This document discusses strategies a subcontractor can use to pursue payment from the main contractor when faced with a conditional payment clause. Conditional clauses like "pay when paid" aim to shift the risk of non-payment from the main contractor to the subcontractor. The document outlines two alternative bases for a subcontractor's claim: 1) negotiating a direct payment agreement with the employer; and 2) arguing the main contractor failed to fully pursue the subcontractor's claims against the employer as required by law. It also discusses the importance of timing, with the subcontractor systematically requesting evidence and pursuing legal action if needed. Overall, the document advises subcontractors to argue lack of pursuit by the main contractor rather than simply
This document provides an overview of business contracts and torts under Omani law. It analyzes two legal cases. The first case involves a singer, Mr. Badar, who failed to attend required rehearsals for a musical performance due to illness. The event organizer, Mr. Yosuf, terminated their contract. Analyzing Omani contract law, the termination was likely valid as Mr. Badar broke a key term of the agreement. The second case involves a construction dispute that raises issues of negligence and liability. The document provides advice to each party based on the relevant Omani laws.
1. Effective multi-party arbitration clauses in construction contracts require properly drafting the clause to encompass all potential disputes between related parties to the construction project under one proceeding.
2. Back-to-back agreements between contractors and subcontractors are important to ensure subcontractor obligations match those in the main contract. However, contractors sometimes fail to secure these agreements.
3. Independent dispute resolution clauses are needed in the main contract and any subcontracts. Awards from arbitrations between the client and contractor would not necessarily bind the subcontractor in separate arbitrations between the contractor and subcontractor.
The document discusses various aspects of contract performance and discharge under commercial law in India. It covers the meaning of performance and discharge of a contract, modes of discharge such as performance, agreement, impossibility, lapse of time and operation of law. It also discusses remedies for breach of contract, including rescission, specific performance, injunction, quantum meruit and damages.
A demand guarantee is a guarantee that must be honoured by the guarantor upon beneficiary's demand. The beneficiary is not required to first make a claim or take any action against the obligor of the guaranteed obligation that the guarantee supports
FORCE MAJEURE CLAUSE: RELEVANCE AND APPLICABILITY IN THE WAKE OF COVID – 19 A...Hitendra Hiremath
Article deals with aspects ascertaining COVID-19 as a force majeure event, the steps to be undertaken by a party to contract before invoking the force majeure clause, absence of the force majeure clause in a contract and impact on real estate sector.
This document summarizes key aspects of contract law in Nepal. It discusses how contracts must be performed precisely according to their terms. Only the promisee has the right to demand performance, though there are exceptions for beneficiaries, joint promisees, and family settlements. Performance can be done by the promisor, an agent, or legal representative. Contracts become void if performance becomes impossible due to changes in circumstances. Rights and obligations can be assigned, except for contracts that are personal in nature.
Assignment #12 -hajer al rubaiai ( business) (1)projectname
This document provides an overview of business contracts and torts under Omani law. It analyzes two legal cases. The first case involves a singer, Mr. Badar, who failed to attend required rehearsals for a musical performance due to illness. The event organizer, Mr. Yosuf, terminated their contract. Analyzing Omani contract law, the termination was likely valid as Mr. Badar broke a key term of the agreement. The second case involves a construction dispute that raises issues of negligence and liability. The document provides advice to each party based on the relevant Omani laws.
1. Effective multi-party arbitration clauses in construction contracts require properly drafting the clause to encompass all potential disputes between related parties to the construction project under one proceeding.
2. Back-to-back agreements between contractors and subcontractors are important to ensure subcontractor obligations match those in the main contract. However, contractors sometimes fail to secure these agreements.
3. Independent dispute resolution clauses are needed in the main contract and any subcontracts. Awards from arbitrations between the client and contractor would not necessarily bind the subcontractor in separate arbitrations between the contractor and subcontractor.
The document discusses various aspects of contract performance and discharge under commercial law in India. It covers the meaning of performance and discharge of a contract, modes of discharge such as performance, agreement, impossibility, lapse of time and operation of law. It also discusses remedies for breach of contract, including rescission, specific performance, injunction, quantum meruit and damages.
The document discusses various aspects of performance and discharge of contracts under commercial law. It defines performance of contract as parties fulfilling their obligations agreed upon in the contract. It can be actual performance or attempted performance. Discharge of contract implies termination of contractual obligations and can occur through performance, agreement or consent between parties, impossibility of performance, lapse of time or operation of law. In case of breach of contract, remedies available include rescission of contract, suit for specific performance, injunction, quantum meruit or damages.
The Interim Judicial Managers were appointed by the High Court of Singapore to manage the affairs and property of ZenRock Commodities Trading Pte Ltd, which is currently under interim judicial management. The IJMs have identified over 200 questionable transactions dating back to January 2018 involving double financing arrangements, set-off agreements, and tripartite agreements. These transactions allowed ZenRock to obtain multiple letters of credit financing from different banks for the same cargo. The IJMs' review found that ZenRock used duplicate and misleading documents to obscure the true nature of deals and receive financing that it may not otherwise have been entitled to. The total liabilities to bank creditors from these questionable transactions amounts to USD175.3 million.
