Google Stops Taking Street View Pics in Germany

There won’t be any new Street View pics of Germany from Google. Even after the company won a battle in a German court in March, which ruled that it’s legal in Germany to take pictures from the street even from the Street View camera’s height of 10 feet, a Google spokesperson told Search Engine Land that it has other priorities:

Our business priority is to use our Google cars to collect data such as street names and road signs to improve our basic maps for our users in a similar way that other mapping companies do.

Existing imagery of streets in the 20 cities already covered in Germany will remain. There’s no further info about Google’s reasons for halting its Street View photography, but we’re thinking one reason could be that the company’s growing weary of blurring pictures of buildings requested by German citizens, the number of which is pushing 250,000 at the moment and growing ever larger.

Google’s been acting in good faith throughout this drama, negotiating with the Germans, letting them choose whether they’d like to be included in the Street Views, and facing accusations of gathering data from open Wi-Fi signals, which Google said was inadvertent.

Google’s been having more trouble with Street View in other countries lately as well, including France, where Google was fined $142,000 for privacy violations in March. Different countries have various privacy laws, but we’re not thinking people have a reasonable expectation of privacy when they’re walking down a public street. Even so, Google will let anyone in the world opt out of Street View if they so desire.

Tell us in the comments why you think Google has halted its Street View photography in Germany. Could Germany just be the first in a series of countries objecting to Google’s ubiquitous photography?

Print Story Email Story

More Stories in Social Media

Top Related Stories

  • http://twitter.com/WoollyMittens WoollyMittens

    Germany hates progress. Why are they even on the internet? They never make any English language pages anyway. At least the French had the common sense to make their own national internet (minitel) way back when.

  • http://twitter.com/WoollyMittens WoollyMittens

    Germany hates progress. Why are they even on the internet? They never make any English language pages anyway. At least the French had the common sense to make their own national internet (minitel) way back when.

  • http://atli.advefir.com/ Atli Þór

    Come on. There are “privacy” concerns and then there is just plain paranoia. Do people really thing somebody is using Google Street View to spy on them? What exactly are they afraid of?

    If I take a picture of a crowded German/French street, or of a random house, and post it on my blog, am I also subject to privacy suits? Best leave my camera at home when I go visit Germany I guess. (Which I will. I like German people :))

    I don’t blame Google for not bothering to provide this free service to a country that clearly doesn’t want it.

  • http://atli.advefir.com/ Atli Þór

    Come on. There are “privacy” concerns and then there is just plain paranoia. Do people really thing somebody is using Google Street View to spy on them? What exactly are they afraid of?

    If I take a picture of a crowded German/French street, or of a random house, and post it on my blog, am I also subject to privacy suits? Best leave my camera at home when I go visit Germany I guess. (Which I will. I like German people :))

    I don’t blame Google for not bothering to provide this free service to a country that clearly doesn’t want it.

  • http://www.dennisjsmith.com Dennis J. Smith

    My nephew was walking down his street on the way home and was captured in the Street View photos. My brother and his wife didn’t care. I like it because I can use Navigator and see what a place looks like when I arrive. I’ve also used to describe a place over the phone to a friend who couldn’t find a local business.

  • http://www.dennisjsmith.com Dennis J. Smith

    My nephew was walking down his street on the way home and was captured in the Street View photos. My brother and his wife didn’t care. I like it because I can use Navigator and see what a place looks like when I arrive. I’ve also used to describe a place over the phone to a friend who couldn’t find a local business.

  • http://leanderwattig.de Leander Wattig

    There are many Germans who think that blocking photos taken from public streets and places is stupid.

  • http://leanderwattig.de Leander Wattig

    There are many Germans who think that blocking photos taken from public streets and places is stupid.

