www.fgks.org   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

home / subscribe / donate / tower / books / archives / search / links / feedback / events

 

What You're Missing in our subscriber-only CounterPunch newsletter
Bush's Worst Appointment Yet?

Read Jeffrey St Clair's blazing expose of the new Interior Secretary nominee , Dirk Kempthorne, and make up your own mind. Even in the dingy history of Idaho's predators, Kempthorne stood proud as the dingiest of them all. Now he's poised to seize his place in history. Will he be the sleaziest Interior Secretary in history, sleazier than Watt, fouler than Fall? More on the great Israel Lobby debate! Norman Finkelstein blazes a new path, asks "Are the Neo-Cons really committed Zionists?" "Bliss was it in that dawn" Not in Michigan! Raymond Garcia describes Dem governor's appalling plan to scapegoat youth and teachers. Plus the full print version of Virginia Tilley's savage dissection on this website of the double-standard onslaught on Hamas by the US and EU. CounterPunch Online is read by millions of viewers each month! But remember, we are funded solely by the subscribers to the print edition of CounterPunch. Please support this website by buying a subscription to our newsletter, which contains fresh material you won't find anywhere else, or by making a donation for the online edition. Remember contributions are tax-deductible. Click here to make a donation. If you find our site useful please: Subscribe Now!

Get CounterPunch By Email for Only $35 a Year

Flamenco Hits Portland!

Today's Stories

May 20 / 21, 2006

Patrick Cockburn
iraq is Disintegrating

May 19, 2006

Winslow T. Wheeler
Democrats and the Defense Budget: Just as Ruinous as the Republicans

José Pertierra
Posada Carriles: Extradite or Prosecute, There's No Other Option

John Ross
The Marcos Factor: Mexico's Electoral Wildcard

Dave Lindorff
Virtual America

Jeff Juel
Ecological Extortion in the National Forests?

Alan Farago
Defanging the Endangered Species Act

Eric Johnson-DeBaufre
Building a New Sanctuary Movement

José Martî
Letter to Manuel Mercado: "The Revolution Desires Complete Freedom"

Jonathan Cook
Marriage Ban Closes the Gates to Palestinians

Website of the Day
Fix the Movie and Revolutionize the Movie Industry!

 

May 18, 2006

Bill Simpich
Building a Movement that will be Stronger After the US is Out of Iraq: Lessons from the 1970 Student Strike

Patrick Cockburn
The Carnage in Basra

Christopher Brauchli
The Needle and the Damage Done: the Death Penalty's Ministers

Nora Barrows-Friedman
The Nakba in Palestine

Victoria Buch
In the Name of Israel's State Security

Eric Ruder
Nuclear Hypocrites

George Wuerthner
The Ice Cream Wilderness?

Juan Santos
The Border War Comes Home

Website of the Day
Help Stop Animal Torture at Devore

 

May 17, 2006

Lenni Brenner
The Lobby and the Great Protestant Crusader

Carlos Villarreal
Immigrant Scapegoats and the Manufacturing of a Crisis

Larry Everest
Catching Rumsfeld Red-Handed: an Interview with Ray McGovern

CounterPunch News Service
Hugo Chavez: the London Sessions

Lee Sustar
Compromise and Conquer? Inside the Senate Immigration Bill

Anthony Papa
Dealing with the Rockefeller Drug Laws: a Tale of Two DAs

William S. Lind
Ink Blots and Super Fortresses: More Contradictions from Iraq War

Bruce K. Gagnon
Where are the Real Leaders?

JoAnn Wypijewski
Has Anything Really Changed at Fort Sill?

