- News
- Images
-
Voices
-
Find by writer
- Yasmin Alibhai-Brown
- Rebecca Armstrong
- Memphis Barker
- Terence Blacker
- Chris Blackhurst
- David Blanchflower
- Archie Bland
- Chris Bryant
- Ian Burrell
- Andrew Buncombe
- Ben Chu
- Patrick Cockburn
- Laura Davis
- Mary Dejevsky
- Grace Dent
- Robert Fisk
- Andrew Grice
- Stefano Hatfield
- Philip Hensher
- Ian Herbert
- Howard Jacobson
- Ellen E Jones
- Alice Jones
- Owen Jones
- Simon Kelner
- Dominic Lawson
- Donald MacInnes
- Donald Macintyre
- Lisa Markwell
- Michael McCarthy
- Hamish McRae
- Jane Merrick
- James Moore
- Matthew Norman
- Dom Joly
- Amol Rajan
- Comment
- Campaigns
- Editorials
- Letters
- IV Drip
- Archive
- Our Voices
- Commentators
- Columnists
- Democracy 2015
- IV Drip Archive
- Blogs
-
Find by writer
- Sport
- world cup hub
- Tech
- Life
- Property
- Arts + Ents
- Travel
- Money
- IndyBest
- Student
Wednesday 26 February 2014
Owen Jones: Socialism’s critics look at Venezuela and say, ‘We told you so’. But they are wrong
The democratic credentials of the post-Chavez government are being maligned
I once wrote about the “hierarchy of death” - the macabre process by which the newsworthiness of death is ranked. The fame or influence of the deceased; whether they are a Westerner or not; the colour of their skin; whether they are affluent or poor: all are crucial factors. But the perceived political significance of death is important too, as the latest wave of political turbulence in Venezuela illustrates.
Here's the right-wing narrative. The Venezuelan people have taken to the streets in huge numbers against a human rights-abusing regime. The response has been murderous repression, with each death damning evidence of a monstrous autocracy. The government's economic policies have caused nothing but ruination for the population, demonstrating once again that “socialism” is an abject failure. Those who challenge this narrative, like myself, are nothing but dupes, useful idiots, the modern-day equivalents of the Fabians who went to Stalin's Soviet Union and lauded it as a new civilisation.
So let's have some context. Before Hugo Chavez was elected President in 1998, Venezuela was ruled by various neo-liberal administrations. In 1975, 15 per cent of Venezuelans lived in poverty; two decades later, it had surged to 45 per cent. When Venezuelans protested against the then President Pérez - who U-turned on election pledges to abandon neo-liberalism in 1989 - the full might of the state was unleashed on them in the so-called “Caracazo”, a Tiananmen Square-style massacre in which hundreds of protesters were slaughtered.
Repulsed by the traditional political elite, Venezuelans delivered Chavez a landslide victory in 1998. At the time, he advocated the Third Way approach championed by Tony Blair, but his key strategy was to use oil riches to fund social programmes. Poverty rates collapsed from 50 per cent to around 25 per cent; extreme poverty was reduced by two-thirds. According to the UN, this represents the second-biggest percentage-point drop in poverty in Latin America. The traditional bastion of neo-liberal dogma, the World Bank, reveals that, while Venezuela's gross national per capita income languished below the continent's average before Chavez came to power, it is now $13,120, higher than Brazil or Argentina, and against an average of $8,981. Despite recent economic troubles, the UN revealed that Venezuela enjoyed the region's biggest drop in poverty in 2012.
Does this mean that Venezuela is some sort of paradise? No. Inflation runs at over 50 per cent: but it is a disease the country is long familiar with. Under Chavez's neo-liberal predecessor Rafael Caldera in the 1990s, it topped 100 per cent. And yet this was not presented as a failure of free-market capitalism. The law-and-order situation is simply unacceptable, exacerbated by various factors: neighbouring Colombia's civil war; a society that’s awash with guns; and an ineffective police force riddled with corruption. Neither should the government's support for tyrannies in Syria and Libya be overlooked, though given Western support for vile dictatorships such as Saudi Arabia – and Tony Blair's lucrative employment by Kazakhstan's dictatorship – let's not overdose on the hypocrisy.
But take a look at the behaviour of the opposition. In 2002, Chavez was overthrown by a Western-backed Pinochet-style coup, vigorously incited and backed by a private media that made Fox News look like pinko liberals. And yet – almost uniquely – a popular uprising returned the elected government to power. Imagine if our elected government was overthrown by a junta, which killed numerous innocent people in the process, and the whole thing was cheered on by ITN and Sky News. What would be the aftermath?
