www.fgks.org   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

baltimoresun.com

« Catching up with ... former Oriole Joe Nolan | Main | Ayanbadejo continues speaking out for gay rights »

Ohio State needs to oust Jim Tressel now

tresselblog.jpgSo Jim Tressell, all mild-mannered and be-sweater vested, is a liar. While this runs counter to all known research conducted on men who cannot live without wearing only the middle part of their sweaters, it does fit right in line with what we all suspect about college coaches.

The question is: Why the hell would Ohio State continue to put up with Jim Tressel?

Yeah, he wins. He wins a lot. Since he took over in 2002, the Buckeyes are 106–22. They've played in three national title games and won one.

But, it's Ohio State. It has one of the largest football budgets in the country, and the facilities to prove it. It has a rabid fan and alumni (donor) base. It has tradition. It has fertile, established recruiting ground.

There are other coaches who can win there.

Which should -- but won't -- come secondary to the fact that Tressel just happened to let slip the fact that he's not the type of person you'd want teaching young men or representing a university.


The damage that a protracted case involving Tressell -- the school won't even go before the NCAA committe on infractions until August, and that group won't rule until months after that -- isn't worth taking.

To review: Tressell made a mockery of one of the tenants of the NCAA. By not reporting obvious violations -- his players receiving impermissible benefits --  he subverted the very spirit of fair play that supposedly binds the NCAA member schools. The organization relies on self-reporting and, predictably enough, dislikes when that practice is proven publicly to be the sham that it is. Not only that, it has piles of evidence -- emails and phone records -- to support its case. So many of the flagrant violations you hear about, be it illegal payments or sweetheart summer jobs, can't ever be tried by the NCAA because they don't have access to bank records and the like. The group relishes hearing cases this air-tight.

According to the committee on infractions, Tressel contacted just about everybody other than his bosses at Ohio State or a representative at the NCAA when he found out that several of his players had traded memorabilia for cash and tattoos. Even through the dense language found in the notice of allegations, it's clear that the NCAA will focus on that element. It has charged  Tressel with unethical conduct. Few coaches have made it through such a charge. 

(By the way, you've gotta check out Ohio State's official announcement that it received a notice of allegations. The art -- a full Ohio Stadium, the lights illuminating a sea of red fans -- is all sorts of awkward. If only someone was dotting the 'i.')

This sort of controversy will significantly hinder the work of the football program, regardless of what's eventually discovered about Tressel's actions. He'll spend many hours meeting with his lawyers each week. They've got to craft a response to the NCAA's allegations before he can even think about preparing to take the committee's questioning in person (those sessions often last hours upon hours).

Meanwhile, members of the athletic department, university legal office and probably outside counsel will work to prepare the school's official response. They'll spend thousands of hours and well into six-figures to build a case.

Meanwhile,  media scrutiny will be intense. The Columbus Dispatch has already unleashed investigative reporters on the case. The paper has published multiple articles basically accusing the university of skirting open records laws as part of a continued cover up. Tressel won't hold another normal press conference this year. Questions will continue, both from local and national outlets.

Reporters (or at least this one) thrive while covering stories such as this. Disgruntled sources are the best kind, and you can be sure that there are going to be Ohio State alums and administrators who aren't fond of the way Tressel has besmirched the university. More than that, the Tressel is no longer untouchable. Those he's wronged in the past may now be able to come forward without fear of retribution. The whole thing is a mess.

There's more gray here than maybe it appears we're willing to admit. The chivalrous scholar-coach is a fallacy, anyway. And it'd be easy to argue that Tressel did what he thought was best for his players and thus fulfilled his No. 1 duty. At the Division I level -- especially in a powerhouse conference -- the coaches and players are engaged, most often, in an unsentimental business arrangement (which is why the players were so willing to part with what, to fans, seem like invaluable trinkets). Under those conditions, maybe Tressel did the noble thing in trying to protect his guys.

A few years ago I covered the demise of Kelvin Sampson at Indiana. As with Tressel, the NCAA eventually focused on the fact that Smapson had been less than honest (though he was also a repeat offender, making it worse). Like Ohio State, Indiana had originally backed Sampson and tried to sell the whole thing as a honest slip up. But within a few months it became clear that the university would have to try to save face by ditching Sampson -- who recruited well and had a top 25 team in his second season -- right in the middle of a promising season.  It collapsed. The Hoosiers are 28-66 since then -- easily the worst stretch in their storied history -- and the reputation of the program was badly damaged.

After the Sampson fiasco, the players he recruited to Indiana -- many from difficult circumstances -- dispersed. A few of them -- Eric Gordon and Jordan Crawford in particular -- turned out OK, but others scattered to smaller schools and failed to graduate.  Sampson had prided himself on finding kids with rough edges and helping them better their lives through basketball. That goal fell to the wayside because he'd done something silly -- reached out too often, and in illegal ways, to recruits -- and tried then to fib about it. I've always felt bad for those kids who lost that opportunity because of what Sampson did, and I've always told people that, ultimately, Kelvin Sampson meant well. He truly cared about his players.