Website of the Day
The Pacific Northwest: Animated

 

May 16, 2006

Ward Churchill
Punishing Free Speech

Ted Honderich
The Moral Barbarism of Blair and Bush

Paul Craig Roberts
Ministry of Fear

Annie Nocenti
"Jesus was a Zombie?": Letter from Haiti

Charles V. Peña
Regime Change Redux: US Plans for Iran Go Far Beyond Nuclear Efforts

Ron Jacobs
Circling the Wagons and Building Walls: Bush and Co.'s Immigration Policy

Norman Solomon
A Sick, Hungry Well-Armed Nation

Harvey Wasserman
Why the Fundamentalists Are Freaking Out Over the Da Vinci Code

Michael George Smith
Bush, Immigration and the Democrats

Harry Browne
New Frontiers of Shamelessness: Bono's Independent

Website of the Day
Seeger: "Bring Them Home"

 

May 15, 2006

Alexander Cockburn
Abe Rosenthal's Times

William Blum
Appealing to the US is Not Very Appealing

Tanya Golash-Boza and Douglas A. Parker
Dehumanizing the Undocumented: an Immigration Policy Statement by Sociologists Without Borders

Dave Lindorff
Gen. Hayden's Sedition Against the Consitution

Debra Schaffer Hubert
The Battle Cry of G.I. Jesus: Capital Punishment for Gays?

Patrick Cockburn
Now It's Shia Troops Versus Kurdish Troops in Iraq

Tom Turnipseed
The Messianic Presidency

Ken Livingstone
Welcome to London, President Chavez!

Gideon Levy
Game Theory: Hamas is Winning

Mickey Z.
Is Impeachment Too Good for Bush?

Jeff Faux
What Bush's Speech Will Miss: Immigration and the Desperate Mexican Economy

Website of the Day
Iraq War Images Uncensored

 

May 13 / 14, 2006

Vijay Prashad
The Indian Road: Left Triumph

Joan Roelofs
Why They Hate Our Kind Hearts, Too

Kathy Kelly
Imagining Survival

Michael Neumann
On the Value and Stability of Israel

Dr. Susan Block
Hookergate

Daniel Cassidy
How the Irish Invented Poker

Christopher Reed
Rebel Journalist: the Memoirs of Wilfred Burchett

Mike Roselle
The Fallacies of Greenpeace

Saul Landau
Up the Mekong to Cambodia

Robert Fisk
The Inescapable Beat: US Military Bases in Brazil

Ralph Nader
Sally Mae and the Student Loan Swindle

Evelyn Pringle
Rove and Fitzgerald Play Monopoly

Fred Gardner
The Marketing of "Cannabis Americana"

Stanley Heller
Is Another Mass Murder of Arabs in the Offing?

Conn Hallinan
China: a Troubled Dragon

Valentina Palma Novoa
"They Ordered Me to Lay My Head in a Pool of Blood"

David Krieger
Why Nuclear Weapons Should Matter

Col. Dan Smith
The Senate's Peace Quilt

Christopher Brauchli
Mister Bush and Mister Zarqawi: Video Stars

Jeffrey St. Clair
Playlist: What I'm Listening to This Week

Poets' Basement
Davies, Ford, Engel, Guthrie, Orloski and Louise

Website of the Weekend
Not Your Soldier!

 

May 12, 2006

Michael Snedeker
Death by Snitch: the Attempted Murder of Michael Morales

Dave Lindorff
What Fourth Amendment?

Leah Fishbein / RJ Schinner
Santorum vs. Santorum-Lite: In Pennsylvania, Abortion is Absent from the Debate

Brian Kwoba
The Immigrant Rights Movement: Birth of a New New Left?

Chris Kromm
Why Southern Progressives Should Support an Estate Tax

Kai Diekmann
45 Minutes with Bush: the BILD Interview

David Swanson
Bush Tops Nixon: the Most Despised President in History

Virginia Tilley
Hamas and Israel's "Right to Exist"

Website of the Day
The CounterPunch Story That Made the Front Page of the NYT Today

 

May 11, 2006

Sunsara Taylor
Battle Cry for Theocracy: Meet the Shock Troops of the Christian Youth

Jonathan Cook
A Short History of Unilateral Separation

Tariq Ali
High-Octane Rocket-Rattling Against Iran Won't Work

Wayne S. Smith
Recycled Non Sequiturs: State Dept. Presents No Evidence Cuba is a "Terrorist State"

Mike Whitney
Secretary of Lies

Pratyush Chandra
The Royal Nepalese Army and the Imperialist Agency

Joshua Frank
Save Darfur? Not So Fast

Mickey Z.
Does Property Destruction Equal Eco-Terrorism?