Insolvency Resolution Process of Guarantors under IBCKaran Valecha
This presentation provides for the insolvency resolution process of guarantors to a corporate debtor. It further takes into account the nature and definition of a contract of guarantee and how the same is treated under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 pointing out the key case laws on the subject followed by a brief discussion on the constitutional validity of notification enabling CIRP of personal guarantors.
This document discusses key concepts related to contracts, including consideration, breach of contract, contingent contracts, contracts of indemnity, and contracts of guarantee. Some key points:
1. Consideration is something of value given in exchange for a promise. It can be past, present or future acts and must be desired by the promisor.
2. Breach of contract occurs when a party fails to fulfill their contractual obligations. This can be an actual or anticipatory breach.
3. A contingent contract is one whose performance depends on an uncertain future event. If the event occurs or does not occur, the contract is enforced or voided accordingly.
William Kosar What Every Budget Officer Should Know_RwandaWilliam Kosar
This document provides an overview of key contract information for budget officers. It discusses types of contracts including public contracts, general conditions of contracts, and public-private partnerships. It also covers memorandums of understanding, performance guarantees, bid rigging, and types of resource exploration contracts like production sharing agreements and power purchase agreements. Checklists are recommended to ensure all important contract details are included. The dangers of memorandums of understanding being non-binding are outlined, and performance guarantees using letters of credit or bonds are described. Finally, common forms of bid rigging like cover bidding, bid suppression, bid rotation, and market allocation are defined, along with warning signs of anti-competitive bidding practices.
The document discusses various topics related to contract law in India including essential elements of a valid contract, performance of contracts, remedies for breach of contracts, quasi-contracts, consent, agents and agency, termination of agency, and negotiable instruments. It provides definitions and explanations of these legal concepts under the Indian Contract Act 1872. The key points covered include what constitutes a valid contract, rules regarding performance and breach of contracts, types of quasi-contracts, essentials of a valid agent and agency relationship, and circumstances for termination of agency.
The document discusses various concepts related to contracts and agreements. It defines a contract as an agreement that is enforceable by law, containing two key elements - agreement and enforceability. An agreement requires plurality of persons, consensus between parties, and consideration to be a contract. Contracts can be classified based on formation, performance, validity and type. Conditions for a valid contract and circumstances in which contracts may become void or voidable are also outlined.
Bankruptcy Act 1997 (By BU AIS 2nd Batch)Jessic Sharif
This document is a presentation on the Bankruptcy Act of 1997 given by a group of students at the University of Barisal. It defines key terms related to bankruptcy such as adjudication, creditors, debtors, and discharge. It explains that bankruptcy is a legal process that allows individuals who cannot pay their debts to eliminate or discharge most of their debts and get a fresh start. It discusses who can and cannot be declared bankrupt under the Act and the conditions for creditors and debtors to file bankruptcy petitions. The effects of an order of adjudication are that the bankrupt must assist in realizing and distributing their property to creditors, all non-exempt property vests in the receiver or court, and the bankrupt loses power to enter transactions binding creditors
The document discusses the Supreme Court of India's interpretation of frustration and the doctrine of force majeure in the Energy Watchdog v. CERC case regarding power purchase agreements. It analyzes the court's findings that Section 32 of the Contract Act governs matters relating to express or implied contractual clauses, while Section 56 provides relief in cases of subsequent impossibility. However, the document argues that the court failed to clarify the relationship between these two sections and whether parties can completely avoid Section 56's mandate by including a force majeure clause under Section 32. It concludes there is ambiguity around how far Section 32 can curtail Section 56's broader concept of impossibility.
The document discusses Article 299(1) of the Indian Constitution, which requires all contracts made by the executive branch of the Union or state governments to be made in the name of the President or Governor. It summarizes several key court cases that have interpreted this article, establishing that implied contracts are not allowed and any contract not in compliance with Article 299(1) is invalid. It also discusses how provisions of the Contract Act apply to government contracts and circumstances under which such contracts can be challenged.
While private finance has occurred in Myanmar's telecom sector, structuring these deals presented challenges due to the absence of defined procedures allowing offshore lenders to take onshore security or perfect said security. These deals highlighted issues with Myanmar's current project finance environment and a need for legal reforms. Taking security over immovable property requires approvals but issues remain regarding registration. Perfection of mortgages and charges on both movable and immovable property is problematic. Enforcement of security through the courts is uncertain and non-recourse project finance transactions may be misunderstood. Overall, Myanmar's laws regarding secured transactions and a central registration system require updates to better facilitate private project financing.
A non-compete clause is an agreement where an employee promises not to compete with their employer for a specified period after leaving the job. To be valid, the restrictions in a non-compete clause must be reasonable in terms of time, geographic scope, and line of business. Indian law generally considers restrictions on practicing a profession to be void, but exceptions are made if the restrictions protect an employer's legitimate business interests like trade secrets or goodwill.
