www.fgks.org   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

You might be using an unsupported or outdated browser. To get the best possible experience please use the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Microsoft Edge to view this website.

3.0
Our ratings take into account the card’s rewards, fees, rates along with the card’s category. All ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.

WHY WE PICKED IT
Read More

SCROLL TO SITE

Best Online Brokers for Day Trading 2021

Contributor,  Editor

Published: Jun 1, 2021, 1:15pm

Editorial Note: Forbes Advisor may earn a commission on sales made from partner links on this page, but that doesn't affect our editors' opinions or evaluations.

Professional traders are a demanding bunch. That’s because the margin between success and failure in markets can be paper thin—and having the right trading platform can make all the difference.

Day traders earn their living by entering and closing out multiple trades in a day in pursuit of profits. This strategy requires fast and reliable trade execution, the lowest possible commissions and access to customer service when things go awry.

Forbes Advisor evaluated a total of 21 online brokerage platforms in order to help you choose the best online brokers for day trading. Our side-by-side tests placed the greatest importance on low commissions and fees, best-in-class platform and technology and highly responsive customer service to find the best trading platforms available.

Read more

Best Online Broker for Day Trading

Interactive Brokers

Interactive Brokers
4.6
Our ratings take into account the range of fees, features and tools offered by each online broker platform. Ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.

Tiered trading commissions

$0.0005 to $0.0035

per share

Account minimum

$0

Interactive Brokers
Open Account
Via InteractiveBrokers' Secure Website

Tiered trading commissions

$0.0005 to $0.0035

per share

Account minimum

$0

Why We Picked It

Interactive Brokers earned the top spot in our listing thanks to its powerful Trader Workstation platform, easy access to a vast selection of global markets and rock-bottom trading commissions. These features and more make Interactive Brokers the preferred trading platform for professionals at hedge funds and investment firms.

In our research, we found that Interactive Brokers stood out by charging substantially lower fees than its rivals in several areas. It’s IBKR Pro tiered pricing plan offers better rates for direct access trading than other leading trading platforms for professionals. We also noted lower commissions for futures trading, and the lowest margin rates among the platforms we surveyed.

Note that $0 stock commissions are available on Interactive Brokers’s IBKR Lite platform for non-professional traders.

We were impressed by the flagship Trader WorkStation platform and the quality of order execution. Trader WorkStation offers highly customizable alerts, watchlists and sophisticated charting. It features advanced order types. Traders can stay on top of the news with the latest reports from Reuters, Dow Jones and a variety of other sources on the platform.

Trader WorkStation includes essential features for day traders, such as hot keys, which allow traders to rapidly place preset orders with the stroke of a single key. Traders also have access to Level 2 quotes, which show the best bid and ask prices from each market participant. Time and sales data, sometimes known as “the tape” is also available. This is a streaming record of all stock transactions made throughout the trading day, including trade size, price and time.

A total of 135 markets in 33 countries are available for trading. Interactive Brokers clients can trade global stocks, options, futures, currencies, bonds and funds all from a single platform.

Accounts can be funded in multiple currencies and assets can be denominated in multiple currencies. Clients can trade a dizzying range of markets—from stocks on the Mexican Stock Exchange to futures on Italy’s Borsa Italiana. Penny stocks and fractional share trading are also available.

Quality of order execution is of paramount importance to day traders. Direct market access is available for both stocks and options, allowing traders to decide how they want their orders to be routed.

To facilitate optimal order execution, Interactive Brokers created a software product called Smart Routing, which continually scans competing markets and automatically routes orders directly to the best ECN or market center.

IHS Markit, a third-party provider of transaction analysis, determined that Interactive Brokers’ US stock price executions were significantly better than industry rivals during the first half of 2020; with a net price improvement of $0.62 versus an industry average of $0.15.

Pros & Cons
  • The Trader Workstation platform is robust and feature rich.
  • Interactive Brokers offers highly reliable trade execution.
  • Charges low commissions and fees, and offers the lowest margin rates in our tests.
  • Customer service can be hard to reach.
  • IBKR Pro option charges a monthly maintenance fee.
  • The tiered pricing plans are somewhat complex.

Best Day Trading Platform for Education

TD Ameritrade

TD Ameritrade
4.3
Our ratings take into account the range of fees, features and tools offered by each online broker platform. Ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.