Francis Boyle
Abe Rosenthal Stole My Kill Fee!

Edward S. Herman / David Peterson
US Aggression-Time Once Again: Target Iran

Website of the Day
The Missing Papers of John Roberts

 

May 10, 2006

Werther
Axiom of Evil

Larry Birns / Michael Lettieri
Is Venezuela the New Niger?: the Bush Administration is Trying to Link Hugo Chavez to Iran's Nuclear Program

Ramzy Baroud
Iran and the US: Nuclear Standoff or Realpolitik?

Kevin Zeese
The Corporate Takeover of Iraq's Economy

Evelyn Pringle
Peter Rost vs. Goliath: an Ex-Pfizer VP Takes on Big Pharma

Amira Hass
Hungry and Shell-Shocked

Michael Donnelly
Nature Loses a Champion

Ron Jacobs
Singers in a Dangerous Time: Dylan and Haggard Take the Stage

Sharon Smith
Abstinence Backfires

Website of the Day
Camp In with Ray and Cindy

 

May 9, 2006

Ray McGovern
My Encounter with Rumsfeld

M. Shahid Alam
The Muslims America Loves

Moshe Adler
Mayor Bloomberg: Even Worse Than Giuliani

Walter MIgnolo
Beyond Populism: Natural Gas and Decolonization of the Bolivian Economy

Keeanga-Yamahtta Taylor
Blacks, Latinos and the New Civil Rights Movement

William S. Lind
The Other War Heats Up: Fighting on Afghan Time

Todd Chretien
Does It Really Matter Who Runs the CIA?

Dave Lindorff
Pelosi is in for a Big Surprise in November

Ishmael Reed
Furor Over the "Colored Mind Doubles"

Website of the Day
Two Years for One Joint

 

May 8, 2006

Kate McCabe
"No Less Courage": Political Prisoners' Resistance from Ireland to Gitmo

Paul Craig Roberts
A Nation of Waitresses and Bartenders

Col. Dan Smith
Privatizing West Point: "Duty, Honor, Trademarks..."

Norman Solomon
Gag and Smear: the Misuses of "Anti-Semitism"

Ingmar Lee
Bush's Destabilizing Nuke Deal with India

Robert Jensen
"Covering" and the Law

Ricardo Alarcon
The Struggle for Immigrant Rights in a Neo-Liberal Economy

Will Youmans / M. Kay Siblani
The Danders of Misunderstanding Sudan

Alexander Cockburn
The Row Over the Israel Lobby

Website of the Day
Labelle Does The Who: We Don't Get Fooled Again

 

May 6 / 7, 2006

Jeffrey St. Clair
The Rise and Possible Fall of Richard Pombo

Ariel Dorfman
Mission Akkomplished: the Secret History of George W. Bush

Joe Allen
Death Row at the "Castle": Inside the Military's Judicial System

Fred Gardner
From Ritalin to Cocaine: Steve Howe's Untold Story

Jeff Taylor
Democratic Masqueraders: Plutocracy and the Party of the People

Saul Landau
The Immigration Malaise

Stephen Philion
Lessons from the Fordham 9: Challenging CIA and Military Recruiters on Campus

Trish Schuh
Islamophobia, a Retrospective

Ralph Nader
The Tragedy of False Confessions

Robert Fisk
Through a Syrian Lens: Is the US Provoking Civil War in Iraq?

Paul Cantor
Parody of a Protest: We Came, We Marched, And ... ?

John Holt
"This Goddamn Place Looks Like Hell"

James Ryan
When is a West Point Grad, No Longer a West Point Grad?

