www.fgks.org   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

Iroquois Nationals forfeits first game

Governments’ passport snafu blocks team travel

By Gale Courey Toensing

NEW YORK – A week-long international dispute over the use of Haudenosaunee passports has caused the Iroquois Nationals to forfeit the opening game of the 2010 World Lacrosse Championships, but team members were still hoping to fly to England for the remaining matches.

The top-ranking Iroquois Nationals lacrosse team was still in New York on Thursday, July 15 when they were supposed to play a match against the English host team at 7 p.m. Manchester time on the opening day of the world championships.

The team’s lawyers and board members were continuing diplomatic efforts with the British government to issue visas for the 50-person delegation of players, coaches, family members and supporters.

“I feel betrayed, and I have 23 players here who are anxious to play,” Percy Abrams, the Iroquois Nationals executive director, told AOL News in New York. “We’re just trying to keep up hope that somehow we’ll be able to make game two this Saturday.”

By Thursday, team members had overcome a barrier to their travel posed by the U.S. government and now faced obstacles placed by the British and Canadian governments.

But their spirits were bolstered when they showed up at a field in Oyster Bay on Long Island to practice, and found signs posted in the neighborhood saying, “Welcome Nationals!” We support you!” “Go Nationals!”

A crowd had gathered to watch them practice and cheer them on, and many told the players that they had called and e-mailed British officials in support of the team.

The team was scheduled to leave July 11, but three days earlier the British government announced it would not recognize the Haudenosaunee Confederacy passports and asked the U.S. government for written assurance that the players would be allowed to return to their homes.

The U.S. government also refused to honor the Iroquois passports even though they’ve been used for decades for international travel.

The State Department earlier had offered to provide team members with U.S. passports – an offer that was unanimously refused because it would violate the sovereignty of the six Haudenosaunee (or Iroquois) Confederacy nations – the Onondaga, Mohawk, Seneca, Oneida, Tuscarora and Cayuga.

After an international media blitz and outpourings of support from thousands of people, the State Department decided on July 14 to provide the British with the assurance they sought and agreed to issue one-time waivers that would allow the players to travel on their Haudenosaunee passports. But by that time the British had set a new condition: Team members must travel on U.S. or Canadian passports.

By Thursday, the Canadian government had not yet confirmed whether it would intervene on behalf of the 14 members of the Iroquois delegation who are from the northern side of the U.S.-Canadian border who hold Haudenosaunee passports – but the passport dispute sparked a debate in Canada over First Nations rights.

“The Immigration and Refugee Protection Act specifies that Canadian citizens and registered Indians under the Indian Act have a right to enter Canada,” Immigration spokeswoman Karen Shadd said in a statement published in the National Post. “Furthermore, these persons are also exempt from the requirement to hold a document to enter Canada.”

According to Passport Canada, the Canadian passport issued by Ottawa is the only “official” document for travel abroad.

Gavin Taylor, a Native history professor at Concordia University in Montreal, told the Post that the Canadian government has avoided dealing fully with the Native mobility issue for centuries and is now facing the consequences.

“If they explicitly allow the Iroquois to travel on their own passport, it does open up a Pandora’s box of problems because other groups might also claim their own passports. ... and the Canadian government does claim to have jurisdiction over these people even if they deny that jurisdiction.”

Ironically, the first known person to travel on a Native passport was the great Cayuga Chief Deskaheh, a representative of the Iroquois people in Ontario.

In 1923, holding a passport issued by the Haudenosaunee authorities, he traveled to Geneva to the League of Nations headquarters seeking justice for his people against infringements by the Canadian government. His goal was to ask the league to admit the Federation of the Six Nations and to request compliance with a 1784 treaty between his people and King George III of Great Britain.

He spent a year trying to get an audience with league authorities, but was turned away.

Both the U.S. and British governments said that the Haudenosaunee passports no longer meet the security criteria that were toughened up after the 9/11 attacks. The passports lack the high-tech features associated with the beefed up documents, such as holograms, microchips and other machine-readable information.

