For the first time this year, the effects of file-sharing on personal taste became unmistakably clear: the indie community's palettes-- and everyone else's-- have broadly diversified. Freed from the careful decision-making that comes with $12 purchases, we can now easily branch out beyond the genres we've always loved and discover the inherent worth in all of them. To reflect this, Pitchfork opened its new singles-oriented review section, We Are The World, to surprising acclaim from many of its staunchly indie-minded readers-- some of which claimed (maybe even rightly) that commercial pop seems to be at its most creative height since the 1960s.
The great thing about music right now is that listeners don't have to be "staunch" anymore. In an age when all music is free, dedicating yourself to just one specific genre or type only denies you the hedonistic musical bliss that is rightfully yours. Sure, we all still buy albums for their increased sound quality, tangibility, artwork and artist support, but let's be straight about one thing: singles are for downloading. As of this week, there's but one gold single on the Billboard chart, and if you think that's normal, check the back issues from five years ago. These days, even the majors seem to have given up on trying to sell them, as even Christina Aguilera's new song-- once prime CD5 material-- is identified on the charts as an "album cut."
Rock music has always been a breeding ground for great albums, while commercial pop continually worships at the altar of The Single, so it makes sense that our two Top 50 year-end lists reflect this. But in 2003, there were more than enough brilliant tracks from both sides, and friends, coming from a reformed tightass, there's just no reason to deny it. When shit's free, there's no guilt for pleasure. Enjoy. (Check out our Spotify playlist to hear the tracks.)
50: Ellen Allien
"Trash Scapes"
[Bpitch Control]
Dance music might have been a driving force in 2003, but few artists took as many risks with it as Ellen Allien. In lead single "Trash Scapes", the Berlinette brings together factions of electro, glitch, EBM and industrial for a dark post-nuclear world portrait with dayglo highlights. Fractured beats and chopped-up lyrics set the stage for the cinematic chorus, when Allien's vocals coalesce with six-inch-thick guitars. Traces of Front Line Assembly's 80s digital noir might catch you off-guard, but this rogue DJ never spins out of control-- whatever miracle adhesive they sell overseas is working spectacularly. --Joshua Sharp
49: The Postal Service
"Such Great Heights"
[Sub Pop]
Death Cab for Cutie's Ben Gibbard and Dntel's Jimmy Tamborello have earned the 2003 crown for Indiedom's reigning odd couple: following through on the promise of 2001's one-off cut "(This Is) The Dream of Evan and Chan," the duo's full-length Give Up officially pitted Gibbard's soft, confessional coos against Tamborello's laptop sheen. With its lilting vocal line layered over punchy rhythms, lead single "Such Great Heights" saw Gibbard's plaintive whines backed up by Tamborello's digitalis, creating a loping ballad with an irresistible melodic hook-- a charming blend of honest introspection and upbeat pop futurism. --Amanda Petrusich
48: Nas
"I Can"
[Ill Will/Columbia]
Message songs usually go about as far as there are people who dig the message. In this case, a minimal pairing of beats and Beethoven powers Nas' self-help checklist of education, pride of heritage and persistence. And like the best message songs, the music is the real persuader: children's chorus, one-finger classical piano and a simple, modest beat combine to form the kind of track kids might actually come up with. For some people, "I Can" was a little too childlike, but it's hard to be hard when you're promising "you can host the TV like Oprah Winfrey." Anyway, the little girls understand. --Dominique Leone
47: Nas
"Made You Look"
[Ill Will/Columbia]
After nearly a decade of trying to live up to his classic Illmatic, 2003 saw a sharper Nas striking hard on God's Son. The album's first single, "Made You Look", was his defiant reclamation: only a year before, "You're a slave to a page in my rhymebook" would have been an absurd and empty claim coming from the Brooklyn-based emcee. As a chorus taunts Nas with playground chants, he instinctively fights back, defending his hip-hop legitimacy with fearless production and lines like, "You all appointed me to bring rap justice but I ain't 5-0," and the hilarious, "Don't say my car's topless, say the titties is out." Pass the fifth, he's back in the game. -- Nick Sylvester
46: Freeway [ft. Jay-Z & Beanie Sigel]
"What We Do"
[Rocafella]
With the retirement of Jay-Z, Freeway moves to the heart of the Rocafella order-- and between his frizzy beard and gruff vocals, it's obvious that the curse of the Billy Goat doesn't exist in Philadelphia. On "What We Do", producer Just Blaze tosses regal-soul rocks at the Timba/Neptunes throne and makes more than a few dents, while Freeway explains why he acts the motherfuckin' fool in a sing-song rasp-- the Brothers Grimm to Nelly's Richard Scary nursery rhymes. Add Jay's best guest spot of the year and B Si in the third lane and it's a tragedy these three didn't cross over that bridge to platinum sales. --Scott Plagenhoef
45: Snoop Dogg [ft. Pharrell Williams & Uncle Charlie Watson]
"Beautiful"
[Priority]