Lawrence R. Velvel
Harvard and Its Presidents: Plagiarism, Ghostwriting, and the Character of Larry Summers

Greg Moses
Canto for a Cinco de Mayo Weekend

Laray Polk
Homeland Security Spending: a Dallas Case Study

Ron Jacobs
Subterranean Fire: a Review

Ben Tripp
No News is Good News

Mickey Z.
9/11 Movies, Anti-War Protests and "Illegal" Humans

Jeffrey St. Clair
Playlist: My Own Private, Springsteen-Free JazzFest (Week Two)

Poets' Basement
Kirbach, Landau, Davies, Engel, Buknatski, Subiet, Ford and Thoreau

Website of the Week
Lawrence Welk Meets the Velvet Underground

 

May 5, 2006

Vijay Prashad
The Charmless Inconveniences of the Bourgeoisie

Robert Fisk
Sy Hersh versus the Bush Administration (and the DC Press Corps)

David Swanson
Washington Post Writer Rushes to Rummy's Defense Against Ray McGovern

Mearsheimer / Walt
The Storm Over "the Israel Lobby"

Dave Lindorff
They're Back!: The Looters of Social Security

Sarah Ferguson
A Day Without Gringos: Immigrants Flooded the Streets of NYC on May, But Where Were the White Peaceniks?

CounterPunch News Service
Costs of US Wars: Bush's GWOT Now Fifth Most Expensive in US History

Corporate Crime Reporter
David Sirota: Still Shackled to the Democrats

Website of the Day
Watch Ray KO Rummy

 

May 4, 2006

John F. Sugg
Sami al-Arian's Final Persecution

Will Potter
Green is the New Red: How the Bush Administration is Using Terror Laws to Prosecute Nonviolent Environmental Activists

Jonathan Cook
The Long Path Back to Umm al-Zinat

Roger Burbach
Bolivia's Radical Realignment

Chris Dols
Colbert's Moment (And Why the Beltway Gang Didn't Get It)

Christopher Brauchli
Sen. Frist Without Clothes

Tony Swindell
"Our Descent into Hell has Begun"

Website of the Day
The Two Lobbies

 

May 3, 2006

Robert Bryce
The Self-Locking F-22

Paul Craig Roberts
John Kenneth Galbraith, a Great American

James Petras
The Rise of the Migrant Workers' Movement

Lee Sustar
Democrats and Immigrants: the Grand Evasion

David Bolton
The War on Drugs is a War on Ourselves

Joshua Frank
Challenging Hillary

Jeffery R. Webber
Evo Morales' Historic May Day: Bolivia Nationalizes Gas!

Website of the Day
Happy Birthday, Pete Seeger!

 

May 2, 2006

Evelyn Pringle
Gouge and Profit: Will Big Oil Destroy

Tariq Ali
On the Death of Pramoedya Ananta Toer: Indonesia's Greatest Writer
the US Economy?

Saul Landau
Life in the Mekong Delta

Paul Craig Roberts
Endgame for the Constitution

Gary Leupp
"Out of Iraq, Into Darfur?"

Ron Jacobs
May Day in Asheville

Sen. Russell Feingold
Our Presence is Destabilizing Iraq

Anthony Papa
Rush Limbaugh and the Politics of Drug Addiction

Website of the Day
Rainbow Books

 

 

May Day, 2006

Norman Finkelstein
The Israel Lobby: It's Not Either / Or

Christopher Reed
Mercury's Message, 50 Years On

Michael Donnelly
Rummy's Not the Only One Who Should Go: What About the War's Liberal Enablers?

Dave Zirin
A Day Without Pujols

Mike Whitney
The "N' Word: Take Back the Oil Companies!

Gilad Atzmon
Self-Haters Unite!

Missy Comley Beattie
Marching for Peace

Alexander Cockburn
The War on Terror on the Lodi Front

Website of the Day
In Your Face, Mr President

 

April 29 / 30, 2006

Peter Linebaugh
May Day with Heart

Ralph Nader
Break Up the Big Oil Cartel

Robert Bryce
The Scandal of the V-22: It Kills, It Crashes, But It Won't Die

Rev. William Alberts
Praying for Peace or Preying on Peace? Time for People of Faith to Censure Bush

Lee Sustar
Opening a New Movement

John Chuckman
Xenophobia in a Land of Immigrants

Eric Ruder
An Interview with Camilo Meija on the War and Immigrants

Seth Sandronsky
Securing the Homeland for Whom

Ron Jacobs
Neil Young's Call to Arms

Ben Tripp
A Fork in the American Road

Fred Gardner
Forgotten Memories: Personal and Political

Don Monkerud
Corruption Reform in the Age of Abramoff: Not a Roar, But a Whimper

Tommy Stevenson
JazzFest, Tears and the Renewal of New Orleans

Lettrist International
Proposals for Rationally Improving the City of Paris

Contratiempo
Back to the Back of the Yards: the Jungle, 100 Years Later

St. Clair, Vest and D'Antoni
CounterPunch Playlist: What We're LIstening to This Week