Tiered trading commissions

$0

Account minimum

$0

TD Ameritrade
Open Account
Via TD Ameritrade's Secure Website

Tiered trading commissions

$0

Account minimum

$0

Why We Picked It

TD Ameritrade has top rankings in our listing of the best online brokers for its mobile app and its beginner-friendly options. The latter can also pertain to new day traders learning the ropes, since TD Ameritrade has the most extensive educational resources of any day trading platform in our survey.

TD Ameritrade’s education center includes in-depth coverage of technical analysis and different day-trading strategies. For example, you’ll find material on topics including momentum trading and how to trade using Fibonacci retracements, pivot points and classic chart patterns.

Educational content is offered in multiple formats, ranging from immersive courses to videos, articles, webcasts and even live events.

Paper trading is an excellent tool for testing and refining your plan of action in the market. The paperMoney simulator on the thinkorswim platform allows you to apply your day trading strategies in live market conditions without risk. Scanners within the platform are available to identify interesting stocks for day trading.

TD Ameritrade offers what it calls advanced order routing technology, and the majority of market orders executed are filled at a better price than the nationally published quote. However, this broker receives payment for order flow and direct routing for equities orders is not currently available.

Pros & Cons
  • Plenty of In-depth educational resources for new day traders.
  • Thinkorswim platform is free.
  • Paper trading is available.
  • Does not offer direct access trading for stocks.
  • Some fees are slightly higher than peers.
  • Does not offer fractional shares.

Best Online Broker for Trade Execution

Lightspeed Trading

Lightspeed Trading
4.0
Our ratings take into account the range of fees, features and tools offered by each online broker platform. Ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.

Tiered trading commissions

$0.0010 to $0.0045

per share

Account minimum

$10,000

Lightspeed Trading

Tiered trading commissions

$0.0010 to $0.0045

per share

Account minimum

$10,000

Why We Picked It

In the world of day trading, a split second can make the difference between a profitable trade and a loss. As its name suggests, Lightspeed Trading has worked hard to ensure that customers can execute their trades and receive market data as rapidly as possible, with a tight focus on serving professional and institutional traders.

The Lightspeed Trader platform has been stripped down to focus on data and order execution, without unnecessary bells and whistles. The platform is ultra-low latency, highly stable and intimately customizable. The technology and features of Lightspeed Trading are designed to enable traders to seize market opportunities lightning fast.

Scanners are a key tool that helps day traders find volatile stocks or stocks that are near key price levels. Lightspeed’s scanner, Lightscan, offers unique analytical tools, such as net change (the change from beginning of the period to last price) and H/L (showing whether the stock is currently at the high or low of the period). Another useful feature is Lightspeed’s scanner for block trades, which allows you to track the activity of large traders and institutions by scanning for sizable trades.

Time and sales data and Level 2 quotes are available for both stocks and options. The platform has a short location feature that indicates whether a stock is easy to borrow for short trading, would require extra effort to locate or is not available at all for borrowing. The Social Sentiment tool leverages data from Twitter and social media to capture financial market sentiment about a specific security.

As a direct access broker, customer orders can be routed to over 100 destinations, including exchanges, market makers and dark pools. Orders can be configured and executed efficiently with keyboard shortcut hot keys. Charts are also optimized for speed.

Lightspeed performed well in our customer service tests. We were able to quickly reach a representative and not left on hold. Their team offers personalized support, and clients can choose to be assigned an account representative to work directly with them.

New account promotions are sometimes offered, such as a three month special where clients get a 50% rebate on their commissions. After three months, a lump sum in cash is given for half of the commissions generated.

Pros & Cons
  • Fast and reliable execution of trades.
  • Powerful scanners geared to day trading.
  • Dependable customer service.
  • High minimum account balance.
  • Limited educational and research materials.
  • Commissions and fees could be lower.

Best Day Trading Platform for Customer Service

Cobra

Cobra
4.0
Our ratings take into account the range of fees, features and tools offered by each online broker platform. Ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.

Tiered trading commissions

$0.002 to $0.004

per share

Account minimum

$5,000

Cobra

Tiered trading commissions

$0.002 to $0.004

per share

Account minimum

$5,000

Why We Picked It

Founded in 2003, Cobra Trading is geared toward professional and institutional traders. Cobra Trading shines in several areas, including short selling, commission rates and customer service.

In our tests customer service was very good across the board. We received fast, helpful responses via phone, email and human chat. Unlike the larger firms there is no need to navigate various automated menus before reaching a live representative.

The human operated chat is very convenient and something that rival Lightspeed Trading lacks. All of the customer service agents at Cobra Trading are licensed professionals, many with substantial trading industry experience.

