'The Homosexuals' by About Face Theatre: Charting a new century of gay life in Chicago
IN PERFORMANCE: "The Homosexuals" ★★★ Through July 24 at the Richard Christiansen Theatre in the Biograph, 2433 N. Lincoln Ave.; Running time: 2 hours, 20 minutes; Tickets: $28 at 773-871-3000 or www.aboutfacetheatre.com
Philip Dawkins' ambitious, substantial and deeply impressive new play, “The Homosexuals,” begins with a disaster: Catherine Zeta-Jones winning the Tony Award.
“For singing,” spits out Peter, one of the group of gay Chicagoans whom this play follows — or, more accurately, whose lives it rewinds through the first decade of the 21st century. He peers at the results of the 2010 Tonys in his copy of the Tribune. Peter (Scott Bradley) is an old-fashioned homosexual: he likes his news on paper. The young man breaking up with him, Evan (Patrick Andrews), is of a different breed altogether. He was in grade school during the height of the AIDS crisis. And although he is vaguely aware of iconic gay plays like “The Boys in the Band” and “Love! Valour! Compassion!,” he read them in a class promoting diversity. He did not live them. And he surely does not care about swishy musicals.
Precisely what that means for this young everyman is at the core of Dawkins' sweeping drama, one that begins at the end of the decade and progressively moves back in time, finally ending with another Tony Award house party just after the turn of the millennium. With a little more work, Dawkins will have a play that deserves some major subsequent productions after this About Face premiere at the Richard Christiansen Theatre. He clearly wants to update those earlier plays that charted the ways gay American men, scarred by discrimination, found family and community in each other.
Dawkins does so by turning that conceit on its head. “The Homosexuals” begins with togetherness but charts a progressive course towards isolation, as its central characters love and lose each other and Evan, part hero and part anti-hero, tries to figure out what it means to be gay in a decade when, as his friend Tam (Elizabeth Ledo) wryly observes, “there are no dirty words. Every term has been reclaimed and is now either empowering or ironic.”
Empowering. Ironic. Where does that leave a young man, arriving in Chicago from Iowa at the age of 20? What does it mean to be gay in a decade that contained the promise (and, for some, the disappointment) of the Obama presidency? Those questions are all under review, as is the question of whether those powerful gay communities, formed in crisis, are becoming increasing fractured. Whether that represents diversity or dissipation is the real question of this very fine new play.