'Murder for Two' at Chicago Shakes: Without a real suspect, 'Murder' will remain a misdemeanor
THEATER REVIEW: "Murder for Two – A Killer Musical" ★★ Through June 19 Upstairs at Chicago Shakespeare Theater, Navy Pier; Running time: 1 hour, 30 minutes; Tickets: $25-$30 at 312-595-5600 or www.chicagoshakes.com. With Joe Kinosian and Alan Schmuckler.
In “Murder for Two — A Killer Musical,” the campy new whodunit at Chicago Shakespeare Theater, two piano-playing actors play 14 characters. Or more precisely, the actor Alan Schmuckler plays the police officer trying to solve a country-house murder, while Joe Kinosian, who co-wrote this frenetic, 90-minute show with Kellen Blair, plays all 13 of the suspects.
“Murder for Two” partly follows the playbook of successful shows like “The 39 Steps,” wherein four actors play something like 140 characters, and partly spoofs the traditional setup (detective, isolated locale, array of suspects with ample motives) of Agatha Christie murder mysteries such as “Ten Little Indians.” Second City is currently doing something similar on Norwegian cruise ships. “Murder for Two,” which also recalls John Kander and Fred Ebb's “Curtains,” also throws an original score into the mix (music by Kinosian, lyrics by Blair).
Such tours de force can be fun for an audience (and, with only two actors, profitable for summer-stock theaters). Indeed, “Murder for Two,” which is premiering as part of CST's new-works initiative, has its amusements. You'll laugh at some of the shtick.
But director David H. Bell's production forgets a couple of crucial truths. Shows with actors playing multiple characters only really work if the actors disappear inside the roles. Kinosian doesn't disappear anywhere. He's certainly a very entertaining personality with a plethora of talents and eye-popping energy. But if he got any bigger or showier, he'd be holding back the tides of Lake Michigan.