The Origin of the Okunev Population, Southern Siberia: The Evidence of Physical Anthropology and Genetics

Okunev cemeteries in the Minusinsk Basin were compared with 23 other pre-Andronovo series from southern Siberia, and 45 Early and Middle Bronze Age groups from Eastern Europe (24 Yamnaya and 21 Catacomb), using multivariate statistical analysis. While the Afanasyevo admixture in the Okunev population is possible, the hypothesis that the Okunev culture of the Minusinsk Basin originated from the second migration from the Eastern European steppes to southern Siberia in the Early Bronze Age is not supported. It could, however, be applied to people associated with the Okunev-type (Chaa-Khol) culture in Tuva, although these may as well have descended from the Afanasyevans. As concerns the Minusinsk Basin and other regions of southern Siberia except Tuva, the fi ndings agree with the idea of a marked evolutionary conservatism peculiar to the autochthonous populations of that territory, as evidenced by the fact that each of the three Early Bronze Age population clusters—on the Yenisei, in the Altai, and in Baraba—has its own Neolithic ancestors in the same area (this does not concern the Chaa-Khol, the Yelunino, and apparently the Samus populations). The immediate ancestors of the Okunev people can be identifi ed with the Neolithic population of the Krasnoyarsk-Kansk area, and more distant ones with the Upper Paleolithic southern Siberian common ancestors of the Okunev people and the Native Americans. These ancestors are evidenced by both cranial data (indirectly) and genetic data (directly). The la tter suggest that among these common ancestors were the Malta boy and the Afontova Gora II male. The Okunev population, then, is a relic, offering us a unique opportunity to see what the Upper Paleolithic ancestors of the Native Americans may have looked like in their southern Siberian homeland.

1. Allentoft M.E., Sikora M., Sjogren K.-G., Rasmussen M., Stenderup J., Damgaard P.B., Schroeder H., Ahlstrom T., Vinner L., Malaspinas A.-S., Margaryan A., Higham T., Chivall D., Lynnerup N., Harvig L., Baron J., Della Casa P., D^browski P., Duffy P.R., Ebel A.V., Epimakhov A., Frei K., Furmanek M., Gralak T., Gromov A., Gronkiewicz S., Grupe G., Hajdu T., Jarycz R., Khartanovich V., Khokhlov A., Kiss V., Kolar J., Kriiska A., Lasak I., Longhi C., McGlynn G., Merkevicius A., Merkyte I., Metspalu M., Mkrtchyan R., Moiseyev V., Paja L., Palfi G., Pokutta D., Pospieszny L., Price T.D., Saag L., Sablin M., Shishlina N., Smrcka V., Soenov V., Szeverenyi V., Toth G., Trifanova S.V., Varul L., Vicze M., Yepiskoposyan L., Zhitenev V., Orlando L., Sicheritz-Ponten T., Brunak S., Nielsen R., Kristiansen K., Willerslev E. 2015 Population genomics of Bronze Age Eurasia. Nature, vol. 522 (7555): 167-172.

2. Balabanova M.A. 2016 K antropologii naseleniya eneolita - rannei bronzy (po materialam mogilnikov Volgogradskoi oblasti). Nizhnevolzhskiy arkheologicheskiy vestnik, vol. 15 (1): 72-94.

3. Balanovsky O.P. 2015 Genofond Evropy. Moscow: Tovarishchestvo nauch. izd. KMK.

4. Chikisheva T.A. 2012 Dinamika antropologicheskoi differentsiatsii naseleniya yuga Zapadnoi Sibiri v epokhi neolita - rannego zheleza. Novosibirsk: Izd. IAET SO RAN.

5. Chikisheva T.A., Pozdnyakov D.V. 2019 The Physical Anthropology of the Odino People, Western Siberia. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 47 (4): 128-139.

