June
19 , 2006
Al Franken's War
Tears of a Clown
By JOHN
WALSH
Last
Friday, June 17, was not a good day for the Al Franken radio show.
Al was “down,” sounding like he was on the verge of
tears, not such a good disposition for a comic. It seems his listeners
had let loose on him when he proclaimed that he “agreed with
Bush” on the question of withdrawal from Iraq. That is, Franken
does not support the Murtha proposal to depart posthaste and call
it “redeployment”; in fact Franken does not support
any timetable for withdrawal at all. The emails and phone calls
apparently poured in after this most explicit declaration yet of
his long-held position. Here is the email I sent after hearing him
say, in the course of declaring himself a disciple of Bush, that
his radio program was the site of genuine “debate” about
what to do in Iraq:
Dear
Al,
Today
you did not tell the truth about the War on Iraq. You have never
had a real debate on your program about immediate withdrawal,
which is the position of over 70% of the Dem Party - although
not that of the moneyed Dem Establishment (e.g., Hillary Clinton
and Harry Reid) to which you seem to be very much in thrall. (By
the way, this shows that the Democratic Party is not democratic
(small “d”).)
You
were pro-war before the war and now you remain pro-war. Do you
know how that strikes the ear when you talk about your children
who, like the Bush kids, do not go to fight whereas other less
privileged kids, one of them the daughter of friends of mine,
do?
Why
you take this manifestly absurd position is unclear. You are a
smart guy, even though you went to Harvard (joke). So what is
up? Is it ambition for public office that leads you to take the
Establishment position? Or is it loyalty to Israel? I do not know
your position on Israel; but you have never, to my knowledge,
discussed the oppression and plight of the Palestinians.
Along
those lines you have never had a discussion of the Mearscheimer
and Walt paper, and you must be familiar with it.
So
by omission you lie. And hence I have to stick with my piece in
CounterPunch.com, from about a year back, “Al Franken is
a Big Fat Phony.”
Perhaps
some day you will catch up to Randi Rhodes who, after years of
hanging up on callers who advocated immediate withdrawal from
Iraq, has finally come around. And she is finally talking about
Third Parties without the pressure of which the Dems will never
change.
jw
p.s.
Why not have on Justin Raimondo of antiwar.com or Kevin Zeese
or Ralph Nader to discuss the anti war position? Or have two of
them. You and Richard Perle or your frequent guest, Norm Ornstein,
or some other reactionary from AEI could take the other side.
In
fact there was apparently such a furor from many others that Franken
opened up the phones, something he rarely does now, and he took
all of three (3!) calls. The final one came from a retired military
guy in Minnesota who made it clear he was for getting out of Iraq
pronto and told Franken that he was disappointed in him. The caller
also noted that he had two friends, both conservatives, a retired
policeman and a firefighter, who did not vote in the last election
but would have voted for Kerry had he been against the war. That
was the final call. Franken went back to his guest list of minor
celebrities and Democratic Party hacks.
Why
was Franken shaken by all this? Does he see a threat to his run
for Senate in Minnesota? Does he perhaps have some twinge of guilt
over the hundreds of thousands killed or maimed in Iraq while he
calls for fighting on, with his own kids, who are of military age,
nice and safe? Maybe his hypocrisy was too much for him to bear
for a few minutes with the barrage coming at him. But he was soon
back on track – like Luisa in the Fantastiks.
Franken
reaches a lot of people and so he has a lot of responsibility. He
must be counted as one voice shoring up support for the war especially
among Democrats. It is time for antiwar groups in Minnesota to look
for a candidate to run against Franken for Senate in 2008. It would
be pathetic to reward his complicity in the war effort with a seat
in the U.S. Senate.
John
Walsh can be reached at John.Endwar@gmail.com.
Lest
his comments above on Randi Rhodes be misconstrued, she still has
a long way to go.
|