On Wednesday night's (January 10) episode of "American Idol" provided a handful of surprises, some wacky choreography, some interesting vocal choices and a handful of early favorites.
One of the bigger disappointments of the night was the performance by the group who called itself "The Phoenix," consisting of contestants Kat Nestel, Moorea Masa, Ben Honeycutt, Jeffery Goldford and Jermaine Sellers. They were thrown a curve ball when Nestel decided to quit just before the group had to perform, and clearly the team couldn't hold it together enough to make it through (although Jeffery and Jermaine were still given a pass). Their performance was especially a shame because they butchered a fantastic and underrated song: Kansas' "Carry On Wayward Son."
The tune, which appeared on the prog rockers' 1976 album Leftoverture, is one of the greatest and most misunderstood songs of the '70s. It's an epic tune with a killer melody that has often been used as shorthand for the excesses and general bloodlessness of prog. Admittedly, it has a lot going against it, as the album version is over five minutes long and the lyric sheet makes references to "wise men" and "stormy seas of moving emotion." Plus, frontman Steve Walsh's voice is sort of high and he sometimes played shirtless and oily (as the photo above proves). It's no wonder it's the song lame dad Randy Marsh chose to play on the "Guitar Hero" episode of "South Park."
But on the other hand, "Carry On Wayward Son" totally rocks. The riff is magnificent, the solos are killer and the chorus is a total fist-pumper. In fact, it does something that not enough songs do: It leads with the chorus. (You know, like "Dude Looks Like a Lady.") It sounds great coming out of a car stereo, and it's also an excellent karaoke song. And yeah, it happens to be one of the most fun tunes to play on "Guitar Hero."
It's not the first time that "Carry On Wayward Son" has made an appearance on "American Idol," as rock chick Amanda Overmyer trotted out the tune during the seventh season of the show. It seemed like an odd choice for the Phoenix, and as it doesn't seem like there are many prog rockers left in this year's batch of contestants, perhaps it'll be the last we hear of it for a while (on the show, at least). But whether you head to iTunes now or fire it up on "Guitar Hero," do yourself a favor and allow "Carry On Wayward Son" to take you away. (If you're really feeling dangerous, pair it with "Dust in the Wind.")