Cobra’s day trading platform, TraderPro, is well equipped with advanced charting capabilities. It features Level 2 quotes, hot keys and a locator to find stocks to borrow for short trading. TraderPro offers a decent level of customizable features for trading alerts, news and watch lists.

One downside to watch out for are platform fees. Unless you trade more than 200,000 shares per month, you will need to pay a $100 monthly fee for the TraderPro platform. In order to get direct order routing options, you’ll pay $125 a month for Cobra’s DAS Trader Pro—this fee is waived if you trade 250,000 shares a month. Other platform features may also incur fees unless monthly trading volume minimums are met.

Pros & Cons
  • Phone support calls answered fast.
  • Free broker assisted trades.
  • Knowledgeable, highly trained customer service reps.
  • Support is not 24/7.
  • High minimum deposit.
  • Substantial platform fees.

Best Day Trading Platform for Strategy

TradeStation

TradeStation
3.7
Our ratings take into account the range of fees, features and tools offered by each online broker platform. Ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.

Tiered trading commissions

$0

Account minimum

$2,000

TradeStation

Tiered trading commissions

$0

Account minimum

$2,000

Why We Picked It

TradeStation gets an honorable mention in our listing, thanks to its combination of long-tested trading technology and in-depth research resources. Since the late 1980s, TradeStation—then called Omega Research—has been known for powerful tools that let day traders develop and back-test their trading strategies against historical market data and generate buy and sell alerts.

The TradeStation desktop platform lets day traders back-test, optimize and fully automate their trading strategies in the stock and futures markets. Trading strategy back-testing can draw from over 50 years of historical daily price data.

The TradeStation platform makes it easy to test strategies across different time frames and provides a wealth of statistical data in the performance report, including key metrics such as profit factor and maximum drawdown.

One of the platform’s unique features is EasyLanguage, a simple programming language which can be used to create powerful trading indicators, strategies and custom trading applications using English-like statements. This feature is unique among the ones offered by professional trading platforms.

Pros & Cons
  • Excellent day trading strategy development tools.
  • Supports excellent research and education resources.
  • Rock-bottom trading commissions.
  • Receives payment for order flow.
  • Minimum balance of $2,000 required for TradeStation desktop platform.
  • Customer service was inconsistent in our tests.

Best Day Trading Platform for Short Selling

Cobra

Cobra
4.0
Our ratings take into account the range of fees, features and tools offered by each online broker platform. Ratings are determined solely by our editorial team.

Tiered trading commissions

$0.002 to $0.004

per share

Account minimum

$5,000

Cobra

Tiered trading commissions

$0.002 to $0.004

per share

Account minimum

$5,000

Why We Picked It

Short selling is a key strategy deployed by day traders. Cobra Trading is geared towards the needs of professional day traders in the equities and options markets. They also offer futures trading through their Venom Trading division. Cobra Trading offers a strong range of platforms, competitive commission rates and reliable customer support.

One area where Cobra Trading stands out is in making it easy to short sell low priced securities and penny stocks. Easy to Borrow (ETB) lists are regularly updated by brokerage firms and made up of highly liquid stocks that can be sold short immediately. However, some stocks favored by day traders are not so readily available for short selling. These are often small cap or penny stocks that are attractive in part because they are highly volatile.

Cobra Trading has access to multiple locate sources including those of their clearing firm, Wedbush Securities, which has free HTB (hard to borrow) locates. Locate sources are the various securities lending firms where clients can locate and borrow hard to borrow shares. The DAS trading platform offered by Cobra Trading has a locate monitor window where you can check inventory from four different locate sources. Having multiple sources gives traders a better chance of being able to find the shares they may be targeting for selling short.

Pros & Cons
  • Multiple short locate sources.
  • Good customer service.
  • Competitive commissions.
  • Substantial platform fee.
  • High minimum account balance.
  • Does not offer international markets.

Methodology

Forbes Advisor exhaustively tested 21 of the leading US online brokerage services in our search for the best day trading platform. We conducted a hands-on, six-month survey that compared hundreds of variables across six major categories: commissions and fees, platform and technology, range of product offerings, research and education, account security and customer service.

We opened live accounts and performed in-depth assessments of the broker platforms and their services. Testing was led by a seasoned trading industry professional.

In choosing the best brokers for day trading, we placed the greatest emphasis on the categories of commissions and fees, platform and technology and customer service. We carefully compared the commission rates, platform fees and account-related costs on the leading platforms.

