., 1997: The Social rented Sector, Housing and the Welfare State in the UK. Housing Studies 12(4): 437-461.
Murphy L., 1999: Housing Policy. In: Boston J., Dalziel P. and St John S. (eds), Redesigning the Welfare State in New Zealand: Problems, Policies and Prospects. Oxford University Press, Auckland.
Murphy L., 2000: A Profitable Housing Policy? The privatisation of the New Zealand government's residential mortgage portfolio. Regional Studies 34(4): 395-399.
Murphy L., 2003: Reasserting the 'social' in social rented housing: politics, housing policy and housing reforms in New Zealand. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 27 (1), 90-101.
Murphy L. and Kearns R.A., 1994: Privatisation by Stealth: Housing New Zealand Ltd. Environment and Planning A 26, 623-637.
Parker M., 1997: The Industry Commission's Approach to Housing Assistance. In: Coles R. (ed.), The End of Public Housing? Urban Research Program, Research School of Social Sciences, Australian National University, Canberra.
Priemus H., 1997: Growth and Stagnation in Social rented housing: What is 'Social' in Social rented housing. Housing Studies 12(4): 549-560.
Richardson R., 1991: Budget 1991. Government Printer, Wellington.
Thorns D., 1986: New Zealand Housing Policy: Continuities and Changes. Housing Studies 8(3): 182-191.
Thorns D., 2000: Housing Policy in the 1990s-New Zealand a Decade of Change. Housing Studies 15(1), 129-138.
WINZ, 2001: Quarterly Report: Statistics March 2001. Work and Income New Zealand, Wellington.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Murphy, L. To the market and back: Housing policy and state housing in New Zealand. GeoJournal 59, 119–126 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:GEJO.0000019970.40488.d5
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:GEJO.0000019970.40488.d5