Lawyer in Vietnam Oliver Massmann REAL ESTATE – FOREIGNERS BUYING PROPERTY ...Dr. Oliver Massmann
Lawyer in Vietnam Oliver Massmann REAL ESTATE – FOREIGNERS BUYING PROPERTY – WHAT YOU MUST KNOW:
GUIDING NOTES ON ISSUES RELATING TO THE CURRENT LAW ON LAND (2013) AND ITS GUIDING REGULATIONS FOR LAND TRANSACTIONS
This document is a certificate and project work from Mamta, a student of B.A. LL.B at Manipal University Jaipur. It discusses void contracts under sections of the Indian Contract Act 1872. Key points include:
1) A void contract is an agreement that has no legal effect and is not enforceable by law due to missing essential elements like offer, acceptance, lawful consideration or object.
2) Circumstances that make a contract void include agreements with minors or intoxicated persons, agreements based on mutual mistake of fact, agreements with unlawful objects/consideration, and agreements in restraint of marriage or trade.
3) Void contracts differ from voidable contracts, which are
Esteban desea a todos una Feliz Navidad iluminada por la "VELA FREGOLINA", con buena salud, actuaciones y bienestar para las fiestas venideras y siempre, enviando un abrazo de Fregolino.
This document provides an overview and analysis of brand leadership in the current business environment. In 3 sentences:
Brand leadership has changed significantly with the rise of social media, data analytics, and a focus on collaboration. Today's brand leaders must focus on envisioning the future, investing in people, gathering consumer insights, co-creating with consumers, and making corporate social responsibility a strategic priority to connect with consumers and drive business value. The article examines how brands can navigate this new landscape of leadership by sharing power, joining conversations, innovating, leading through design, and recognizing that both brands and consumers play a role in global progress.
Yeiver Yuseppeth Uribe Gutiérrez solicitó reingresar al programa de Sociología en la Universidad Popular del Cesar en dos oportunidades, el 24 de mayo de 2011 y el 24 de octubre de 2012. Ambas solicitudes se encuentran pendientes de aprobación.
Centro regional de formación de profesores de castillaCarol de la Plaza
El documento describe la creación del Centro Regional de Formación del Profesorado de Castilla-La Mancha mediante el Decreto 59/2012. El centro será referente en el uso de nuevas tecnologías y representará una nueva estructura de formación permanente para profesores. Sus objetivos incluyen formar una estructura regional participativa, ofrecer formación relevante para las necesidades de los docentes, y mejorar las plataformas tecnológicas para formación de profesores.
M-Tech Print Solutions Pvt. Ltd is an Indian company that provides printing solutions with a website at www.m-tech.net.in and can be contacted via email at info@m-tech.net.in. The document provides contact information for M-Tech Print Solutions Pvt. Ltd, including their website and email address.
Casey Naoki Kawahira's project portfolio includes three educational projects and one senior project completed while obtaining their Civil Engineering degree from California Polytechnic State University. The portfolio highlights designs of a student housing complex, office building, warehouse, and assessments of lateral drift and timber structures completed between 2013-2015. Kawahira gained experience in reinforced concrete, steel, timber, and foundation design, cost estimation, and seismic analysis.
Al fauzul azeem fi salat ala nabi ill kareem by syed muhammad usman makkiMuhammad Tariq
The document discusses the history and development of the city of Boston from its founding in 1630 by Puritan settlers as a small town on the Shawmut Peninsula through its growth into a major colonial city and center of activity during the American Revolution. It provides details on the economic and population growth of Boston throughout the 18th century as well as its role as an important port and hub of trade and commerce in the years leading up to the Revolutionary War.
This document describes a software solution for sizing, selecting, and generating quotations for safety and pressure relief valves. The software provides guided configuration, integrated calculations, product selection, pricing, and proposal generation capabilities. It aims to streamline the sales process for valve manufacturers and provide a better customer experience.
Digipack CD cases are made of cardboard which is better for the environment than plastic cases. They allow for customization of each panel but may not provide enough space for all details. While digipacks are a visual representation of the artist and won't break like plastic, cardboard may show wear more quickly and cost more to add designs due to having three sleeves.
This document summarizes key points about negotiating subcontractor clauses. It discusses typical "battle of the forms" scenarios when a subcontractor's submittal does not match solicitation documents or a proposal. It provides tips for reviewing subcontracts, including paying attention to modifications of association forms. Specific clauses discussed include flow-through, payment, indemnity, timing of performance, no damage for delay, termination for convenience, and liquidating clauses. The document emphasizes striking overly onerous clauses and negotiating reasonable revisions.
Breach of contract occurs when one party fails to meet their obligations under a contract. There are three main types of breach: anticipatory breach, where a party signals they will not perform before the deadline; actual breach, where a party fails to perform by the deadline or makes performance impossible; and partial breach, where a non-material part of the contract is breached. When a breach occurs, the innocent party is entitled to damages to put them in the position they would have been in if the contract was fulfilled. Remedies for the innocent party include getting the breaching party to reconsider, contacting consumer forums, or suing for damages or specific performance.