None of that, though, should have ever factored into Indiana's decision about how to deal with him. Casual fans don't see that nuance, and the NCAA has legislated complicated thought out of how it does things. Sampson lied and worked outside the spirit of the governing body's rules. He was doomed from then on out, spending hours of his time dealing with NCAA matters instead of coaching.

Tressel may better be able to get away with missing chunks of time, as football programs don't tilt based on one man. A head coach's job is more management of the team and glad-handing of top recruits and money givers anyway.  So much of the actual teaching and scheming is done by position coaches.

Which is also why Ohio State should rid itself of Tressel now.  There are other coaches who can win at one of the nation's most prestigious football schools. And they might not even be liars -- or at least be better at not getting caught.

Comments

Why would anyone read a story from a reporter with a "potty mouth"?

I agree. It has been proven time and time again, that football is bigger than the overall integrity of the Ohio State University. It's a great school ,and shouldn't be tarnished by this foot-dragging on Tressel. There must be alumni who support the school outside of athletics that would step up and say enough is enough.

All this over the players (not the coach) selling items given to them and receiving free tatoos - tell me the value of these benefits? Yet Auburn pays to get a player and nothing happens. The Fiesta Bowl abuses its tax-eexmpt status and nothing will happen. It took how many years to punish Reggie Bush who had parents living rent free with the intent of benefiting the agent (not the case of the OSU players). These are all dealing with benefits over $100k. Yet a big stink over the couple thousand dollars - more money is paid to most talented NCAA student (ha) athletes every month from boosters.

Earle Bruce and John Cooper did real well at OSU!

Having a brother who's a teacher at "The Ohio State University", a nephew who recently graduated from there and a sister who works in the admissions department, I can tell you they would just as soon admit Obama is an alien as ask Tressel to step down. The guy is a god to the faithful and the insiders excuse everything. If Tressel wanted, he could get most of Columbus to drink the koolaid ala Jim Jones. Hero worship is scary!

This is a great example of why people think the media is comprised of ranting fools. Jim Tressel hid "the truth", but does the crime fit the punishment? The NCAA is not about following rules, it is about making money. Terrelle Pryor makes nothing from the video games in which he is featured. The NCAA does. Then it penalizes Pryor for selling his stuff to make a fast buck, THEN it jumps on Tressel for hiding it. The whole situation is dumb and makes the NCAA look like idiots. It's a witch hunt, and it is sad the media is fanning the flames at the stake.

Kenny G, Auburn has not been proven guilty. I guess the osu has not either. All in all, the head coach of the osu (Notice the lower case osu) is an admitted liar. I know you osu fans can not stand THE SEC (Notice the caps), but at least we have not been caught for something so stupid as players getting tattoos. Do your guys go to any of their classes? Who trades memorabilia after AJ Green gets caught (Note he had no idea he violated a rule)? If it happened before Green got caught, why not get out ahead of the press? Why would you suppress the facts? I think osu has been so ashamed of their record vs The SEC that they would ignore anything to win. BTW, good luck with this deal, you osu fans will need it.

Go Dawgs!
Tommy

Absolutely agree, Chris Korman. And for all you readers who don't understand what's probably going to happen, see Bruce Pearl, Dez Bryant, and a host of others. Pearl, the head basketball coach at Tennessee, lied to the NCAA about recruiting violations; he's gone. Bryant lied to the NCAA about contacts he had with Dion Sanders; he was declared ineligible and lost his entire senior at Oklahoma State. Tressel allowed ineligible players to play the entire 2010 season and lied to the NCAA about it. The Obstruction State University probably is going to have its 2010 victories vacated. Tressel the Liar should be fired.

Reply to Jim: The problem is not what the players did, they'll serve thier suspension, not graduate, and move on to the NFL. Tressel deliberately lied to the NCAA to keep those players eligible and to win games. The NCAA has already soiled themselves by allowing the players to play in a Bowl game and postponing the suspensions into the next season, proving that TV ratings and money are the top priority. They won't let this one go unpunished and not being able to coach against Akron is not much punishment. Tressel signed a statement that he was unaware of any NCAA violations, a cold blooded lie, and in my opinion borders on fraud. Nice guy to coach your kid, huh?

Thanks, all, for commenting here. Good discussion so far.

Eric, I've long admitted that the NCAA system as a whole is unfair to the "student-athletes" who do the work. I've written on this very blog that players in the marquee sports of football and men's basketball should be paid. And I've criticized the NCAA frequently for being double-faced; its pious money grubbing is enough to make me nauseous.

That being said, the NCAA remains in charge of college sports. It flexes its enforcement muscles on matters such as these -- or extra phone calls -- because it has no muscle in other areas. It can't fix the larger problems because it is the larger problem. So it hounds on issues like this so it can puff its chest about reform and sanctity and doing what's right.

Within that context, getting rid of Tressel is the right move. Whether the punishment fits the crime -- wouldn't you be fired for concealing something significant from your bosses? -- can be debated. But Tressel already operates in a skewered world and has received a bloated salary made possible due to the discounted price of player labor.

Thanks, again, for stopping by the read.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Verification (needed to reduce spam):

ADVERTISEMENT

Most Recent Comments
The Burning Question
ADVERTISEMENT

Baltimore Sun blog updates

 Subscribe to this feed
Charm City Current
Stay connected