Poets' Basement
Engel, Orloski and Guthrie

Website of the Weekend
Survival of the Fattest

 

April 28, 2006

James Ridgeway
What You Won't See in Flight 93, the Film

Ramzy Baroud
Hamas' Impossible Mission

Sarah Knopp
An Interview with Nativo Lopez on the May Day Protests

William S. Lind
Off With His Head!: But Rumsfeld's Should Not be the Only One That Rolls

Werther
Operation Canned Meat and Its Derivatives

April 27, 2006

Winslow T. Wheeler
How Much is the War Costing? How Many US Troops are Really in Iraq?

Robert Fisk
The United States of Israel?

Juan Santos
Immigration Endgame

Robert Jensen
Why Leftists Distrust Liberals

Dave Lindorff
Making America Safer: One Released War Crime Victim at a Time

Jose Pertierra
Honor and Injustice:the Case of the Cuban Five

 

April 26,2006

Robin Philpot
The Rich Life of Jane Jacobs

Sherry Wolf
Democrats, Their Apologists and Abortion: the Jig is Up

Pratyush Chandra
Nepal: a Saga of Compromise and Struggle

Joshua Frank
Zig-Zagging Through the War With John Kerry

Gary Leupp
The Neo-Cons and Iran: No Negotiations

Bill Quigley
Katrina: Eight Months Later

 

 

April 25, 2006

Gary Leupp
Wilkinson Speaks Out About the Coming War on Iran

Paul Craig Roberts
The World is Uniting Against the Bush Imperium

Linda S. Heard
Is the US Waging Israel's Wars?: the Prophecy of Oded Yinon

Ralph Nader
Political Science: Gingrich, "Futurism" and the Abolition of the OTA

Mike Whitney
Preparing for the Economic Typhoon

Michael Donnelly
Lutherans Betray Michigan's Loon Lake Wetlands for Pieces of Silver

Sharon Smith
Breathing New Life Into May Day

Website of the Day
SDS Ver. 2

 

April 24, 2006

Tim Wise
What Kind of Card is Race?

John Stanton
Strike Iran, Watch Pakistan and Turkey Fall

Dave Lindorff
Dangerous Times Ahead

Steve Shore
Berlusconi Defeated: The Long Wait is Over ... Or Is It?

Amadou Deme
Hotel Rwanda: Setting the Record Straight

Mickey Z.
15 Minutes of Radical Fame: America Meets Bill Blum and Ward Churchill

Ralph Nader
Lee Raymond's Unconscionable Platinum Parachute

Alexander Cockburn
Obama's Game

Website of the Day
Too Stupid to Be President?

 

 

 

 

Subscribe Online

Weekend Edition
May 20 / 21, 2006

Exposing Military Incompetence

"United 93": a Review

By SAUL LANDAU and FARRAH HASSEN

FAA: "Hi. Boston Center TMU [Traffic Management Unit], we have a problem here. We have a hijacked aircraft headed towards New York, and we needsomeone to scramble some F-16s or something up there, help us out.

NEADS: Is this real-world or exercise?

FAA: No, this is not an exercise, not a test." (9/11 Commission Report, pg. 20)

Yes, no exercise or test for the almost 3,000 people who died on 9/11/01! Scrambling F-16s doesn't sound like much of a request, given that the taxpayers shell out over $600 billion for "defense" (counting Iraq, Afghanistan and intelligence).

But military ground commanders could not communicate with those who send jets "scrambling." Indeed, NORAD's Northeast Air Defense Sector (NEADS) received notice of American 11's hijacking 9 minutes before it struck the World Trade Center's north tower.

Minutes later, millions around the world would watch United 175 hit New York's second WTC tower. The President - enthralled in the aftermath of his literary ecstasy, My Pet Goat, which he read to Florida schoolchildren - remained unreachable; the Vice President, desperately seeking shelter.