This document discusses key considerations for IT contracting guarantees when a material adverse change occurs with the guarantor. It recommends that guarantees: (1) obligate payment if the supplier breaches and continue services, as money is not sufficient; and (2) address what constitutes a material adverse change and remedies. For public companies, a credit rating drop defines material adverse change, while for private companies, the customer reasonably defines it. The remedy is typically an immediately available letter of credit as additional security for the customer. Provisions should also permit removing the additional security if the guarantor can show the material adverse change was rectified.
Clause 4.2 Performance Security-Understanding Clauses in FIDIC ‘Conditions of...Divyanshu Dayal
The document discusses performance security under FIDIC conditions of contract. Performance security is usually 10% of the contract price and is valid until the contractor has completed the works and remedied any defects. The employer can claim under the performance security if the contractor fails to extend the validity period, fails to pay amounts owed, or fails to remedy a default. The performance security is returned once the contractor is entitled to the performance certificate.
This document discusses various methods for transferring loans between lenders, including novation, assignment, sub-participation, and declaration of trust. It provides details on the legal implications and requirements of each method under English law. Novation requires consent from all parties and can extinguish any related security, while assignment does not transfer obligations and maintains any guarantees or security. Sub-participation transfers only the economic interest and risks, not legal rights, and cannot be used directly against the borrower. Equitable assignment has fewer formal requirements but lacks notification, while statutory assignment directly links the assignee and borrower upon notice.
This document discusses conditions precedent, representations, and warranties that are standard clauses in syndicated loan agreements. Conditions precedent are requirements that must be met before a borrower can draw down loan funds, such as providing documents showing authorization and financial ability. Representations and warranties provide contractual remedies if statements made about the borrower's legal/financial position are untrue. Both conditions precedent and representations/warranties aim to ensure everything is in order before funds are lent and allow calling back the loan if issues arise.
Be aware of the legal consequences of issuing guarantee cheques in uaeDr. Hassan Mohsen
The bank Guarantee in UAE is governed under Civil Transaction law No 5 of 1985 owing to its commercial nature heedless of the capacity of the party to whom such an instrument is issued or the reason for which it is issued. The concerned article by Civil lawyers of Dubai not only discuss the meaning of guarantee cheque but the legal consequences surrounding such cheques when issued in UAE.
This document summarizes Clause 16 of a construction contract, which deals with suspension and termination of work by the contractor. It discusses the contractor's right to suspend work if the engineer fails to issue payment certificates on time or the employer fails to meet its financial obligations. It also covers the contractor's right to terminate the contract for reasons like prolonged suspension of work or employer bankruptcy. The document provides detailed explanations of key aspects of clause 16, including the required notice periods and processes for suspension, termination, and resolving related claims.
Specific performance, can parties contract outjoseph-omwenga
Specific performance is a court order requiring a party to fulfill their contractual obligations. It is a discretionary remedy granted when monetary damages are inadequate. Certain types of contracts, such as those involving land or unique goods, are more likely to receive specific performance. Parties can generally contract out of specific performance by including damages provisions or defenses to the remedy. However, courts may scrutinize such provisions between parties with unequal bargaining power.
The document discusses various aspects of subcontract administration in construction projects, including:
1) The relationship between the general contractor, owner, and subcontractors, and common issues that can arise such as payment delays and disputes.
2) Key considerations for general contractors in selecting and managing subcontractors, including checking qualifications, financial resources, experience, and drafting appropriate contract terms.
3) Sample contract clauses related to scope of work, changes, delays, defaults, bonding, disputes, and other key terms to address risks and obligations for both parties.
Taxation of Damages- "Damages paid for Breach of Contract to attract GST"EquiCorp Associates
Authority for Advance Rulings (AAR) has ruled that payments in respect to non-performance of a contract would be liable for Goods & Service Tax (GST). This view is based on the provisions under the erstwhile Service Tax Law, “agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act, or to tolerate an act or a situation, or to do an act” was a declared service under Section 66E(e) of Finance Act, 1994. Similar provision has been incorporated in Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST Act) also under Schedule II. Under GST law, the taxable event is supply which has been defined widely and includes all forms of supply for a consideration which is made in course of or in furtherance of business. The act of tolerance or agreeing to refrain from an act is treated as supply of service under the CGST Act. As per these provisions there should be an agreement between the parties to either refrain from doing an act, or to tolerate an act/situation or to do an act.
- Liquidated damages are a predetermined sum that a contractor must pay to the owner if the contractor fails to complete the work by the agreed upon deadline. They are intended to compensate the owner for monetary losses due to the delay.
- For liquidated damages to be enforceable, the amount must be a reasonable estimate of the owner's losses in case of a delay, the exact losses must be difficult to determine, and the damages must not act as a penalty.