Pharrell Williams' bleating falsetto is somehow both hideous and overwhelmingly alluring at the very same time, but when coupled with Snoop's wound-down rhymes and The Neptunes' punchy, handclapper production, nothing else feels quite so right. "Beautiful" is a lush, unstoppable promise, Snoop's mesmeric flow persistently erasing any flaw from the green world around him. Before long, Pharrell's lazy, high-pitched clucks are enough to make women actually believe the silly shit he says: I'm his favorite girl! --Amanda Petrusich
44: Manitoba
"Jacknuggeted"
[Domino]
The greatness of this track rests solely in the moment when the galloping acoustic guitar, just joined by a lone organ chord, bursts into even more propulsive strumming, like a sloppy-tongue kiss from the first day of summer. This single from Up in Flames nicely sums up Manitoba's electronica/acoustic revival of the sunnier side of the 60s: its trajectory seems simple on the surface, but dive deeper and you'll find you can't touch the bottom. --Chris Dahlen
"Time for Heroes"
[Rough Trade]
To this cynic's ears, the line, "Did you see the stylish kids in the riot?/ Shoveled up like monks/ But no, not on fire," seems to carry some hypocrisy, considering the fashionable retro-trends The Libertines spent this year riding, but sincerely or not, it carries one of the most heavenly impressions of the late 70s' British blue-collar pub-punk sound to come 'round these parts in a long time. There are more than just echoes of The Clash in Carl Barat's cockney vocals and stinging lyrical sarcasm, but musically, the band finds their own terrain, encompassing mid-70s Bowery apathy, the folk of the British countryside, and the vast oceans in between. In 2003, we're a hell of a long way from the spirit that spawned the surge of punk rock in England, but that doesn't mean it isn't worth remembering. --Eric Carr
42: The Rapture
"Sister Saviour"
[Strummer/Universal]
"Sister Saviour" isn't your typical Rapture song, nor is it your typical Rapture ballad: it's Rapture Class C, the brilliantly restrained 80s pop junket. Carried by a slick rhythmic shuffle, pulsating synths, and the jammed guitar chords that emulate Rio -era Duran Duran, this track may not be one of the band's most characteristic moments, but it's unquestionably one of their best. The Rapture's decision to forgo their usual jagged riffs and tortured wails was a good call here: such intense art-punk conviction would have decimated this track's perfectly coked-out club ambience. --Joshua Sharp
41: Johnny Cash
"Hurt"
[American Recordings]
Everyone knows that in his autumn years, Johnny Cash underwent an artistic transformation in which he gained the ability to assimilate any song on earth. It didn't matter if you were Merle Haggard or Glenn Danzig: if he deigned to record it, your song became his, and you were powerless to resist. Which was fine, because it was really meant to be his song, anyway. Like "Hurt", for example, in which all trace of Nine Inch Nails frontman Trent Reznor's frustrated complaining miraculously became a weary resignation to the inevitability of a long and difficult life's surmounting end-- and the unexpected death of wife June Carter just after its release (not to mention her appearance in the song's already harrowing video) only lent it more heft and potency. Though you still find Cash's records amongst any store's stock of country music, he was more a folk hero as iconic as Woody Guthrie or Phil Ochs, a rebel whose only solace was rebellion. It's only fitting that one of his career's greatest achievements also served as his final finger to the world. --Ryan Schreiber
- « Previous Feature
Top 100 Albums of the 1990s
- Next Feature »
Top 50 Albums of 2003
The Top 50 Albums of 2003 as selected by the Pitchfork Staff
Most Read Features
-
-
Rising
Lee
April 1, 2014
-
Update
Girl Talk
March 25, 2014
-
Articles
Cloud Nothings: Silent Shout
March 20, 2014
-
Overtones
Beyond the Yellow Brick Road
March 28, 2014
-
Cover Story
Mac DeMarco: Mannish Boy
March 26, 2014
-
Update
tUnE-yArDs
March 19, 2014
-
Update
Future
April 2, 2014
-
Interviews
Jonathan Glazer and Mica Levi
March 31, 2014
-
Situation Critical
Kevin Drew
March 24, 2014
-
Update
Owen Pallett
March 18, 2014
-
-
-
Articles
Cloud Nothings: Silent Shout
March 20, 2014
-
Update
tUnE-yArDs
March 19, 2014
-
Photo Galleries
Arcade Fire's Reflektor Tour
March 10, 2014
-
Update
Owen Pallett
March 18, 2014
-
Rising
Frankie Cosmos
March 5, 2014
-
Situation Critical
Hannibal Buress
March 14, 2014
-
Update
Girl Talk
March 25, 2014
-
Ordinary Machines
The #Art of the Hashtag
March 12, 2014
-
Articles
When I'm Gone: Why Vivian Girls Mattered
March 3, 2014
-
Rising
Viet Cong
March 13, 2014
-
-
-
Articles
St. Vincent: Reckless Precision
February 17, 2014
-
Show No Mercy
The Top 40 Metal Albums of 2013
December 26, 2013
-
Update
Pharrell Williams
February 28, 2014
-
Articles
Cloud Nothings: Silent Shout
March 20, 2014
-
Articles
Real Estate: Suburban Dreams
February 27, 2014
-
Articles
Beyoncé's Muse
January 21, 2014
-
Paper Trail
Experiencing Nirvana
February 12, 2014
-
Articles
Massive Nights: Ten Years of the Hold Steady
February 10, 2014
-
Guest Lists
Deafheaven
January 6, 2014
-
Interviews
Mark Kozelek
February 3, 2014
-
-
-
News
Jack White to Record and Release "World's Fastest Release Record" in Single Day
A live rendition of the title track from the upcoming ...
