Antiglobalism's Jewish Problem
Jewish organizations are also becoming more of a presence in the
antiglobalization movement. Last year, there were fears that the
Johannesburg-hosted World Summit on Sustainable Development would turn
into a replay of the ill-fated 2001 U.N. World Conference Against Racism
in Durban, where anti-Semitic rhetoric culminated in a draft resolution
adopted by the NGO forum singling out Israel as guilty of "genocide."
The SWC urged 180 ecological organizations planning to attend
Johannesburg to ensure the conference stayed on message. The responses
were largely positive, reflecting the frustration of many Third World
NGOs who felt that the controversy at Durban had overshadowed vital
issues on their agendas.
And then there are the Jews within the antiglobalization movement
itself. Many are drawn to the movement for the same reason that Jews
have always been disproportionately represented in campaigns for social
justice: the principle of tikkun olam (repairing the world). It imparts
a commitment not only to care for the Jewish community, but for all of
society. The antiglobalization activists who are Jewish carry a unique
burden in that they are made to feel like strangers even though they are
passionately devoted to safeguarding the environment, advocating human
rights, and promoting economic equality. But rather than abandoning the
movement, they seek to wrest the agenda from the extremists who would
exclude them. A measure of their success could be seen in the final day
of the 2003 World Social Forum in Porto Alegre. While street protesters
waved their swastikas, a small group of Jewish and Palestinian peace
activists organized a series of workshops, funded by local Jewish and
Palestinian communities in Brazil. The result was a joint statement,
read to 20,000 cheering activists, calling for "peace, justice, and
sovereignty for our peoples," and a Palestinian state existing side by
side with Israel.
Some Jewish groups sympathetic to many of the antiglobalization
movement's goals have mistakenly chosen to remain on the outside. Jewish
voices need to be raised when the shouting of the militants threatens to
drown out other issues. And tikkun olam imparts a mandate to counter
demagogues in the developing world who scapegoat Jews and Israel as an
excuse to perpetuate systems that keep their nations mired in poverty.
In that spirit, Rabbi Joseph Klein told his congregation at a synagogue
in Michigan last June, "We will have to develop a strategy that allows
us to participate in the effort to bring social equity and economic
justice to all people, while at the same time distancing ourselves from
these newest purveyors of the Protocols." He concluded his sermon by
quoting from Pirkei Avot, the Jewish book of ethics: "It is not for you
to complete the work, but neither are you free to withdraw from it."
Mark Strauss is a senior editor at Foreign Policy.
Source:
Foreign Policy
Rights: © 2003 ForeignPolicy.com. Reprinted by permission from the November/December 2003 issue of Foreign Policy.
Related Articles:
The Poor Like Globalization
Globalization with Few Discontents?
A Fair Globalization: Creating Opportunities for All
A Trusteeship for Palestine?
Comment on this article.
|