6. Damgaard P.B., Martiniano R., Kamm J., Moreno-Mayar J.V., Kroonen G., Peyrot M., Barjamovic G., Rasmussen S., Zacho C., Baimukhanov N., Zaibert V., Merz V., Biddanda A., Merz I., Loman V., Evdokimov V., Usmanova E., Hemphill B., Seguin-Orlando A., Eylem Yediay F., Ullah I., Sjogren K.-G., H0jholt Iversen K., Choin J., de la Fuente C., Ilardo M., Schroeder H., Moiseyev V., Gromov A., Polyakov A., Omura S., Yucel Senyurt S., Ahmad H., McKenzie C., Margaryan A., Hameed A., Samad A., Gul N., Hassan Khokhar M., Goriunova O.I., Bazaliiskii V.I., Novembre J., Weber A.W., Orlando L., Allentoft M.E., Nielsen R., Kristiansen K., Sikora M., Outram A.K., Durbin R., Willerslev E. 2018 The first horse herders and the impact of Early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia. Science, vol. 360 (6396). URL: https://science.sciencemag.org/content/360/6396/eaar7711

7. Flegontov P., Changmai P., Zidkova A., Logacheva M.D., Altinisik N.E., Flegontova O., Gelfand M.S., Gerasimov E.S., Khrameeva E.E., Konovalova O.P., Neretina T., Nikolsky Y.V., Starostin G., Stepanova V.V., Travinsky I.V., Triska M., Triska P., Tatarinova T.V. 2016 Genomic study of the Ket: A Paleo-Eskimo-related ethnic group with significant Ancient North Eurasian ancestry. Scientifi c Reports, vol. 6, article No. 20768. URL: https://doi.org.10.1038/srep20768

8. Formozov A.A. 1969 Ocherki po pervobytnomu iskusstvu. Moscow: Nauka. (MIA; vol. 165).

9. Fu Q., Li H., Moorjani P., Jay F., Slepchenko S.M., Bondarev A.A., Johnson P.L.F., Aximu-Petri A., Prufer K., de Filippo C., Meyer M., Zwyns N., Salazar-Garcia D.C., Kuzmin Y.V., Keates S.G., Kosintsev P.A., Razhev D.I., Richards M.P., Peristov N.V., Lachmann M., Douka K., Higham T.F.G., Slatkin M., Hublin J.-J., Reich D., Kelso J., Viola T.B., Paabo S. 2014 Genome sequence of a 45,000-year-old modern human from Western Siberia. Nature, vol. 514 (7523): 445-449.

10. Gromov A.V. 1997 Proiskhozhdeniye i svyazi naseleniya okunevskoi kultury. In Okunevskiy sbornik. St. Petersburg: Petro-RIF, pp. 301-358.

11. Gromov A.V. 1998 K voprosu ob iskusstvennoi deformatsii cherepov okunevskoi kultury. In Sibir v panorame tysyacheletiy, vol. 1. Novosibirsk: Izd. IAET SO RAN, pp. 147-156.

12. Gromov A.V. 2002 Antropologiya naseleniya okunevskoi kultury (epokha bronzy). Cand. Sc. (History) Dissertation. St. Petersburg.

13. Haak W., Lazaridis I., Patterson N., Rohland N., Mallick S., Llamas B., Brandt G., Nordenfelt S., Harney E., Stewardson K., Fu Q., Mittnik A., Banffy E., Economou C., Francken M., Friederich S., Garrido Pena R., Hallgren F., Khartanovich V., Khokhlov A., Kunst M., Kuznetsov P., Meller H., Mochalov O., Moiseyev V., Nicklisch N., Pichler S.L., Risch R., Rojo Guerra M.A., Toth C., Szeczenyi-Nagy A., Wahl J., Meyer M., Krause J., Brown D., Anthony D., Cooper A., Alt K.W., Reich D. 2015 Massive migration from the steppe was a source for IndoEuropean languages in Europe. Nature, vol. 522 (7555): 207-211.

14. Hammer 0. 2012 PAST - Paleontological Statistics. Oslo: Univ. of Oslo. URL: https://folk.uio.no/ohammer/past/index_old.html

15. Hollard C., Zvenigorodsky V., Kovalev A., Kiryushin Y., Tishkin A., Lazaretov I., Crubezy E., Ludes B., Keyser C. 2018 New genetic evidence of affinities and discontinuities between Bronze Age Siberian populations. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 167 (1): 97-107.

16. Kazarnitsky A.A. 2012 Naseleniye azovo-kaspiyskikh stepei v epokhu bronzy (antropologicheskiy ocherk). St. Petersburg: Nauka.

