Bhimaprasad Maiti

A great lens,using since 2008.

N0 response from Mr.Host ,as usual.He throws up a Challenge,but when challenged he had no response - perhpaps.

Mr.Jack Simpson,Introspection is the base of each human being.Every one should realise that before making any remark at least Mr.Host,Bill Thoo is certainly aware of it, I presume.

Mr.Jack Simpson,Though your photo was simply great by any standard,your abstract composition was beyond the usual voters of the challenge theme ,not to speak of the Hosts.So it got 99 th position....

Yes, provided you please clearly state/clarify what you convey in your Theme Challenge.Is there any scope for disagreements?

No, your thinking is wrong,as you have strong reservation on your judgement on disqualifications as ultimately you could not justify.

Not many like the one ranking 99 th position.Perhaps the voters were not given due inputs on Abstract landscape on sun rise sun set shots or the Host had not adhered to his Challenge theme.

Mr.Host,Pl respond ,particularly ,to the last line.

Mr.Host, the Challenge I faced is/was one of exposure of cross light and the subject.There were confusion of human elements mutually confronting each other ,It was a candid shot and simplification...

Placed 50^th in the challenge. in full boom as winter wanes and spring sets in

Mr,Host,Your contradiction in statement is pointed out only. Are not covering the gap.

Mr.Host,what a contradictory statement your last lines meant.Are you o.k.

Mr.Bren, the better definition will the ledge of land protuding into the water of sea / bay not visible in high tide.That was my submission. Pl. confirm your mistake

Placed 45^th in the challenge. on head,at a fashion show ,Kolkata,Vintage car Rally,India

Me Host,pl. respond.

Placed 67^th in the challenge. People activities around the Clock Tower,Sribhumi,Kolkata,India

Mr.Host, most of all the photos so far exhibited in your challenge programme,suffer from horizon syndrome,be it mountain,or other wise.Pl.justify your disqualification notice as tree lines in...

It is intriguing to note that the Host has disqualifies the shot on ground of no location mention,although it was mentioned in Exif data

Placed 39^th in the challenge. Green frond of Palm tree

Placed 47^th in the challenge. Challenge-Moon surface-post processing skill