The Air Force, occupied with maneuvers, finally freed two unarmed F-15s. But they could neither locate nor shoot down the other two purloined aircraft, one of which hit the Pentagon. Subsequently, two other armed jets flew in the wrong direction. American 77, the third plane, hit the Pentagon. A fourth, United 93, the subject of a new movie, crashed in rural Pennsylvania, killing all 37 aboard.

A docu-drama based on available facts, "United 93" shows an expensive, bloated military establishment, lacking the most minimal capability of responding to security needs. Are you listening, Senator Evan Bayh (D-IN)? He urged Democrats to defeat Republicans "on their own ground" by showing they were tougher than Bush on security issues. (Washington Post, May 9) Instead, we suggest they see the film, which should convince rational people to demand a forceful reduction of the "defense" budget.

The 9/11 Commission Report and previously published stories also indicated that the communication-challenged "intelligence community" failed to coordinate and then interpret intelligence that could have prevented the 9/11 attacks.

In mid 2006, Americans should feel less safe than they did five years ago. The dead and wounded multiply in "liberated" Iraq and Afghanistan. Christopher D. Baker, a man with past criminal convictions, "won" for his Shirlington Limousine and Transportation Inc., a $25 million contract with the Department of Homeland Security to provide expensive limousines to senior officials. "Civil servants" used the limos to go to hooker appointments and elite poker games. The May 7 New York Times reported that FBI agents have interviewed Shirlington employees who drove "prostitutes to hotel poker parties" attended by former California Congressman Randy "Duke" Cunningham and other Republican notables.

Thus, yet another shocking scandal characterizes the "security anxiety age," where TSA airport screeners at checkpoints play musical chairs with plastic trays filled with shoes, cell phones and laptops. Despite routine "wanding" of suspicious passengers, Government Accountability Office investigators, who conducted tests at 21 airports between October 2005 and January 2006, passed through airport "security" with bomb-making materials in tow. (MSNBC, March 17, 2006)

Democrats fear that if they challenge Bush's vacuous war on terrorism, he might label them "weak." Meanwhile, Super Spender Bush reveals himself as President Incompetent, unable to direct the evacuation of people from New Orleans or help them find refuge after Hurricane Katrina destroyed their homes. His ineptitude in Iraq and Afghanistan costs taxpayers nearly $10 billion a month. (Washington Post, April 20, 2006) His Administration's plan for a predicted bird flu pandemic: throw the problem to the bankrupt local authorities.

In light of Bush disasters, why would Americans fear to face a movie -- a much-needed reality check? "United 93" transcends predictable Hollywood recreations of doomed flights. It shows tragedy arising from banality; how high-tech "security" evaporates, literally, from the radar screen when confronted by everyday reality ­ hijackers flying jumbo jets below the radar.

Director Paul Greengrass ("Bloody Sunday," "The Bourne Supremacy") dissects the impenetrable façade of security lingo by focusing on everyday behavior: people involved in all aspects of the tragic event, those on the ground and on board the planes.

The opening scene shows four hijackers played by Khalid Abdalla, Lewis Alsamari, Omar Berdouni and Jamie Harding reciting morning prayers in a hotel room. They bow and invoke God, hardly stereotyped terrorists; rather, fervent men completing routine ritual. Then, one decrees: "It's time."

Travelers at Newark airport have no inclination that 9/11/01 will become an unforgettable day. They maneuver through airport security, chat on cell phones and read newspapers as they wait for United 93 to depart. The benign-looking hijackers sit unnoticed in the same waiting lounge.

In FAA headquarters and a military control center, the scenario unfolds. 46 minutes after take off, four men take over the airline. The 9/11 Commission report says that one hijacker announced: "Ladies and Gentlemen: Here the captain, please sit down keep remaining sitting. We have a bomb on board. So sit." (pg. 12)

Rapid cuts juxtapose shock and confusion at FAA's control center in Herndon, Virginia (Ben Sliney plays himself as operations manager) and at NEADS in Rome, New York. The scenes reveal serious communication problems. Those who must act on the hijackings cannot reach commanders who provide ROE (Rules of Engagement) for shooting down passenger planes that could hit other buildings. Military officials, in turn, couldn't reach Bush or Cheney for orders. Instead, a bureaucratic morass encases those trying to respond to planes crashing populated buildings.

