www.fgks.org   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

An investigation is not Islamophobia

The Asian Mayor of Tower Hamlets says he welcomes scrutiny, yet he tried to stop a BBC 'Panorama' report

Share

Because "Islamophobe" is shorthand for "Bad Person", it can sometimes silence legitimate debate – which is what the mayor of the London borough of Tower Hamlets seems to have tried to do to the BBC.

Lutfur Rahman is Britain's first directly elected Asian mayor. On 22 May, he seeks re-election. He says he aspires to the highest standards of transparency and probity and that he welcomes scrutiny.

Two weeks ago, on Panorama, we scrutinised the way he's run this most diverse of boroughs. Instead of welcoming this, the mayor employed a major City law firm and a PR company at huge public expense to try to get the programme stopped.

Tower Hamlets is home to the largest Bangladeshi population in Britain. The mayor says he seeks only to promote harmony; his Gandhi-like watchword is "No Place for Hate". Yet before even a frame had been transmitted, a fusillade of hate-filled tweets screamed from his closest supporters: the licence fee had been "used to preach hate", to "demonise Muslims" and to "peddle racism and Islamophobia".

The mayor launched an inflammatory 26-minute counter-documentary, weeks in the making. Fat was poured on this fire by a young Bengali researcher, who made increasingly fantastical claims that we were "Islamophobic bullies" and handed confidential research material from our production, including source notes, to the mayor's office. Because of concerns about her reliability, we had asked her to leave the team after five days.

Her claims seem to have been accepted as fact by some Bengali papers who gave no right of reply. That is not how the 30 Bengali confidential sources who helped us in our research see us. Her account is a travesty of the truth.

The BBC immediately reported this breach of data security to the Information Commissioner. Yet the Mayor of Tower Hamlets conflated this with the researcher's unsupported claims by tweeting that the BBC was under "criminal investigation after whistleblower reveals racism and Islamophobia in Panorama".

The mayor is a solicitor. He must know that the Information Commissioner is concerned with data security – not allegations of racism or Islamophobia. Yet the mayor was perfectly happy to twist the truth. He was right about one thing, though: disseminating personal data can be a criminal offence and a criminal investigation by the Information Commissioner may yet follow.

Many of the sources whom the researcher betrayed to the mayor's office were fellow Bangladeshis, who spoke frankly and in confidence. Attempts were subsequently made to pressurise one Bangladeshi source into retracting what we had previously been told.

The programme was manifestly neither Islamophobic nor racist. We made no mention of the mayor's links to Islamist fundamentalists. Instead, we focused squarely on governance, challenging the very principles that the mayor says underpin his approach to public office: transparency, accountability and probity.

We noted, for example, how he has given about £50,000 in grants to the Bengali media and a further £50,000 a year for "community media advice" to the chief correspondent of the most popular Bengali TV channel. That same channel has three times breached Ofcom impartiality rules by its blatantly biased coverage of the mayor. He counters that the relationship the two have is "professional".

Had the Prime Minister been paying the BBC's political editor £50,000 a year from public funds, the scandal would – rightly – have resonated around the world.

We also highlighted the mayor's repeated refusal to answer questions about his very large increase in grants to Somali and Bengali voluntary organisations.

In the run-up to the election, there have been widespread and persistent allegations by opposition councillors that Mr Rahman skewed the award of nearly £9m of grants in favour of Bengali- and Somali-run organisations to help him get out the vote on 22 May. The mayor categorically denies this, insisting that he awarded the grants solely on the basis of need.

To win, the Mr Rahman will likely need a big Bengali-Somali turnout because they comprise only one-third of Tower Hamlets, while his support in the rest of the borough appears to be thin.

Our detailed spreadsheet analysis of 488 grant applications showed that 70 per cent of recommendations by council officers were changed in some way as to which organisations should get grants, and how much.

This is an unusually high degree of political involvement in what would normally be a mainly administrative process, especially since council officers had factored in their understanding of how the mayor wanted to use voluntary organisations to promote equality and community cohesion aligned to his vision of "One Tower Hamlets".

The upshot of this 70 per cent cash "churn" was that the mayor increased funding to Bengali and Somali organisations by 139.5 per cent from £1.5m to £3.6m. He cut what was left for other organisations by 25 per cent overall.

We showed our analysis to three eminent ex-council officers. All agreed the audit trail was deficient, providing no reasoned explanation for the scale of changes. Mr Rahman said our "allegations just don't add up" and launched another vituperative attack "about journalistic integrity at the BBC".

He insists that the true figure for grants to Bengali-Somali organisations is £1.6m – not £3.6m. If we are right about the source of this figure, it will be the mayor whose maths will be seen to have been deficient.

