By Christabel Nsiah-Buadi
Producer, The Laura Flanders Show
Air America Radio
This week, in their first article in Newsweek since the magazine was dressed-down by Scott McClellan in a White House press conference, Michael Isikoff and Evan Thomas’ quote a Defense Department spokesman Lawrence DiRita, who alleges that Guantanamo commanders followed up each and every complaint they received from detainees about disrespect for Islam.
But DiRita's comments cry out for corroboration.
What DiRita has to say couldn’t be further from the experience of Martin Mubanga, a British Muslim who was arrested in Zambian by local authorities after returning from Afghanistan, handed to the U.S. and subsequently detained in Guantanamo Bay for 33 months until July 2005.
In his first broadcast interview with the US media on Sunday May 22, Martin Mubanga told Laura Flanders, host of The Laura Flanders Show, broadcast on Air America Radio, that offensive treatment of the Koran at Guantanamo Bay was routine – and complaints by inmates about the desecration of the Koran fell upon deaf ears, and often resulted in severe punishment, including pepper-spraying of prisoners.
Mubanga told Laura Flanders that US Military Police at Guantanamo often used religion as a means to provoke the inmates. Mubanga himself was forced to watch Military Police officers thrown his Qur’an on the floor during a search:
‘…there were two (Military Police officers) on either side of me, holding my wrists as I was kneeling down, and they had me in wristlocks. And one of the three that were searching took my Qu’ran. And instead of replacing it, to its place, one military policeman threw that on the floor… ‘
And, according to Mubanga, disregard of Muslim practices didn’t end at mishandling the Qur’an either:
‘The officials or the hierarchies used to punish us with regard to our religion by shaving our hair or shaving our beards…there was a particular bloc ‘Quebec Bloc’ and ‘Romeo Bloc’, which is in Camp Three of Delta Camp, where they would give shorts to brothers. And in our religion, you are not permitted to pray whilst your knees are uncovered.’
DiRita also says that in 2002, partly in response to an incident where a guard ‘inadvertently knocked a Qur’an from its pouch onto the floor of a detainee’s cell’, Guantanamo commanders issued ‘precise rules to respect the “cultural dignity of the Koran thereby reducing the friction over the searching of the Korans.”
Again, Mubanga’s first-hand experience of Guantanamo directly contradicts the comments of DiRita. He told Laura Flanders that it was the detainees who created guidelines that would ensure more respectful treatment of the Koran – not camp officials. When the detainees asked Camp officials, including General Jeffrey Miller, to enforce these guidelines, their requests, were, ‘refused point blank…subsequently, (the inmates) thought that they should do some sort of actions to show their anger and to try and reverse this decision, which resulted in many people being ‘earthed’.
Mubanga, describes ‘being earthed’ as a procedure that involves a minimum of five Military Police officers, dressed in riot gear with riot shields who, ‘would come in and manhandle you and put you to the floor. On occasion, you would be pepper sprayed, you’d be tied and carried out to the place that you are supposed to go’.
What the Defense Department won’t tell you is how its policy is translated by the guards in Guantanamo Bay – Mubanga provided some interesting insight:
‘…There were a few (soldiers) who were quite simply following orders and rightly or wrongly they would follow those orders because they saw no alternative other than themselves being remonstrated or reprimanded. You know, there were a few who had a hatred for the Islamic religion and the Islamic way of life… and people from the East and had a general ignorance toward the religion, and um, anything that was not American.’
Mubanga’s view of his treatment in Guantanamo Bay is clear and damning, ‘I was not given my rights, my legal rights as a British citizen, or as an individual. I was not treated humanely… I feel that they wanted to do whatever they had to do to bring back the result that they required or that they wanted’. And Human Rights advocates, lawyers, detainees, their families, even former Guantanamo Bay would agree with his version of events.
Erik Saar, a former US army sergeant, who was a translator in Guantanamo Bay from December 2002 until June 2003, describes how one female interrogator who smeared a prisoner with red ink, claimed it was menstrual blood and left, saying, "Have a fun night in your cell without any water to clean yourself" in his book, Inside the Wire. Likewise, you can read written testimony from current and former Guantanamo Bay detainees, who cite examples of offensive behavior towards the Koran in the Report into the Systematic and Institutionalized U.S. Desecration of the Qur’an and other Islamic Rituals, which can be found on the Islamic human rights website, CagePrisoners.com.
Meanwhile, advocacy groups for one reason or another can’t corroborate or refute the Defense Department’s recent statements about prisoner abuse. Jumana Musa, an Advocacy Director for Amnesty International USA says, ‘It’s impossible for most human rights organizations to get access to any of these US detention facilities to see what really happens. And I think that if all of these detentions were acting in compliance with International law, we wouldn’t have this problem . . .".
One human rights organization that has some access to detention facilities like Camp Delta in Guantanamo Bay is the International Commission of the Red Cross (ICRC). Unfortunately, the ICRC refuses to make any more public comments on the issue, as I found out when I asked Simon Schorno, spokesperson for the ICRC.
One gets the feeling that the White House is conducting a huge PR offensive, but how long can it last?