- Courts will generally uphold liquidated damages clauses if the daily amount is a reasonable estimate of losses and if the delay is not due to events outside the contractor's control such as natural disasters.
CONSTRUCTION AND ENGINEERING LAW: THE INTERPRETATION AND APPLICATION OF DEMAN...Werksmans Attorneys
This document summarizes two recent court cases, Coface South Africa Insurance Co v East London Own Haven and Guardrisk Insurance Company Ltd v Kentz, regarding the interpretation and application of demand guarantees. Both cases establish that demand guarantees are enforceable based on their terms alone, without consideration of any issues between the holder and other party to the underlying contract. The document also discusses standard contract conditions regarding insolvency, business rescue, and the rights of parties. Key considerations discussed include the wording of securities and underlying contracts with regards to business rescue versus winding up.
A surety bond is a three-party agreement between a contractor, an owner, and a surety company to ensure the contractor fulfills the terms of a construction contract. The surety company prequalifies contractors and guarantees their performance, while contractors must reimburse any losses incurred by the surety. If a contractor defaults, the surety investigates and may complete the project, arrange for a replacement, or pay the bond amount. Subcontractors benefit from payment bonds which allow direct claims against the surety if the contractor does not pay.
The document provides guidance on negotiating oil and gas agreements, including best practices for requests for proposals (RFPs) and contract negotiations. It discusses key elements to consider in an RFP, such as scope of work, commercial terms, and general terms and conditions. It also identifies important clauses to pay attention to like changes, dispute resolution, payment terms, liability, and insurance. The document advises being careful to not take exceptions to an RFP and to negotiate strategically by emphasizing cooperation, keeping communication respectful and businesslike, and remaining calm.
PRC Contract Law Principles and Risk Management in Contract DraftingRHKLegal
An overview of contract drafting techniques with regard to the PRC Contract Law principles and recent Supreme Court Directions. An analysis of limitation of liability and liquidated damages clauses in the China market context.
The document discusses claims that may arise under the new FIDIC Conditions of Contract, including procedures for extension of time claims, payment claims, and dispute resolution. It notes that the contractor must provide a notice of claim within 28 days of becoming aware of the issue, and must follow up within 42 days with full supporting particulars. It describes the requirements for particulars, including linking causes of delay to periods of delay and providing factual evidence like correspondence and photographs.
Rob Tolley London - Construction Surety BondsRob Tolley
Due to the significant level of risk inherent in the construction industry, many project owners ensure that they only work with contractors and subcontractors who are both licenced and bonded. This is an effective way to transfer risk and protect project owners from suffering a financial loss caused by projects taking longer than anticipated or a range of unforeseen factors.
The document discusses the employer's right of set-off under a construction contract. It defines set-off as a deduction by the employer of debt owed by the contractor. There are two pre-conditions for a set-off: 1) the contractor commits a breach of obligation and 2) fails to rectify defects as instructed. The document outlines various contract clauses where set-off can be applied if the contractor fails to meet obligations, such as failure to comply with instructions or insure works. It provides the procedures for setting off amounts, including giving notice and allowing contractor objections to be resolved by adjudication or arbitration if needed. Set-off and liquidated damages are handled separately from interim payments.
Wind_Energy_Law_2014_Amanda James_Overcoming Wind Energy Project Financing Ob...Amanda James
The document discusses key considerations for setting up the legal structure and financing of a wind energy project. It addresses:
1) Choosing an appropriate business entity that provides liability protection while optimizing tax treatment and eligibility for incentives. Common options include general partnerships, LLCs, LPs, and cooperatives.
2) Crafting long-term power purchase agreements with creditworthy utilities that specify pricing, production commitments, delivery points, default provisions, and risk allocation to provide predictable revenue essential for securing financing.
3) Negotiating other important contracts like engineering, construction, turbine supply, and O&M agreements that allocate costs, risks and warranties to support the project's viability.
Wind_Energy_Law_2014_Amanda James_Overcoming Wind Energy Project Financing Ob...
CLI ARTICLE ON SUBCONTRACTING
1. Proposals for a subcontractor’s
escape from a conditional clause
Antonios
Dimitracopoulos
Bin Shabib &
Associates, UAE
Types of conditional clauses
Conditional clauses can be broadly divided
into two categories, namely ‘pay when paid’
and, ‘pay if paid’ clauses.
Pay when paid clauses generally contain a
condition such that payment by the main
contractor to the subcontractor will be
dependent upon payment being first received
by the main contractor from the employer.
The main purpose of a pay when paid
clause is to defer payment to a point in time
The common practice is that the main contractor will contractually delegate various elements of
its works to specialist subcontractors. Such subcontractors may be sourced and chosen by the
main contractor or may be specifically nominated by the employer.
The UAE Civil Code1
at Article 8902
expressly provides for the right of the main contractor to
subcontract, provided there are no contractual terms preventing this in the main contract.
Therefore, main contractors are potentially exposed to making payments to their subcontractors
when they have not themselves received the corresponding payments from the employer.