17. Khokhlov A.A. 2017 Morfogeneticheskiye protsessy v Volgo-Urale v epokhu rannego golotsena (po kraniologicheskim materialam mezolita -bronzovogo veka). Samara: Izd. Samar. Gos. Sots.-Ped. Univ.

18. Kim A.M., Kozintsev A.G., Moiseyev V.G., Rohland N., Mallick S., Reich D.E. 2018 Native American relatives in Bronze Age southern Siberia? Okunev Culture and the new dialogue of genome-wide ancient DNA and physical anthropology. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 165, suppl. 66: 139.

19. Kozintsev A.G. 1976 Naseleniye Minusinskogo kraya epokhi bronzy i ego rol v formirovanii antropologicheskogo sostava narodov Zapadnoi Sibiri. Voprosy antropologii, No. 54: 180-189.

20. Kozintsev A.G. 2004 Kety, uraltsy, “amerikanoidy”: Integratsiya kraniometricheskikh i kranioskopicheskikh dannykh. In Paleoantropologiya, etnicheskaya antropologiya, etnogenez: K 75-letiyu Ilyi Iosifovicha Gokhmana. St. Petersburg: MAE RAN, pp. 172-185.

21. Kozintsev A.G. 2008 The “Mediterraneans” of Southern Siberia and Kazakhstan, Indo-European migrations, and the origin of the Scythians: A multivariate craniometric analysis. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 36 (4): 140-144.

22. Kozintsev A.G. 2009 Craniometric evidence of the Early Caucasoid migrations to Siberia and Eastern Central Asia, with reference to the IndoEuropean problem. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 37 (4): 125-136.

23. Kozintsev A.G., Gromov A.V., Moiseyev V.G. 1995 Amerikanoidy na Yenisee? (Antropologicheskiye paralleli odnoi gipoteze). In Problemy izucheniya okunevskoi kultury: Tezisy dokl. konf. St. Petersburg: MAE RAN, pp. 74-77.

24. Kozintsev A.G., Gromov A.V., Moiseyev V.G. 1999 Collateral relatives of American Indians among the Bronze Age populations of Siberia? American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 108 (2): 193-204.

25. Kozintsev A.G., Gromov A.V., Moiseyev V.G. 2003 New evidence on the possible collateral relatives of American Indians in Bronze Age Siberia. Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia, No. 3 (15): 149-154.

26. Kozintsev A.G., Selezneva V.I. 2015 Vtoraya volna migratsii evropeoidov v Yuzhnuyu Sibir i Tsentralnuyu Aziyu. In Radlovskiy sbornik: Nauchnye issledovaniya i muzeinye proekty MAE RAN v 2014 g. St. Petersburg: MAE RAN, pp. 51-62.

27. Kruts S.I. 2017 Skify stepei Ukrainy po antropologicheskim dannym. Kiev, Berlin: Izdatel Oleg Filyuk. (Kurgany Ukrainy; vol. 5).

28. Lazaretov I.P. 1997 Okunevskiye mogilniki v doline r. Uibat. In Okunevskiy sbornik. St. Petersburg: Petro-RIF, pp. 19-64.

29. Lazaretov I.P. 2019 Khronologiya i periodizatsiya okunevskoi kultury: Sovremennoye sostoyaniye i perspektivy. Teoriya i praktika arkheologicheskikh issledovaniy, No. 4: 15-50.

30. Lazaretov I.P., Polyakov A.V. 2018 Issledovaniya mogilnika Uibat-Charkov i novye dannye o rannem etape razvitiya okunevskoi kultury. Teoriya i praktika arkheologicheskikh issledovaniy, No. 3: 41-69.

31. Lazaretov I.P., Polyakov A.V., Esin Y.N., Lazaretova N.I. 2012 Novye dannye po formirovaniyu okunevskogo kulturnogo fenomena. In Istoriko-kulturnoye naslediye i dukhovnye tsennosti Rossii. Moscow: ROSSPEN, pp. 130-136.

32. Lipsky A.N. 1969 Amerikanoidy na Yenisee. In Proiskhozhdeniye aborigenov Sibiri i ikh yazykov. Tomsk: Izd. Tom. Gos. Univ., pp. 155-159.