One of the leaders of the current protests is Leopoldo Lopez, who was involved in the 2002 coup and helped arrest Chavez's Interior Minister. The unrest demands the government's “exit” only a few months after the opposition lost municipal elections. Molotov cocktails, rocks and fireworks have been thrown. Steel wire has been fitted to Opposition barricades, and at least two people have been garotted. Among those shot dead are pro-Government activists, including an MP's brother. That does not in any sense excuse the deaths of opposition supporters: in all cases, the circumstances must be investigated, and those responsible apprehended, whoever they are. Military police officers have been arrested for killing one Government supporter and one opposition activist. But here is what is perverse: those loudest in cheering on often violent anti-government protests in Venezuela are those who would tolerate them least if they happened in this country.
As for the government's much-maligned democratic credentials, when Chavez was elected in 1998, he received 3.7 million votes against the opposition's 2.6 million. In 2013, his successor Nicolás Maduro received 7.6 million votes, against the opposition's 7.4 million. The leap in the number of votes is not down to a population explosion: many were not even registered to vote until the government's registration drives. International observers have repeatedly declared every election to be free; in 2012, former US President Jimmy Carter hailed Venezuela's election process as “the best in the world”. When Chavez lost a constitutional referendum in 2007, he accepted it.
State media is clearly biased in favour of the government. But it has a derisory audience share, and the dominant private media remains biased in favour of the opposition, even if it is less strident than it was once. In 2007, the government refused to renew the radio broadcast licence of RCTV because of its support for the coup: it was wrong to do so, as some Chavistas accept, but it continues to broadcast via satellite and cable.
Venezuela is one of the world's most polarised nations. Talks must happen; the dead need justice; the government must guarantee freedoms; violent disorder must end. But one thing is clear. Those who relish using Venezuela's troubles for political point-scoring have no interest in the truth.
Read more
James Bloodworth: The left has a blind spot on Venezuela. When will it acknowledge that Chavez's socialist dream has turned into a nightmare?
Owen Jones: Hugo Chavez was a democrat, not a dictator, and showed a progressive alternative to neo-liberalism is both possible and popular
-
Ukrainian forces launch full-scale attack on pro-Russian separatists as ceasefire ends
-
Scottish independence poll: Support for Alex Salmond's bid slips
-
Tube strike: London braces for Tour de France disruption as power workers prepare for eight-day walkout
-
Tube strike: London faces week's disruption as Underground workers prepare for eight-day walkout
-
European Court of Human Rights upholds French ban on full-face veils
-
Nicolas Sarkozy 'held for questioning' by police
Topman: Tips from top stylists
Shop London has teamed up with Topman. View the latest film clips shot at Topman Oxford Circus, plus your chance to win a £1,500 voucher.
Win a tailor-made trip to Graubünden, Switzerland’s No. 1 holiday destination
Discover Swiss alpine holidays – your way
Discover Another China
Join Simon Calder as he travels into the heart of the People's Republic
48 Hours in: Hong Kong with Simon Calder
Watch Simon uncover the fascinating Chinese city-state
All the fun of the fair with Così fan tutte!
Summer is finally here as English National Opera's new production of Mozart's Così fan tutte transports you to 1950's Coney Island.
Park life
From the have-to-have Hawaiian shirt to the perfect printed shorts Shop London teams up with Specsavers for summer style.
Get the look. See the trends.
Westfield and Snapfashion team up to create a new digital styling tool. Create a style board or browse this season's trends. #editme.
Get £5 free bet with 888sport
Get a £5 free bet every time your team scores in Brazil!
Dress like a headliner
Whether you're headed for a field in Somerset or the lawns of Hyde Park, everyone can dress like a headliner this festival season.
What a credit check offers to UK customers
What can a credit check offer UK customers? A ticket out of debtor’s hell and, quite possibly, a financially secure future.
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Owen Jones
iJobs General
Internal Resourcer – Contract – Up to 8 weeks – Immediate Start - £12-£15 per hour
£12 - £15 Per Hour: Clearwater People Solutions Ltd: We are currently recruiti...
Business Architect - Bristol - £500-£620 per day
£500 - £620 per day: Orgtel: Business Architect - Banking - Bristol - £500 - £...
Business Analyst, Regulatory Risk £400-500pd
£400 - £475 per day: Orgtel: Business Analyst, Regulatory Risk,London, £400-55...
Application Tools Specialist - Southampton
£28000 - £34500 per annum + Excellent benefits: Deerfoot IT Resources Limited:...