Main contractors, therefore, often include conditional payment clauses in subcontracts so as to
confer payment related risks onto the subcontractor.
that is determined by a specific event, namely
payment by the employer to the contractor.
The occurrence of pay if paid clauses in
the UAE is relatively uncommon. In general,
whenever pay if paid clauses are included in
subcontracts internationally, they may
amount to specific wording that aims to
clarify that a shift of the risk of non-payment
has been agreed to. Instances of pay if paid
clauses, identified in primarily US cases, can
be focused particularly on clearly and
aggressively reflecting the parties’ intentions.
CONSTRUCTION LAW INTERNATIONAL Volume 10 Issue 2 June 2015 25
2. SUBCONTRACTOR’S ESCAPE
As indicated above, the intention of pay if
paid clauses depends on the eventuality
rather than on deferring the timing of
payment and to shift the risk of non-payment
from the main contractor to the
subcontractor.
UAE statutory law background to
conditional payment structures in
construction
UAE law provides a protective barrier for
the employer and confirms, in the Muqawala
section of the UAE Civil Code, Article 891,
that no claim may be addressed by the
subcontractor to the employer, save for
instances of assignment.3
This being the position, one must ask what
consideration does the subcontractor enjoy
in return for this unenviable shift in
risk-taking that conditional clauses impose?
For conditional clauses to have a fair sense
of purpose in a subcontract, the answer to
that question must revolve around the
following:
• the main contractor is obliged to adopt the
subcontractor’s claims for payment as if the
claims were its own;
• to the extent it considers the claims valid,
the main contractor must then pursue them
with the employer, again as if they were its
own; and
• any failure to do so should prohibit the
main contractor from relying on any
conditional clause, thus rendering it
directly accountable to the subcontractor.
In terms of legal authority, the concept of
conditional payments seems to fall squarely
within the ambit of Part 3, Section 1 of the
UAE Civil Code, relating to ‘Dispositions
conditional by suspension or deferment’,4
Article 428 of which supports the view that if
the performance of an obligation is subject
to a condition, then efforts must be made for
that condition to be observed.5
It is not relevant how much time has passed
since payment to the subcontractor became
due, but rather what can be proven to have
taken place during such time. This would
appear to be a more dominant driver in
determining the operation of a conditional
clause under UAE law.
By contrast, if it can be shown that no
demonstrable efforts (in the context of
Article 428) have been made to observe the
condition, then it would be arguable under
UAE law that the main contractor can no
longer rely on a conditional pay when paid
clause and that to effectively avoid making
payment to the subcontractor, it would have
to resort to more substantive defences.
As will be seen below, recent UAE
jurisprudence has indicated that, in the
presence of a conditional clause, a claim
against the main contractor based purely on
a breach of the subcontract for non-payment
is likely to fail.
UAE jurisprudence
Whilst many disputes arising out of
subcontracts will be referred to private and
confidential arbitration, there have been a
few instances where an arbitration clause was
absent and litigation ensued.
From the cases readily reported, save one
case in 1995 where a distinction was made
by the Dubai courts on whether a project
had been completed or not6
before a
conditional payment clause could be relied
upon, most subsequent cases7
upheld the
validity of a pay when paid clause and
rejected the claims filed by the
subcontractors on the basis of them being
premature.Inonesuchcase,8
theapplication
of conditional payment clauses in a
subcontract was analysed as follows:
• the contractor imposed a condition that
payments to the subcontractor would be
paid when such moneys from the employer
were paid;
• this is an obligation suspended until the
conditional fact materialised; and
• the subcontractor, therefore, did not have
the right to claim the balance of its dues
until the condition was met, that is, payment
was received by the main contractor from
the employer.
In all these cases, the subcontractor’s claims
were made on the simple basis of a breach
of contract for non-payment. They were not
based on an argument that the true breach
was that the main contractor had failed to
pursue fully the subcontractor’s claims against
When faced with a
conditional payment clause,
the subcontractor’s main
strategy in pursuing its claims
against the main contractor is
one of timing
26 CONSTRUCTION LAW INTERNATIONAL Volume 10 Issue 2 June 2015
3. the employer. Nor were they based on the
employer having rejected such claims, thus
containing the dispute strictly between the
main contractor and the subcontractor. The
subcontractor’s position was countered by a
straightforward application of Article 420 of
the UAE Civil Code,9
in that the condition
precedent (of payment by the employer) had
not yet occurred.
Alternative bases for the
subcontractor to pursue its claims
In light of the above, and given the factors set
out below, we explore two alternative bases
upon which a subcontractor can successfully
pursue its claims against the main contractor,
including whether the timing of any actions it
needs to take to achieve this:
• pay if paid clauses are relatively rare in the
UAE;
• pay when paid clauses defer the timing of
payment;
• the UAE Civil Code acknowledges that
some effort must be made for a condition
to materialise; and
• that the consideration that the
subcontractor must enjoy is the main
contractor’s obligation of pursuing the
subcontractor’s claims.
