Deadline deals are overrated
Odds are that the trade your team makes this week will have minimal impact
We're entering the final days before the July 31 trading deadline, and that means the rumor mill is running on overdrive. Every team within sniffing distance of contention looks at the available talent and prays they'll be able to add the final piece that pushes them over the top into the playoffs, hopefully without needing to sacrifice too much of their future to do so.
The gold standard for this type of trade in recent years has been the deal the Los Angeles Dodgers pulled off in 2008, acquiring Manny Ramirez from the Boston Red Sox at the deadline and then watching as he put up a .396/.489/.743 line and nearly 3 WAR in barely two months of play. The Dodgers won their division by two games that year, and none of the prospects they surrendered ever amounted to anything. As far as deadline deals go, that's the dream scenario.
But back here in reality, it's incredibly rare that a late-July acquisition ever pays off like the Ramirez deal did. For all the attention and passion that gets put into following every rumor as the the deadline approaches, the most essential question often gets overlooked: Are the trades teams make to upgrade even worth the trouble?
To see why deadline deals are overrated, sign up for Insider today.
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
Mike Petriello
FanGraphs- Writer for FanGraphs
- Founder of Mike Scioscia's Tragic Illness
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE MLB HEADLINES
- Jeter back, homers on first pitch vs. Rays
- Pujols put on DL, will miss significant time
- Peavy preparing for likely trade from White Sox
- Farrell: No word from MLB on Ortiz outburst
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
MLB ON ESPN.COM
The Cardinals have what it takes to trade for Jake Peavy, but it's uncertain if they have the motivation to go get him.
EDITORS' PICKS
- Awaiting A Verdict
- It's uncertain if Cards have motivation to trade for Jake Peavy.
Olney
- Nothing To Sell Here
- The Angels are out of it, but don't have anything to sell.
Bowden
- Back In Time
- Derek Jeter homered in his first at-bat, and the Yankees won.
Recap »
- Callis: Top 10 fantasy prospects
- Bowden: GMs who will make a deal
- Olney: Soriano makes sense with Yanks
- Cross: Relievers to target, avoid
- Petriello: Deadline deals are overrated