When testing brokerages, we looked for tools specifically helpful to day traders, like advanced charting and order types, and rapid trade execution. In our customer service tests, we measured the time it took to get a response over the phone, by live chat and by email. We also took into account how well informed and helpful the representatives were and whether they held relevant financial licenses.


What Is Day Trading?

Day traders enter and exit trades multiple times on any given day to capture profits from short-term price movements in assets like stocks, bonds and exchange traded funds (ETFs). They typically close all trades by the end of the day, avoiding the risk of holding market positions open overnight.

Day trading entered the mainstream during the dot-com market boom and bust of the late 1990s, and saw a resurgence of popularity during the Covid-19 pandemic.

Once the exclusive domain of Wall Street firms and professional investors, online brokerage platforms have made day trading accessible to anyone with time, money and the willingness to learn the ropes.


What Do Professional Traders Look for in an Online Broker?

The key factors necessary to succeed in day trading are fast, reliable execution of trades and the lowest possible trading commissions. A day trader can have a majority of winning trades, yet still lose money at the end of the day if their commissions outweigh their profits. Since day traders are continually buying and selling assets, they may rack up substantial costs in the form of trading commissions.

Similarly, optimal execution of orders is essential. Getting in and out of the market and taking small profits continually throughout the day requires efficient order execution. During fast-moving market conditions, such as at the market open or just after an important piece of news has been released, it’s especially important to be working with a broker that can provide reliable order execution.

Finally, if there is a technical outage or any other trading difficulty, traders must be able to reach customer service fast to make sure that they can get out of the market and manage their risk exposure. Brokers with the best customer service will have both phone and chat support available without little to no wait times.


Direct Access Brokers vs. Brokers Selling Order Flow

Since fast trade execution is essential for day trading, professionals prefer online brokers that offer direct access to markets. Direct access brokers allow traders to directly route their orders to specific exchanges, electronic communication networks (ECNs), market makers and dark pools. The freedom to choose how orders are routed can provide access to more liquidity and faster execution.

But direct access to markets costs money, and that’s why direct access brokerage platforms charge commissions—unlike many of the more well-known online brokerages. When stock, bond and ETF commissions are zero, that suggests that an online brokerage is being paid third-party commissions to route order flow to specific middlemen. This typically results in slower trade execution, but it allows for those attractive $0 commissions.


The Risks and Rewards of Day Trading

While it’s notoriously difficult, day trading can yield large rewards for the minority that manage to succeed over time. Increasingly efficient markets and the rise of algorithmic and high-frequency trading have made day trading harder for individuals.

Studies indicate that algorithmic trading has recently accounted as much as 60% to 73% of all equities trading in the United States. To a greater extent, individual ‘point and click’ traders are now competing against formidable machines.

Counterbalancing this is the fact that never before have such powerful platforms, tools and data been available for independent day traders.

Minimum deposits have largely fallen to $0 for investors at leading online brokers. However, higher minimum deposit requirements are required for day traders. In the United States, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) requires that “pattern day traders” must have an equity balance of at least $25,000 in a margin account.

A person is marked as a pattern day trader if they trade four or more times in five business days and their day-trading activities are greater than 6% of their trading activity for that same five-day period.


Next Up in Investing


Forbes Advisor adheres to strict editorial integrity standards. To the best of our knowledge, all content is accurate as of the date posted, though offers contained herein may no longer be available. The opinions expressed are the author’s alone and have not been provided, approved, or otherwise endorsed by our partners.
The Forbes Advisor editorial team is independent and objective. To help support our reporting work, and to continue our ability to provide this content for free to our readers, we receive compensation from the companies that advertise on the Forbes Advisor site. This compensation comes from two main sources. First, we provide paid placements to advertisers to present their offers. The compensation we receive for those placements affects how and where advertisers’ offers appear on the site. This site does not include all companies or products available within the market. Second, we also include links to advertisers’ offers in some of our articles; these “affiliate links” may generate income for our site when you click on them. The compensation we receive from advertisers does not influence the recommendations or advice our editorial team provides in our articles or otherwise impact any of the editorial content on Forbes Advisor. While we work hard to provide accurate and up to date information that we think you will find relevant, Forbes Advisor does not and cannot guarantee that any information provided is complete and makes no representations or warranties in connection thereto, nor to the accuracy or applicability thereof. Here is a list of our partners who offer products that we have affiliate links for.
lorem
Are you sure you want to rest your choices?