Direct payment agreements with the
employer
Although the ability for subcontractors to
successfully negotiate the terms of their
subcontract are usually very limited, we
have seen instances where nominated
subcontractors managed to extract a direct
payment obligation by the employer, at least
for certified amounts, thus bypassing the
main contractor.
This option is also envisaged by UAE
law, in the Muqawala section of the Civil
Code,10
as a possible exception to be
executed by way of assigning the obligation
to pay the subcontractor from the
contractor to the employer.
Two issues are of note in instances where
direct payment mechanisms have been
attempted in the UAE:
• thestandardobligationofthemaincontractor
to effect payment to the subcontractor (on
a pay when paid basis) is often not removed
from either of the two subcontracts; and
• court proceedings that are normally
brought by the subcontractor against both
the employer and the main contractor
have resulted in the court ordering the
subcontractor to proceed first to arbitration
under the subcontract against the main
contractor and, if that were to fail or result
in non-payment, then – and only then –
could the subcontractor proceed in court
against the employer under the direct
payment agreement.
Direct payment agreements are seldom
well-coordinated with the contents of either
the main contract or the subcontract and
commonly serve as a tool for the employer
to deflect liability for the subcontractor’s
payments onto the main contractor and
vice versa.
Lack of pursuit of subcontractor’s claims
A further option for the subcontractor
is to argue that the true breach lies in
the main contractor failing to pursue the
subcontractor’s claims against the employer
to the fullest extent permissible by law. The
instances where the subcontractor could
legitimately argue this include:
• when the employer has rejected the
subcontractor’s claim, the main contractor
has not accepted such rejection, but has
failed to pursue the matter by way of a
dispute resolution process or otherwise; or
• when the employer has deferred payment
to an indefinite point in time that can
no longer be considered reasonable and
the main contractor again fails to pursue
the matter whether by way of a dispute
resolution process or otherwise.
Article 428 of the UAE Civil Code sets out the
degree to which fulfilment of the condition
must be pursued. This lends itself to an
argument that a main contractor’s failure
to pursue the subcontractor’s claims could
effectively amount to a failure to observe the
condition (of payment by the employer) to
the maximum degree possible.
In the presence of a conditional clause, it is… unwise for the
subcontractor to commence legal proceedings against the main
contractor on the simple basis of a debt collection exercise
CONSTRUCTION LAW INTERNATIONAL Volume 10 Issue 2 June 2015 27
4. SUBCONTRACTOR’S ESCAPE
One must be mindful of the fact that main
contractors would commonly be reluctant to
start a dispute resolution process against an
employer purely in order to pursue their
subcontractors’ claims. In demonstrating such
reluctance, the main contractor may argue:
• that at the stage the subcontractor’s action
commenced, it would be unreasonable for it
(the main contractor) to have commenced
legal proceedings; or
• that this may be supported by reference
to various commercial or contractual
considerations.
Whichever option the main contractor
adopts, it is likely that if pursuit of the
subcontractor’s claim is to be argued as a
condition precedent for any conditional
SEQUENCE TIMING S/C’s REQUEST/DEMAND BASIS
A
When invoices become
overdue.
Payment of its outstanding invoices/
dues.
Contractual.
B
When negative reply is
received from main contractor
(MC) on first request.
Evidence of inclusion of its work in
monthly invoices to Employer (E).
Contractual/correspondence based.
C
Once evidence of inclusion
in monthly invoices/final
statement of accounts has
been provided.
Evidence of rejection of payment by E. Contractual/correspondence based.
D
Pay when paid (PWP): once
confirmation of E’s rejection
and MC’s agreement to this is
obtained.
Payment of dues by MC.
Legal: impossibility of condition, Article 423
of Civil Code.
E
Pay if paid (PIP)/PWP: whether
or not E has rejected payment
& whether or not MC has
contested any rejection by E.
Evidence of pursuit of payment.
Legal: lack of pursuit, Articles 420 and 428
of Civil Code.
F
Once the scope of
subcontractor’s (SC) work has
been completed.
Evidence of pursuit of payment.
Legal: lack of pursuit, Articles 420 and 428
of Civil Code.
G
Again when the project has
been handed over.
Evidence of pursuit of payment.
Legal: lack of pursuit, Articles 420 and 428
of Civil Code.
H
Again when the defects
liability period has expired.
Evidence of pursuit of payment.
Legal: lack of pursuit, Articles 420 and 428
of Civil Code.
I
When negative reply is
received from MC on the
above request.
Evidence of a legal notice issued for
amounts inclusive of the subcontractor’s
dues.
Legal: Lack of pursuit, Articles 420 and 428
of Civil Code.
J When the deadline of a legal
notice expires.
Evidence of legal proceedings having
been commenced.
Legal: Lack of pursuit, Articles 420 and 428
of Civil Code.
clause to be relied upon, then such condition
could be easily satisfied in most instances,
save for the case of the main contractor
formally commencing legal proceedings
against the employer.