But the U.S. rejection of the Haudenosaunee passports comes at an odd time, since the Haudenosaunee Documentation Committee has been working with the State Department and the Department of Homeland Security for more than two years on designing and producing enhanced Haudenosaunee passports and “red cards” – identification cards from the individual Haudenosaunee nations, said the Onondaga Nation’s attorney Joe Heath.

“It’s involved dozens of meetings with the DHS and State Department, and several millions of dollars of investment. There’s a memorandum of agreement and it’s so close to being finalized that this (passport dispute) is really another level of irony here.”

The most obvious level of irony, however, is that the Iroquois people invented lacrosse – “the Creator’s game” – more than 900 years ago are being prevented from playing in the world championships.

The game has profound and multilayered spiritual, cultural, and physical meanings to the Haudenosaunee people.

“When you talk about lacrosse, you talk about the lifeblood of the Six Nations. The game is ingrained into our culture, our system and our lives,” said Oren Lyons, Onondaga Faithkeeper, former All-American lacrosse goalie, and the honorary chairman of the Iroquois Nationals.

The Iroquois’ absence will diminish the championships’ meaning, said Neil Goulding, spokesman for the Federation of International Lacrosse, which organizes and sponsors the world championships.

“It really is a shame, as we feel like we’re losing a connection with the sport’s heritage,” he said on AOL News. “The Iroquois had been due to open the tournament with an ancient blessing ceremony, where sacred tobacco is burnt and prayers are chanted. Now the games are just going to start with a few words from Manchester’s Lord Mayor.”

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Amanda said on Monday, Jul 19 at 12:51 PM

@forall - You best believe we would rather not have to take those "non-indian tax dollars" for infastructure on Indian lands. However, since our land and our whole way of life was taken from us, tribes are having to accept these funds to help rebuild and work back into self-sustaining communities. Not to mention the United States responsibility to give them that money based on the treaties they signed with Native people in exchange for all their land. I think that 402 million you speak of is chump change compared to what we should have. Why don't you focus your worries and contempt on people who are really costing the tax-payers for no good reason like the prisioners and/or folks that are on welfare who have children they can't properly care for.

47882004
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Madeleine Blu said on Monday, Jul 19 at 7:05 AM

Hello forall, It is their Land; the wealth of the Land is theirs. The true Americans preserved their Land in pristine condition before the arrival of the Europeans. They did not destroy and gouge out the earth for minerals; they did not dig for oil resulting in the awful destruction of wild animals, birds and sea creatures. Try to understand. Where are you originally from? Europe? Asia? The Americans I have met would give their right arm to see the Native Americans walk as Kings in their own land again and to learn their ways in the care of earth and animal. They desire to be accepted, forgiven and united with the Native American so that they can truly call themselves American and walk together forever.

47856134
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

forall said on Sunday, Jul 18 at 3:43 PM

Sovereign? Then why do Indian Nations accross the U.S. continue to take tax-dollars of non-indian citizens for things like infrastructure on indian lands (402 million dollars in 2009)?

47824399
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Madeleine Blu said on Saturday, Jul 17 at 4:48 PM

In the light of the Iroquois stressing that they will conform to any and all security requirements, including strip searching and having their rooms bugged, the answer from UK Borders is not pertinent, relevant, and far from the stated requests of the British people. We have already signed to the Protection of Indigenous peoples at the United Nations. Why then have UK Borders refused this request? UK Borders in their sullen and uncooperative manner with the USA and the Iroquois, are harmful to the British public by representing them in this manner. I do beseech all UK citizens to write to their Member of Parliament as well.

47769029
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Madeleine Blu said on Saturday, Jul 17 at 4:47 PM

Britain should grant this request from the Iroquois. I am writing to my Member of Parliament that the UK should be mindful of the ignoble part it has played in the Americas. Britain is as responsible for the murder of the true Americans and the subsequent stealing of their Land as is the USA and Canada. If the USA has the greatness in God to recognize the Spirit of Reconciliation coming from the Iroquois and has responded in kind through Mrs Clinton, so should Britain. Although we cannot bring back the dead, or re -grow Buffalo, this reasonable request from the Iroquois should be seen as an opportunity, an answer to prayers, to acknowledge our dark and disgraceful history and attempt to put right what we have done wrong. (Continued below)