  • http://www.LauriePringle.com/ Laurie Pringle

    Don’t kid yourself – a variety of organizations will use that information to help determine how much money you have. If you own a home and it’s well kept, with a nice garden and expensive landscaping, it’s reasonable to assume that you spend money on those items. If your home is in good repair, but the windows are older – or the roof appears to have issues, someone can use that information to identify you as a sales prospect and determine your income level and potential purchasing power.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1102803460 Rolf Lange

    Your comment fails. Germans do not hate progress. Otherwise they wouldn’t be the worlds no. 1 export nation, esp. in technology and manufacturing. Nevertheless we are pretty serious with privacy, sometimes too much as I think (esp. in that Google case).

    But however, this has nothing to do with making English version of web pages anyway. I see all important German companies offering English versions of their web content. I can’t remember any important English speaking company offering German content.

  • http://twitter.com/karpathy Andrej Karpathy

    But someone can just walk up to your house and have a look anyway. It’s a publically viewable space just like any other. The same can be said of clothes that people wear. Should we be worried about people who take pictures of you in your clothes? This is a completely ridiculous debate.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Antoniolopez Antonio Lopez Reyes

    Mexico should be more concerned about street view for the violence we are experiencing with drug dealers and all that. But we are accepting Google’s Street View anyway. The world is changing and we need to change with it. It is changing the way I work as a translator for good. Thanks Google.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Muhannad-Agha/1592874453 Muhannad Agha

    noobs.. this is for ur own good!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Muhannad-Agha/1592874453 Muhannad Agha

    noobs.. this is for ur own good!

  • Anonymous

    People should have the right not to have their homes, faces, children, published in the Internet for billions of people to see. There are pedophiles, robbers, crazies, and just people who might really dislike you, who you might not want to know too much about you. For the same reason, cell phone numbers are not published and people have the right to opt out of phone directories. Google does not have a universal right to display all this information without people’s consent, no matter how cool it is.

  • http://www.facebook.com/GoncaloBrito Gonçalo Brito

    Google street was also banned from my sad, sad country, Portugal, on account of privacy issues. Like me and my friends said back then, there must be a lot of people doing a lot of nasty lillegals around the streets of Portugal…

  • http://www.facebook.com/roy.hayward Roy Hayward

    First, I don’t see the privacy issue. I am not a expert on German Law, but apparently the judge and/or jury in the Germain court didn’t see the issue either.

    Second, is there legitimate use? Although this may not be a point of law, my opinion is swayed by it. Taking pictures of peoples property to post on your blog may not sound legit. But posting everyone’s house on a site linked to mapping to create a pictorial map is.

    So where I could understand being annoyed if someone was following me around with the google street view car, what google is doing has a good purpose.

    Privacy does not mean anonymity. Unethical uses for something does not mean that it should be illegal or abandoned. Otherwise our knowledge, progress and security in the world would be vastly limited.

    Like having a phone number listed in indexes of phone numbers. It can be annoying but most uses are positive. And there is adequate facility to opt out of the phone book, and it seems to opt out of google street view.

  • Anonymous

    I think Google is waiting out for any country to figure out when they are ready for this type of technological advancement. Many are concerned about privacy initially especially when it has been breached. Some cultures are more open about it. We all know that all countries have valuable input they bring to the table of technology some aspect take a bit longer to embrace. I was born and raised in Germany and I don’t have an issues with Street View, in the matter of fact I would love to see more of it and certainly more updates.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_F3PQEDS2YE26BEAEL3YA5P7HOY ilona

    yep, and more than that…you can be fined for not having a fence around your pool..etc..tax evaders have been caught with boats on their prop. many reasons people may want to opt out.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_F3PQEDS2YE26BEAEL3YA5P7HOY ilona

    yep, and more than that…you can be fined for not having a fence around your pool..etc..tax evaders have been caught with boats on their prop. many reasons people may want to opt out.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_F3PQEDS2YE26BEAEL3YA5P7HOY ilona

    i’m sorry, but that is just silly…where is your proof that germany hates progress?

blog comments powered by Disqus