Employer’s outright rejection of a
subcontractor’s claim
As indicated above, instances of an outright
rejection by the employer of a main
contractor’s claim that includes or relates to
the subcontractor’s works would convert the
question of when payment would be made to
a definite non-payment.
In terms of how this can be
accommodated within the confines of
28 CONSTRUCTION LAW INTERNATIONAL Volume 10 Issue 1 March 2015
5. UAE law, Articles 420–428 of the UAE
Civil Code deal with ‘Dispositions
conditional by suspension or deferment’,
essentially relating to conditional clauses.
The main contractor’s options in instances
of outright rejection by the employer would
be to:
• challenge the merits of the subcontractor’s
entitlement (rather than simply its timing)
and adopt arguments raised by the
employer/engineer;
• challenge the merits of the subcontractor’s
entitlement (rather than simply its timing)
and produce its own arguments for doing so;
or
• challenge the employer’s rejection,
pursuing claims that would include those
of the subcontractor.
Which option the main contractor adopts
can be of critical relevance to the application
of either a pay when paid clause or a pay if
paid clause.
Pay when paid clauses are based on a
presumption that payment would eventually
be made. They would, therefore, become
inapplicable if the employer refused to pay,
for the simple reason that for the main
contractor to rely on them, it would have to
unilaterally convert the condition of ‘when’
to a condition of ‘if/whether’.
Timing as a key factor to a
subcontractor’s strategy
When being faced with a conditional payment
clause, the subcontractor’s main strategy in
pursuing its claims against the main contractor
is one of timing. Therefore, a subcontractor
that is deprived of its dues should sequence
its approach to a conditional payment clause
by documenting its requests as follows.
Once the main contractor is forced to file a
legal action against the employer, the
subcontractor’s claims against the main
contractor are effectively carried over onto
an action against the employer. Whilst the
subcontractor can have little control over
suchproceedings(unlessthemaincontractor
encourages them to assist), the conditional
clause will have been given the purpose and
substance that the parties intended.
On the assumption that an award or
judgment is eventually issued and, despite
the main contractor’s perceived best efforts,
the subcontractor’s claims (or any part
thereof) are not awarded, the question arises
whether this would be the end of the road for
the subcontractor. The answer to this
question would depend a lot more on what
the reason is behind the employer’s
exoneration, rather than on whether the
subcontract contained a pay if paid or a pay
when paid clause.
Conclusion
In the presence of a conditional clause, it is
generally accepted that it is unwise for the
subcontractor to commence legal proceedings
against the main contractor on the simple
basis of a debt collection exercise as it is
unlikely to succeed.
Ironically, the more unopposed (by the main
contractor) a subcontractor’s claim is, the
more difficult it is to control the payment
process and the more hindered it is by a
conditional clause. Conversely, any direct
challenge to its claims by the main contractor
may block the triggering of a conditional
clause, thus making the dispute resolution
process an affair that is confined solely between
the main contractor and the subcontractor.
Finally, the question of whether a
subcontractor can pursue its claims against the
main contractor, even after the employer has
been exonerated of any liability, will depend
more on the reasons behind this, rather than
on the nature of the conditional clause.
Notes
1 Federal Law No 1/1987.
2 An English translation of which states: ‘(1) A contractor
may entrust the performance of the whole or part of
the work to another contractor unless he is prevented
from so doing by a condition of the contract, or unless
the nature of the work requires that he do it in person.
(2) The first contractor shall remain liable as towards
the employer.’
3 An English translation states that: ‘Article 891:
A sub-contractor shall have no claim against the
employer for anything due to him from the first
contractor unless he has made an assignment to him
against the employer.’
4 Arts 420–428 of the Civil Code.
5 An English translation states: ‘Article 428: A Condition
must be observed as far as is possible.’
6 Dubai Court of Cassation Case No 281 of 1995: the
distinction related to an obligation by the main
contractor to pay the subcontractor, despite a
conditional clause, if the project has been completed.
7 Dubai Court of Cassation Case No 267 of 2007, Dubai
Court of Cassation Case No 83 of 2009.
8 Dubai Court of Cassation Case No 240 of 2006.
9 An English translation of which provides that: ‘Article
420: A Condition is a future matter upon the existence
or absence of which the full effectiveness (of a
disposition) depends.’
10 Art 891, as previously mentioned.
Antonios
Dimitracopoulos
MCIArb is a partner
with Bin Shabib &
Associates, practising
in the UAE since 1995.
He is dually qualified as
a solicitor of the Senior
Courts of England &
Wales and a Greek
attorney at law and a
registered arbitrator
with the Dubai
International
Arbitration Centre. His
practice focuses on all
aspects of dispute
resolution within the
local construction
industry, often acting
for subcontractors. He
has rights of audience
before the DIFC courts
and extensive
experience in both
UAE litigation and
arbitration. He can be
contacted at antonios.
dimitracopoulos@
bsa.ae.
CONSTRUCTION LAW INTERNATIONAL Volume 10 Issue 2 June 2015 29