'Racist' X Factor voters reject black singers, says Chris O'Dowd
Tuesday 11 February 2014
Viewers of the X Factor are “racist” because they consistently vote to eject the best black singers, the actor Chris O’Dowd has claimed.
Despite the ITV talent show producing several black winners, the IT Crowd and Bridesmaids star said that the millions of viewers who watch the talent show and vote for their favourites remain prejudiced against black contestants.
O’Dowd told Radio Times: “I’m a big X Factor fan. Generally my favourites go out in the first few weeks and, of course, because the viewing public is so racist, all the black, strong singers go out in round five every year.”
Simon Cowell’s talent search has produced a number of black stars, including Leona Lewis and Alexandra Burke, who won the public vote by an overwhelming margin in 2006 and 2008.
However there have been occasions where the judges have stepped in to rescue talented black performers after a lack of viewer votes left them singing for survival.
In 2011, Misha B, described by the Huffington Post as the “blackest contestant the competition has ever had”, was regularly placed in the bottom two. The Post said the public’s rejection of a confident performer, “rooted in black culture” who chose not to bleach her skin lighter like other crossover black singers, was “racist”.
Simon Woolley, director of Operation Black Vote, the body set up to promote racial justice in public life, said O’Dowd had raised a valid issue.
Mr Woolley said: “I wouldn’t describe voters as racist but there’s something more subtle going on which makes it harder for contestants with a ‘darker’ physical complexion to win public support. Generally the ‘blacker’ the artist is, the harder it is for the public to warm to them.”
This prejudice was not limited to The X Factor but other talent shows and wider society. Mr Woolley said: “Whether it's in the arts or business we need a sensible debate if we are to unpick and deal with some deep seated prejudice especially when it simply ignores talent.”
The X Factor producers rejected O’Dowd’s claim. The show was praised last year for giving a platform to talented ethnic minority hopefuls – 40 per cent of the 2013 finalists were black or mixed race.
A programme source said: “The X Factor has a long standing record of celebrating a diverse range of artists including two former winners, Leona Lewis and Alexandra Burke, and numerous others who have reached the final stages of the competition including this year’s semi-finalists Rough Copy, along with JLS, Marcus Collins and Jahmene Douglas in previous series.”
O’Dowd was sucked into a race row himself when he starred in the film The Sapphires as a talent scout who manages an Aboriginal girl group in the ‘60s.
A DVD cover for a film was called “racist and sexist” for relegating its female stars to the background to give the Irish actor centre stage.
The original DVD cover for The Sapphires features the dark-skinned singers in prominent positions, with O’Dowd at the back. But on the US version, released last year, O'Dowd takes centre stage while The Sapphires fade into an entirely blue background.
US distributor Anchor Bay Entertainment has apologised for the cover which prompted the real-life members of The Sapphires to complain to the US civil rights group the National Association for the Advancement of Coloured People.
Last year, X Factor contestant Hannah Barrett revealed that she has been subjected to “horrible, racist comments” during her stint on the ITV show.
She told Reveal magazine: “I’ve received a lot of horrible, racist comments on Twitter. People say I'm too dark to be a singer. People say: 'You're black and ugly' and nasty things like that....The sad thing is that most of them are made by black people who just have lighter skin than me.”
X Factor winners and losers
Winners
Leona Lewis
Hackney receptionist won X Factor 2006 with 60% of public vote after judges compared her powerful voice to Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey. Debut single Bleeding Love topped the charts in 30 countries and her album Spirit sold 8 million copies.
Alexandra Burke
Islington soul singer took 2008 X Factor by storm which Cheryl Cole as her mentor. Won with 58% of 8 million votes cast and sold one million copies of her single Hallelujah. First X Factor winner to be asked to return as guest judge 3 years later.
JLS
London boyband, consisting of members JB Gill, Marvin Humes, Aston Merrygold and Oritsé Williams, auditioned for 2008 series. Faced elimination early on but finished runners-up to Burke. Cowell passed but Epic Records guided the band to 10 million sales during their 5-year career.
Losers
Misha B
Manchester singer/rapper likened to “21st century Grace Jones” during 2011 series was repeatedly forced to sing for survival and had to be saved by judges. Voted out at semi-final stage amid claims that she was “too black” for predominantly white television audience.
Gamu Nhengu
Cheryl Cole faced accusations of racism on social media after failing to put through 18 year-old Zimbabwean-born singer to the 2010 final. Nhengu faces possible deportation over problems with her family visa but remained in the UK and released her debut album last year.
Arts & Ents blogs
Travel Shop
-
Robocop's Gary Oldman on the Kardashians and being the highest-grossing actor in film history
-
HRC: State Secrets and the Rebirth of Hillary Clinton - book review
-
Harry Styles claims One Direction are 'even bigger' than The Beatles
-
Quaaludes: How the hero of Martin Scorsese’s The Wolf of Wall Street got high
-
VIDEO: Samuel L. Jackson vents anger at TV presenter who confuses him with Laurence Fishburne
-
Labour has 'betrayed' working-class voters, says Ukip candidate
-
Switzerland votes to limit the number of EU migrants
-
Is Labour panicking over Ukip? Fears growing that Nigel Farage's party could eat into the white working class vote, admits Peter Hain
-
Six-year-old schoolboy suspended for having Mini Cheddars in his lunchbox has now been expelled
-
Immigration Minister row Mark Harper resigns after employing a cleaner working in the UK illegally
-
Ukip chairman advocated 'termination' of Down's syndrome foetuses and 'breaking from the EU by force' claims Tory MP
- 1 Get Michael Home: Dalston reveller crowdfunds homeless man's ticket back to Jamaica 'where he says he will be happy'
- 2 If you're really saddened by the death of Marius the giraffe, stop visiting zoos
- 3 New insights into the mystery of autism: Could it be caused at birth by salt in the nerves?
- 4 'Neknomination': Isaac Richardson is first Briton to die from online drinking craze
- 5 Flappy Bird: phones selling for £50,000 on eBay after creator Dong Nguyen pulls game from app stores
READER SURVEY
Take our short survey for your opportunity to win one of two £100 Amazon vouchers.
New Year, New Career? Get into teaching!
Are you ready to become part of a new generation of high-calibre teachers?
Win a luxury two-night break in York
Plus two East Coast return tickets from London to York and two York Passes
Win flights to Vietnam with Westfield
Westfield is launching a five week celebration of food. To celebrate the programme Westfield, in partnership with Pho, is offering readers the chance to win two return flights to Vietnam.
This is Kenya
Exploring hidden coastal coves and witnessing the greatest wildlife show on earth are just a few of the experiences that Kenya has to offer.
The science of switching to a career in teaching
Neil Simpkins's new life in the classroom has fulfilled his ambition to focus on physics and encourage the next generation to get involved in the subject
Bermuda
Lose yourself in the enchanting scenery and crystal waters of this historic chain of islands – perfect for relaxation and activity alike
What has Europe ever done for you?
Most of us are unaware of what we are entitled to as EU citizens. Find out more - plus your chance to debate Europe's future.
Travel through paradise - Queensland
No matter how you choose to explore it, Queensland is an unforgettable destination – from spectacular beaches to the buzzing state capital of Brisbane.
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
The European debate: Reader survey
Take part in our reader survey on European rights. plus your chance to join the debate on Europe's future.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.