47768959
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Dan said on Saturday, Jul 17 at 1:36 PM

"Both the U.S. and British governments said that the Haudenosaunee passports no longer meet the security criteria that were toughened up after the 9/11 attacks." - If I'm not mistaken, these passports were used in 2002 to go to Australia and again in 2006 to go to Canada (for the American contingent). Anyway, where's an Indian gonna hi-jack a plane to? (Ironically, the comedian who said that was Charlie Hill, an Oneida of the Iroquois Confederacy) "The passports lack the high-tech features associated with the beefed up documents, such as holograms, microchips and other machine-readable information." - So really these simplistic people in their bureaucracies just wanted to be entertained by the holograms?

47760239
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

The Creators game said on Saturday, Jul 17 at 9:28 AM

The Creators game was rightfully given to the Iroquois by the creator, as a game of peace to resolve conflicts and give thanks to the creator/god. The British have dishonored and disgraced themselves in the creators’ eyes. A nation at war should not play a game of peace given by the creator. Also claiming a right to play and against the rightful owners and then barring them, not honorable. To say another nation’s documents are inferior is shameful when the event is promoting awareness of discrimination and it then bars the nation, the rightful owners who come to honor the game and the creator in peace. Who is a dishonor in god’s eyes, those whose words have power, honor and bring peace or those whose words have no power, no honor and do not bring peace?

47745299
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Cynthia Smoke-Akwesasne said on Saturday, Jul 17 at 12:12 AM

Its always the same story. Someone doesn't trust the Onkwehonwe. They don't understand our customs and ways. May the Creator guide the team through their plight and give them the prowress of the air, water and land animals! Go On Kwe Hon Weh !! Go SIX NATIONS!

47728709
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Cynthia Smoke-Akwesasne said on Saturday, Jul 17 at 12:02 AM

Our simplistic ways of culture and tradition simply astound pilgrims. Today centuries later their concepts of the true people remain the same. May the Creator guide the team with agility, prowress and the speed of all air water and land animals!! GO ONKWEHONWEH GO SIX NATIONS!!!

47728244
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Skinwalker said on Friday, Jul 16 at 10:53 PM

Where's Osama or the bin laden connection they worked out a monetary scam with terror WAR. The secret is out we hold the truth of who we are and never retreat my relations. Now leave the sacred out and work the game.

47724559
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

beloved said on Friday, Jul 16 at 8:00 PM

@go ahead catherine... let it out... i agree you've got my attention!!

47714089
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

NDN_Woman said on Friday, Jul 16 at 2:43 PM

If the Iroquois can use their own passports to travel, then why can't other Indigenous People in the US make their own passports for travel? Do people need to be members of federal tribes to make their own passports? Just wondering.

47688254
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Janice said on Friday, Jul 16 at 2:30 PM

Well good for the Iroquois for taking that stand against the government and working with SG and DHS to create a passport that works for them. Its always frustrating when other governments come into the scene where they need to be brought up to speed with new developments and it takes so long to convince them....happens with my nation too, all to often and seems we are always repeating ourselves. Good luck!

47687094
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

William Pacheco said on Friday, Jul 16 at 1:40 PM

We're only sovereign according to how they want us to be.

47681794
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

catherine davids said on Friday, Jul 16 at 12:58 PM

The Iroquois people are sovereign nation within the borders of the United States and this is NO different than the Vatican, a sovereign nation, within the borders of Italy. Vatican citizens have their own passports, too. This is not a complicated issue - this is simply a tactic to keep one of the world's best sports team from competing. Britain doesn't really believe the United States would refuse to allow the Iroquois athletes and their families back into the United States. That is a ridiculous argument. Britian just does not want the Iroquois coming into Manchester to play Lacrosse. These are cowardly decisions and actions by England - a country who might still feel the sting of defeat several hundred years ago and they don't want in resurrected on a playing field. That is about all I can say without starting a rant-and-rave that would be heard from the Great Lakes across the Pond to the Queen herself.

47677369
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

By posting a comment, user agrees to all Terms Of Use. Comments may also appear in other website locations and in other Indian Country Today products, without notice and at the discretion of Indian Country Today.

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand

Quantcast