2006 St Helens 42-12 Huddersfield
2005 Hull FC 25-24 Leeds Rhinos
2004 St Helens 32-16 Wigan Warriors
2003 Bradford Bulls 22-20 Leeds Rhinos
2002 Wigan Warriors 21-12 St Helens
2001 St Helens 13-6 Bradford Bulls
2000 Bradford Bulls 24-18 Leeds Rhinos
1999 Leeds Rhinos 52-16 London Broncos
1998 Sheffield Eagles 17-8 Wigan Warriors
1997 St Helens 32-22 Bradford Bulls
1996 St Helens 40-32 Bradford Bulls
1995 Wigan 30-10 Leeds
1994 Wigan 26-16 Leeds
1993 Wigan 20-14 Widnes
1992 Wigan 28-12 Castleford
1991 Wigan 13-8 St Helens
1990 Wigan 36-14 Warrington
1989 Wigan 27-0 St Helens
1988 Wigan 32-12 Halifax
1987 Halifax 19-18 St Helens
1986 Castleford 15-14 Hull KR
1985 Wigan 28-24 Hull
1984 Widnes 19-6 Wigan
1983 Featherstone 14-12 Hull
1982 Hull 18-9 Widnes (First game: 14-14)
1981 Widnes 18-9 Hull KR
1980 Hull KR 10-5 Hull
1979 Widnes 12-3 Wakefield Trinity
1978 Leeds 14-12 St Helens
1977 Leeds 16-7 Widnes
1976 St Helens 20-5 Widnes
1975 Widnes 14-7 Warrington
1974 Warrington 24-9 Featherstone
1973 Featherstone 33-14 Bradford
1972 St Helens 16-13 Leeds
1971 Leigh 24-7 Leeds
1970 Castleford 7-2 Wigan
1969 Castleford 11-6 Salford
1968 Leeds 11-10 Wakefield Trinity
1967 Featherstone 17-12 Barrow
1966 St Helens 21-2 Wigan
1965 Wigan 20-16 Hunslet
1964 Widnes 13-5 Hull KR
1963 Wakefield Trinity 25-10 Wigan
1962 Wakefield Trinity 12-6 Huddersfield
1961 St Helens 12-6 Wigan
1960 Wakefield Trinity 38-5 Hull
1959 Wigan 30-13 Hull
1958 Wigan 13-9 Workington
1957 Leeds 9-7 Barrow
1956 St Helens 13-2 Halifax
1955 Barrow 21-12 Workington Town
1954 Warrington 8-4 Halifax (First game: 4-4)
1953 Huddersfield 15-10 St Helens
1952 Workington 18-10 Featherstone
1951 Wigan 10-0 Barrow
1950 Warrington 19-0 Widnes
1949 Bradford 12-0 Halifax
1948 Wigan 8-3 Bradford
1947 Bradford 8-4 Leeds
1946 Wakefield Trinity 13-12 Wigan
1945 Huddersfield 13-9 Bradford (6-5, 7-4)
1944 Bradford 8-3 Wigan (8-0, 0-3)
1943 Dewsbury 16-15 Leeds (0-6, 16-9)
1942 Leeds 15-10 Halifax
1941 Leeds 19-2 Halifax
1940 No competition
1939 Halifax 20-3 Salford
1938 Salford 7-4 Barrow
1937 Widnes 18-5 Keighley
1936 Leeds 18-2 Warrington
1935 Castleford 11-8 Huddersfield
1934 Hunslet 11-5 Widnes
1933 Huddersfield 21-17 Warrington
1932 Leeds 11-8 Swinton
1931 Halifax 22-8 York
1930 Widnes 10-3 St Helens
1929 Wigan 13-2 Dewsbury
1928 Swinton 5-3 Warrington
1927 Oldham 26-7 Swinton
1926 Swinton 9-3 Oldham
1925 Oldham 16-3 Hull KR
1924 Wigan 21-4 Oldham
1923 Leeds 28-3 Hull
1922 Rochdale Hornets 10-9 Hull
1921 Leigh 13-0 Halifax
1920 Huddersfield 21-10 Wigan
1916-19 No competition
1915 Huddersfield 37-3 St Helens
1914 Hull 6-0 Wakefield Trinity
1913 Huddersfield 9-5 Warrington
1912 Dewsbury 8-5 Oldham
1911 Broughton 4-0 Wigan
1910 Leeds 26-12 Hull (First game: 7-7)
1909 Wakefield Trinity 17-0 Hull
1908 Hunslet 14-0 Hull
1907 Warrington 17-3 Oldham
1906 Bradford 5-0 Salford
1905 Warrington 6-0 Hull KR
1904 Halifax 8-3 Warrington
1903 Halifax 7-0 Salford
1902 Broughton 25-0 Salford
1901 Batley 6-0 Warrington
1900 Swinton 16-8 Salford
1899 Oldham 19-9 Hunslet
1898 Batley 7-0 Bradford
1897 Batley 10-3 St Helens