By Jeremy Gordon on April 3, 2014 at 12:52 p.m.
-
Watch the Strokes' Julian Casablancas Crash Arcade Fire's Lollapalooza Argentina Set
Wearing Win Butler's bobblehead mask
By Evan Minsker on April 1, 2014 at 11:28 p.m.
-
Flaming Lips Dark Side of the Moon Companion Part of Funny or Die April Fool's Day Prank
But Flaming Side really does actually sync up with Pink ...
By Jeremy Gordon and Amy Phillips on April 1, 2014 at 01:14 p.m.
-
Jack White Announces New Album Lazaretto, Shares "High Ball Stepper"
By Jenn Pelly on April 1, 2014 at 10:18 a.m.
-
Get Grossed Out by Girl Talk, Freeway, and Waka Flocka Flame's Gory, Hilarious "Tolerated" Video
By Amy Phillips and Molly Beauchemin on March 31, 2014 at 04:17 p.m.
-
Kendrick Lamar and Alicia Keys Share Pharrell-Produced The Amazing Spider-Man 2 Collaboration "It's On Again"
By Evan Minsker and Jeremy Gordon on March 31, 2014 at 09:36 a.m.
-
-
-
News
Arcade Fire, Black Keys, Jack White, Robert Plant, More to Play Glastonbury
By Evan Minsker and Zoe Camp on April 4, 2014 at 05:20 a.m.
-
Reviews
Sage the Gemini
Remember Me
By Craig Jenkins
Sage the Gemini of the Bay Area’s Heartbreak Gang collective has refined a sound that draws influence ...
-
White Hinterland
Baby
By Paula Mejia
White Hinterland's latest finds Casey Dienel experimenting with more jagged percussion and orchestral flourishes, notably horns. But ...
-
Teebs
E S T A R A
By Nate Patrin
Teebs' 2010 debut Ardour had a way of flooding your ears with lush sonic environments. On his new ...
-
The Faint
Doom Abuse
By Ian Cohen
The Faint released their debut album Sine Sierra nearly twenty years ago, and if that makes you feel ...
-
De La Soul
Smell the D.A.I.S.Y.
By Nate Patrin
De La Soul's work with J Dilla helped define their transition from the Prince Paul-produced lightheartedness of ...
-
-
-
News
Arcade Fire, Black Keys, Jack White, Robert Plant, More to Play Glastonbury
By Evan Minsker and Zoe Camp on April 4, 2014 at 05:20 a.m.
-
Reviews
De La Soul
Smell the D.A.I.S.Y.
By Nate Patrin
De La Soul's work with J Dilla helped define their transition from the Prince Paul-produced lightheartedness of ...
-
Tracks
-
News
Sigur Rós Will Cover "The Rains of Castamere" for "Game of Thrones" Soundtrack
By Jeremy Gordon on April 3, 2014 at 03:44 p.m.
-
Reviews
The Faint
Doom Abuse
By Ian Cohen
The Faint released their debut album Sine Sierra nearly twenty years ago, and if that makes you feel ...
-
Features
Paper Trail
Paper Trail: Records Ruin the Landscape
Author David Grubbs talks about his new book, which explores the disdain many 1960s experimental musicians had for recorded music due to its inherent limiting qualities, and compares that mindset to today's era of infinite streaming.
-