THEATER REVIEW: "Middletown" ★★★ Through Aug. 14 at Steppenwolf Theatre, 1650 N. Halsted St.; Running time: 2 hours, 20 minutes; Tickets: $20-$73 at 312-335-1650 or steppenwolf.org
At one point in Will Eno's wonderful new play “Middletown” — a piece that's a bit like Thornton Wilder's “Our Town” if it had been penned by Dr. Seuss and edited by Samuel Beckett — a character suddenly feels moved to discuss the linguistic difference between the word “rock” and the word “people.” “'Rock,'” he opines from the stage of the Steppenwolf Theatre, “has a real honest ring to it. ‘People' feels like an afterthought.”
Like a lot of things in a play that seems quirky but actually is profoundly wise, you have to think about that one for a while. Here's another one: talking about botulism, another citizen of Eno's small town of Middletown wonders if this word might actually refer not to a disease but to “a philosophy of really bad choices.” Get it?
But let's go back to “rock” and “people.” If you do think about it — and if that sounds like a drag, this review is not your review and this play it not your play — you'll surely conclude that the guy's observation has merit. And from there, perhaps, you might start wondering why people, who created our language system even as rocks were just sitting around on the ground, chose to imbue an inanimate object with such gravitas and themselves with the wimpiest of monikers. What the heck does that say about our lack of confidence in ourselves? And at that point, as at other points, “Middletown” would be working its spell.
Eno, who also wrote the acclaimed piece “Thom Pain (based on nothing),” is an unusual writer, to say the least.
Where most contemporary playwrights would just write the word “hello,” Eno will typically write, “hello, hi, how are you?” and protect that trifecta from an editor. Not only is his dialog uncommonly rich and poetic, it free-associates with the most rare and delicious kind of abandonment. His characters start talking, it invariably feels, without actually knowing where their sentence is going to end, or even what they are going to say. But that's not to say that the resultant play is pretentious or formless or academic or esoteric or even just plain weird. Actually, “Middletown” (like the Wilder model) is tightly focused on what matters in small-town life: finding ourselves born, dying, relating to others, finding our place, searching for personal meaning, fighting off loneliness, passing the time.