Laura Cumming’s top 10 art shows of 2014

All human life was on show at the staggering Late Rembrandt exhibition, and there were revelatory, revolutionary works elsewhere by Ai Weiwei, Mondrian, Matisse and Malevich


• Jonathan Jones’s top 10 art shows of 2014
• Adrian Searle’s top 10 art exhibitions of 2014

laura cumming top 10 art shows
Six of the best … clockwise from top left, Rembrandt; Malevich; Alan Beeton, from The History of the Mannequin; Amar Kanwar, from Generation; Matisse; Salvador Dalí with mannequin. Picture credits: The National Gallery; The Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge; Amar Kanwar/Marian Goodman Gallery; Succession Henri Matisse

1. Rembrandt: The Late Works | National Gallery, London

This was staggering: the kind of show you never ever expect to see, for which museums all over the world yield up their most treasured possessions just so that the gallery-goers of one country can witness Rembrandt’s last decade in all its concentrated intensity.

It set countless masterworks before you, from the overwhelming tenderness of The Jewish Bride to the fantastically alert Syndics, each one eyeballing the viewer from a different direction; from the tragic Anatomy Lesson to the haunting nightmare of Lucretia about to stab herself (not once but twice, in before-and-after pictures), knife in hand, sleepwalking towards death.

Rembrandt The Anatomy Lesson of Dr Joan Deyman, 1656
Pinterest
Tragic … The Anatomy Lesson of Dr Joan Deyman, 1656. Photograph: Amsterdam Museum

There were surprises throughout, though, no matter how well you thought you knew Rembrandt. Sweden sent a picture never shown in Britain before: The Conspiracy of the Batavians Under Claudius Civilis, which stopped visitors in their tracks with its shadow-play of raw-faced warriors illuminated from below and dominated by the towering Civilis, who had one eye working but the other a horrendous gaping socket. It was a commission for Amsterdam town hall, but Rembrandt wouldn’t compromise on the outlandishness of the picture. He was never paid; the picture was taken down almost immediately.

This defiance was everywhere apparent at the National Gallery: in the magnificent impasto of the husband’s sleeve in The Jewish Bride, nubs of paint fully an inch thick, but setting off such a twinkling interplay of golden-yellow light; in the strange, rheumy-eyed Christ child looking up at Saint Simeon in the freezing cold of Christmas; in the weird self-portrait at the start, a tiny etching in which Rembrandt shows himself pig-eyed, flaccid and confused, otherwise nearly faceless where he has simply wiped himself out of the plate.

There was an unexpected intimacy to the whole event. It showed Rembrandt out in the countryside – from which he seems to recoil – in tiny drawings; visiting his friends and neighbours in their diamond-paned Amsterdam homes; taking a boat to sketch the corpse of a maid, dangling pitifully from the gallows.

But I couldn’t help circling back to the self-portraits in the first room time and again, with their inexhaustible range of emotional nuance. They represent the fons et origo of everything to come: the artist in all his doubt, courage, shambolic pathos, humanity, profundity, shrewdness, sadness and power. This was an exemplary show of an exemplary master of all human life. It continues until 18 January: catch it while you can.

2. Henri Matisse: The Cut-outs | Tate Modern, London

The late great scissor works in the most comprehensive showing ever were a joy from first to last. And the ultimate generosity of Matisse’s cut-outs was to inspire the artist in every one of us.

The Snail, 1953, by Henri Matisse.
Pinterest
The Snail, 1953, by Henri Matisse. Photograph: Succession Henri Matisse/DACS

3. Giovanni Battista Moroni | Royal Academy, London

Anyone who’s watched the 16th-century Italian painter Moroni gradually reaching centre stage at the National Gallery over the years will have been hungry for this show. It didn’t disappoint: marvellously acute portraits that establish a mutual exchange between sitter and viewer half a century before Velázquez.

The Tailor, 1565-70, by Giovanni Battista Moroni.
Pinterest
Marvellously accute: The Tailor, 1565-70, by Giovanni Battista Moroni. Photograph: The National Gallery, London

4. Veronese | National Gallery, London

For sheer uprush, there was nothing to beat the first (and possibly the last) Veronese show in Britain in this lifetime. Brilliant colour, light and drama; figures surging upwards through space.

The Supper at Emmaus, c 1555, by Veronese.
Pinterest
The Supper at Emmaus, c 1555, by Veronese. Photograph: Musée du Louvre/Gérard Blot

5. Malevich | Tate Modern, London

From the epiphany of abstraction – the revolutionary Black Square presented exactly as it was first shown in 1915 – to the desperate later years, when Malevich was forced back into figuration, this was an exemplary show. Huge, historic, and unexpectedly moving.

Revolutionary … Black Square, 1915, by Kazimir Malevich.
Pinterest
Revolutionary … Black Square, 1915, by Kazimir Malevich. Photograph: Heritage Images/Heritage Images/Getty Images

6. Silent Partners | Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge

The best curating I’ve seen all year, in a show devoted to the uses and abuses of mannequins in art – from early Renaissance models to mutant Chapman children. The focus on these queer quasi-sculptural surrogates revealed so much about the making of art, and the minds of the artists themselves.

Salvador Dalí with mannequin
Pinterest
Figure-hugging … Salvador Dalí with artist’s mannequin, photographed by Denise Bellon at the 1938 International Exhibition of Surrealism, Paris. Photograph: Les Films de l'Équinoxe-Fonds/Denise Bellon

7. Emily Carr | Dulwich Picture Gallery

Emily Carr, Canada’s best-kept secret, came as a genuine revelation: a painter of such passion, power and singularity that her landscapes of Northern Canada had something of Van Gogh’s intensity. She lived in the forests of her paintings and you can practically hear the wind whistling through her work.

Sea and Sky, 1936, by Emily Carr.
Sea and Sky, 1936, by Emily Carr. Photograph: Dulwich Picture Gallery

8. Ai Weiwei | Blenheim Palace and Yorkshire Sculpture Park

Ai was everywhere this year, and it’s hard to choose between the eloquent austerity of his urns, stools and ceramic crabs in the baroque splendour of Blenheim or the outdoor sculptures in Yorkshire. But his Iron Tree, with its lichen of ochre rust, its parts cast from branches gathered by people all over China, its message of hopeful unity, stood highest.

Iron Tree, 2013, by Ai Weiwei, in Yorkshire Sculpture Park.
Pinterest
Standing tall … Iron Tree, 2013, by Ai Weiwei, in Yorkshire Sculpture Park.

9. Mondrian and Colour | Turner Margate

We’re not supposed to admire pre-grid Mondrian, but this beautiful selection of early landscapes from Belgium showed the priggishness of that convention. Mondrian could make the sky sing and the sea catch fire with the most counterintuitive of colours.

Dune Landscape, 1911, by Piet Mondrian
Pinterest
Dune Landscape, 1911, by Piet Mondrian. Photograph: Mondrian/Holtzman Trust

10. Generation: 25 Years of Contemporary Art in Scotland | Various venues

This massive one-nation survey was all over the place in both respects: a chaotic miscellany of shows running from the Borders right up to Lewis. But there were great individual works, particularly films by Torsten Lauschmann and Amar Kanwar.

The Scene of the Crime, 2011, by Amar Kanwar
Pinterest
The Scene of the Crime, 2011, by Amar Kanwar. Photograph: courtesy of Amar Kanwar and Marian Goodman Gallery Paris/New York
Trail