The film doesn't show Bush continuing to read My Pet Goat after the second plane hit the WTC. But, we do see FAA flight controllers watching CNN to get late news. Indeed, archival footage of the flaming twin towers reveals the air traffic controllers' shock. "Jesus Christ," one mutters. "Holy shit," says another, "we haven't had a hijacked plane in over 30 years." This recorded material establishes the dramatic context for unfolding the hijacking story. Once the hijackers seized United 93, flight attendants and passengers surreptitiously phoned friends and relatives and discovered that other hijacked craft had hit the WTC.

The film's actors don't seem to act. The "bad guys" who prayed and slipped box cutters into their belts look effortlessly determined, not cocky and self-assured. Later, one sneaks into the airplane bathroom and assembles an ersatz bomb.

They murder the pilots and one flight attendant, but Greengrass doesn't spatter the screen with blood. Instead, he presents driven men overcoming fear through faith that God will reward their actions.

Several stunned passengers gradually recover enough wit to plan to retake the plane. As the 9/11 Report mentions, one of the passengers ended a phone call with a loved one by saying, "Everyone's running up to first class. I got to go. Bye." (p. 13)

These individuals are not Bruce Willis or Tom Cruise characters who risk their lives to prevent 93 from hitting its Washington target and thus save their country; rather, these passengers revolted because they realized that retaking and landing the plane had become their chance to survive and see their families. They provided the United States with its only resistance to the hijacking of four airplanes ­ three of which did immense damage.
The film contrasts their expressions of hope with other passengers' unwillingness to accept reality. One insists: "We can negotiate with them."

Ultimately, "United 93" illustrates how a high-tech military could not defend the country. So, why waste hundreds of billions of dollars on "security" that offers no security against primitively armed individuals ­ not nations?

The February 6, 2006 DOD Quadrennial Defense Review Report purportedly responds to the defects shown in the reenactments in "United 93." "To strengthen forces to defeat terrorist networks, the Department will increase Special Operations Forces by 15% and the number of Special Forces Battalions by one-third. U.S. Special Operations Command (U.S. SOCOM) will establish the Marine Corps Special Operations Command. The Air Force will establish an Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Squadron under U.S. SOCOMThe Department will also expand Psychological Operations and Civil Affairs units by 3,700 personnel, a 33% increase." (pg. 5)

These recommendations will not deter attacks against giant shopping malls, railroad stations or crowded office buildings. Defense against terrorism has little to do with military hardware or high technology. With all the NSA monitoring of phones and CIA's signal intelligence operations, no Bush administration official recognized the imminence of the 9/11 attack. Nor did high-tech weapons and Special Forces prove capable of winning previous engagements in Korea or Vietnam; nor tame Afghanistan or Iraq.

Rather than professing their ability to do a "better job" than the Republicans on the "war on terror," the Democrats must dare to call for the dismantling of the real emperor ­ the military-scientific-industrial complex -- that has wasted our fortunes and given so little in return.

Saul Landau is an Institute for Policy Studies Fellow.

Farrah Hassen is a Seymour Melman fellow of the Institute for Policy Studies. She can be reached at fhuisclos1944@aol.com


 



 

 

 

Now Available
from CounterPunch Books!
The Case Against Israel
By Michael Neumann

Click Here to Order Michael Neumann's Devastating Rebuttal of Alan Dershowitz

WHAT'S INSIDE
Grand Theft Pentagon:
Tales of Greed and Profiteering in the War on Terror

by Jeffrey St. Clair

 

CounterPunch Speakers Bureau

Sick of sit-on-the-Fence speakers, tongue-tied and timid? CounterPunch Editors Alexander Cockburn and Jeffrey St Clair are available to speak forcefully on ALL the burning issues, as are other CounterPunchers seasoned in stump oratory. Call CounterPunch Speakers Bureau, 1-800-840-3683. Or email beckyg@counterpunch.org.


The Book on 9/11 the White House Denounced as "ABSOLUTE GARBAGE"