33. Maksimenkov G.A. 1975 Okunevskaya kultura. D. Sc. (History) Dissertation. Novosibirsk.

34. Nelson G.C., Madimenos F.C. 2010 Obelionic cranial deformation in the Puebloan Southwest. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 143 (3): 465-472.

35. Polyakov A.V. 2017 Sovremennaya khronologiya pamyatnikov eneolita i epokhi bronzy Minusinskikh kotlovin. In Petroglify Tsentralnoi Azii i Severnogo Kitaya. Ulaanbaatar: Admon print, pp. 187-211.

36. Polyakov A.V. 2019 Obzor rezultatov nachalnogo etapa paleogeneticheskikh issledovaniy naseleniya epokhi bronzy Minusinskikh kotlovin. Teoriya i praktika arkheologicheskikh issledovaniy, No. 2: 91-108.

37. Polyakov A.V. 2020a Pogrebeniya katakombnogo tipa v materialakh okunevskoi kultury. Arkheologicheskiye vesti, No. 26: 98-110.

38. Polyakov A.V. 2020b Problema slozheniya okunevskoi kultury v svete sovremennykh nauchnykh dannykh. Nauchnoye obozreniye Sayano-Altaya, No. 1: 3-6.

39. Raghavan M., Skoglund P., Graf K.E., Metspalu M., Albrechtsen A., Moltke I., Rasmussen S., Stafford T.W., Orlando L., Metspalu E., Karmin M., Tambets K., Rootsi S., Magi R., Campos P.F., Balanovska E., Balanovsky O.P., Khusnutdinova E., Litvinov S., Osipova L.P., Fedorova S.A., Voevoda M.I., DeGiorgio M., Sicheritz-Ponten T., Brunak S., Demeshchenko S., Kivisild T., Villems R., Nielsen R., Jakobsson M., Willerslev E. 2014 Upper Paleolithic Siberian genome reveals dual ancestry of Native Americans. Nature, vol. 505 (7481): 87-91.

40. Romanova G.P. 1991 Paleoantropologicheskiye materialy iz stepnykh rayonov Stavropolya epokhi rannei i srednei bronzy. Sovetskaya arkheologiya, No. 2: 160-170.

41. Sokolova L.A. 2009 Formirovaniye okunevskogo kulturnogo kompleksa. Cand. Sc. (History) Dissertation. St. Petersburg.

42. Solodovnikov K.N. 2007 K voprosu o roli evropeoidnogo komponenta v rasogeneze naseleniya Altae-Sayanskogo nagorya epokhi rannei i razvitoi bronzy. In Altae-Sayanskaya gornaya strana i istoriya osvoeniya ee kochevnikami. Barnaul: Izd. Alt. Gos. Univ., pp. 145-150.

43. Solodovnikov K.N. 2009 Antropologicheskiye materialy afanasyevskoi kultury: K probleme proiskhozhdeniya. Vestnik antropologii, No. 17: 117-135.

44. Solodovnikov K.N., Tur S.S. 2003 Kraniologicheskiye materialy eluninskoi kultury epokhi rannei bronzy Verkhnego Priobya. In Kiryushin Y.F., Grushin S.P., Tishkin A.A. Pogrebalnyi obryad naseleniya epokhi rannei bronzy Verkhnego Priobya (po materialam gruntovogo mogilnika Teleutskiy Vzvoz I). Barnaul: Izd. Alt. Gos. Univ., pp. 142-176.

45. Vadetskaya E.B., Leontyev N.V., Maksimenkov G.A. 1980 Pamyatniki okunevskoi kultury. Leningrad: Nauka.

46. Vasilyev S.A., Berezkin Y.E., Kozintsev A.G., Peiros I.I., Slobodin S.B., Tabarev A.V. 2015 Zaseleniye chelovekom Novogo Sveta: Opyt kompleksnogo issledovaniya. St. Petersburg: Nestor-Istoriya.

47. Zacho C.G. 2016 Population Genomics of the Bronze Age Okunevo Culture: Master Thesis. Copenhagen: Univ. of Copenhagen.