In any case, the matter will be decided by auditors dispatched to the Town Hall at 8am four days after transmission by Communities Secretary Eric Pickles, who says they will also investigate "allegations of governance failure, poor financial management and fraud". Once again, the mayor says he "welcomes" the scrutiny.

I often think how I would feel were I a Muslim in post-9/11 Britain. I suspect that I, too, would feel a sense of victimhood, for Muslims have been under a relentless spotlight. There is a legitimate debate about the tone and scale of this scrutiny.

But that should never stop the BBC from raising valid questions about the way a council is run and public money spent. The idea that any BBC programme would be motivated to do this by racism or Islamophobia is unthinkable, as anyone who has worked for the BBC knows.

John Ware reported and presented 'The Mayor and Our Money' for BBC Panorama on behalf of Films of Record

React Now

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Graduate Software Tester/Junior Test Analyst – Leeds/Bradford

£21,000: FDM Group: FDM Group, an international IT services provider offering ...

Account Manager, London

£40000 - £45000 per annum, Benefits: £6000 Car Allowance: Charter Selection: T...

Co-opted Board Member with business / financial acumen

Unpaid Voluntary Role (reasonable expenses reimbursed): Reach Volunteering: Re...

Nursery Nurse

£20 per day: Randstad Education Manchester: Randstad Education is the UK marke...

Day In a Page

Florida's not-so-coy pastor is just the latest in a plague of fallen preachers

Florida's not-so-coy pastor is just the latest in a plague of fallen preachers

Revelations of extra-marital affairs and a porn habit leave the 20,000 worshippers of one mega-church leaderless
Notes from Madison Avenue: A Mad Men miscellany

Notes from Madison Avenue: A Mad Men miscellany

As the ad agency drama returns for its final series, Sarah Hughes considers its best (and worst) bits
Painting the South Bank red: Celebrating a year of the Shed

Painting the South Bank red: Celebrating a year of the Shed

Fiona Mountford hails the temporary venue that has shaken things up at the National Theatre
Russell Norman reveals how to build a restaurant empire: 'It's not a dinner party'

Russell Norman: How to build a restaurant empire

The food, the service and the numbers: nobody knows dining out like the man behind Polpo
MI6, the CIA and Turkey's rogue game in Syria

Patrick Cockburn: MI6, the CIA and Turkey's rogue game in Syria

New claims say Ankara worked with the US and Britain to smuggle Gaddafi's guns to rebel groups
Courtney Barnett interview: Is she the musical Lena Dunham?

Courtney Barnett: Is she the musical Lena Dunham?

She is candid, comic and coming our way
Britain's best chefs: Seven regional restaurants, seven brilliant local recipes

Behind-the-scenes: Britain's best chefs

From Cornwall to Edinburgh, we scoured the country to ask seven restaurants to show that fine dining is thriving beyond London
Pollen Street Social's Laure Patry reveals how to get the best out of a sommelier

How to get the best out of sommeliers

Laure Patry, group head sommelier for Jason Atherton's Michelin-starred Pollen Street Social-based mini empire, reveals all
Duck & Waffle: Lisa Markwell spends 24 hours at the restaurant that never sleeps

Duck & Waffle: Restaurant that never sleeps

It's always open. Always. How on Earth does that work? Lisa Markwell rides up to the 40th floor of London’s Heron Tower with an access-all-areas pass to the never-ending mealtime
Donald Rumsfeld, the ultimate known unknown of American politics

Rupert Cornwell: Rumsfeld, the ultimate known unknown

A documentary just out in the US shows the hard-nosed former defence secretary unapologetic over the Iraq debacle
Restaurant etiquette: The new rules of modern dining decorum

Restaurant etiquette: Modern dining decorum

Speaking with your mouth full, eating off your knife. No longer are these the bêtes noires of the diner with decorum...
Farewell Maria, what was it you did again?

DJ Taylor: Farewell Maria, what was it you did again?

Being culture secretary is a strange role, not least because no politician can say what culture is
Bill Granger recipes: Our chef shares his painless traditional Easter Sunday menu

Bill Granger's painless Easter Sunday menu

In our chef's menu is so low-maintenance, it allows you to leave the lamb slow-roasting in the oven while you run around hunting for eggs
Gérard Houllier: Raw emotion will power Liverpool to the title

Gérard Houllier: Raw emotion will power Liverpool to the title

The Frenchman came closest to bringing the crown back to Anfield. Ahead of the pivotal showdown with City, he tells Glenn Moore why the current side can win it
The Calvin Report: Boos show fans don't trust Arsène Wenger any more

The Calvin Report: Boos show fans don't trust Arsène any more

Arsenal's manager looks like a man on the edge despite shoot-out win